Volvo and Autoliv team up with Nvidia for self-driving cars
Swiss Trade Balance May 2017: Foreign Trade is Strengthening #SwissMacro
ACDF Architecture completes home for two sisters beside Canadas Lake Memphremagog:
World in Pictures
Germans not opposed to same sex marriage
Anti #Maduro protests in #Caracas #Venezuela #AA
The automated teller machine or ATM turns 50 today: Happy Birthday!!
Margaret Thatcher knew that without security there is no prosperity
RT @LPtravelnews: Revealed: the top 20 countries for best quality of life in the world
Governor Johos Call Stopped Me from Dumping Zari - Singer Diamond: #Tanzania
Our @Fintech5Podcast w/ @GCGodfrey who is keynoting today at #Money2020Europe #money2020EU
I had forgotten about this. So thoroughly weird.
Sweden, UK Denmark have high poverty rates but low persistent poverty - #NotSoBad @ONS
Justices in Tigo Shares Case Refuse to Opt Out: #Tanzania
Financial Support Lures Women to Disclose HIV Status: #Uganda
Questions and answers about the #US Supreme Courts decision on #Trumps #travelban
The children of Camorra gangsters
Bungee instructors terrible English blamed for girl leaping to death
What happens now after the U.S. Supreme Courts travel ban ruling?
Nobel Prize–winning economists come out against Senate GOP healthcare bill
It is high time to localise the energy transition
US judge blocks deportation of hundreds of Iraqis held in immigration sweeps
27 June 1905: Russian battleship Potemkin in the hands of mutinous crew.
How Israel gains from Egypt-Saudi Red Sea islands deal
NAFTA’s Market Growth Increases to 21 Month High in June. #SMI
Bitcoin, Ether lead digital currency slide from highs via @CamiRusso
Sleeping woman swallowed by sinkhole in central #China - her bedroom collapsed in heavy rain
Will some things change with newer generations? Today’s cartoon by @elchicotriste0:
Nigeria, Mexico Trade Volume Hits U.S.$600 Million #Nigeria
South Africa Takes Steps to Halt Spread of Bird Flu #SouthAfrica
Athens slams Tirana square makeover as ‘concealing irredentism’
Namuganza and Nantaba - Who Should Museveni Beat With His Stick?: #Uganda
Ugandan Singer Bobi Wine Arrested in Kasangati #Uganda
German 10y yields jump to 0.28% on hawkish Draghi speech.
Trump son-in-law Kushner hires prominent trial lawyer: NYT
Boxer crabs go to crazy lengths to keep a pair of pom-poms
The 25 most beloved CEOs in America
New CBO report could doom GOP healthcare bill:
U.S. threatens Syria, says Assad is planning chemical weapons attack
What price attention? How data harvesters are changing our minds
European law permits them to be thrown out now.
Train #travel tips for all coming to #France this #summer from @TheLocalFrance
There are now 2.1 million apps in the iPhone App Store — up from 500 in 2008.
Minerals produced by Base Titanium are used as inputs to a variety of diverse industries and products.
Does One Belt, One Road make commercial sense?
Majorities around the world think of Trump as arrogant, intolerant and dangerous
Refugee Summit Leaves Uganda Still in Need Over U.S.$ 1 Billion: #EastAfrica
*DRAGHI: DEFLATION RISK NOW PRICED OUT OF INFLA EXPECTATIONS
To Elisa from Italy Thanks for the excellent tiramisu! #gratitudeproject cc @OxfordAOPP
South western France placed on alert for violent storms
US judge blocks deportation of hundreds of Iraqis held in immigration sweeps
Top US senator threatens to block arms sales to GCC countries over Qatar row
Kurodas still buying Japanese bonds
Denmark is killing Tesla (and other electric cars)
Stormy conditions with flash flooding and hail will threaten #Germany into Wednesday:
10 SP 500 health-care companies with the highest percentages of “buy” ratings:
Witnesses Report Sinking Ship After Explosion: #Somalia
Global business confidence remains very strong in June. #SMI
#Norways $960bn sovereign wealth fund urges banks to disclose #carbonfootprint of loans
A video of the explosion in Kiev that killed a military man as he was driving a Mercedes
H/T @GuyJohnsonTV
Draghi: a tapering is not a tightening. Say what you want, the President rocks at communication.
Israel bombs Gaza after rocket fire
Top CNN employees resign after network retracts Trump-Russia story
#Norway heads the table for the availability of charging positions for plug-in EVs #OOTT
Museveni Cancels Multi-Billion Chinese Mining Deal Over Bribe: #Uganda
Swede Held by Al-Qaida Freed After 6 Years: #Mali
Oh hello @ConversationCA
Bloomberg View: Europes banking union fails its latest test via @BV
Advisers concerned over poor communications with FCA
Social media giants step up fight against extremist content
Albanias Socialists take full control of parliament for first time since communisms end
Russias Rosneft targets bigger gas output, lower costs
The Italian bank CEO winning big from collapse of Veneto lenders
Equity and bond investors are split on the prospects for Baidu
Swede Held by Al-Qaida Freed After 6 Years: #Mali
Nice visualization of Chinas recent deleveraging efforts, via Deutsche Bank:
RUSI Director @kvonhippel welcoming delegates and CGS to the #RUSILWC
Europe was never keen on Bush, loved Obama, hates Trump
With Alphabet, Google faces a daunting challenge: organizing itself
China’s latest logistics IPO is hard to unpack
California to list glyphosate as cancer-causing; Monsanto vows fight
Did Corbyn have the right approach to Brexit after all?
Chinese Premier Li says China will meet it growth goals and pledges free trade support
School secession is segregation
Lightning bolts illuminate the sky above Annaberg-Buchholz in Saxony, Germany on June 22nd (DPA/Andre März)
Japan Pension Fund Manager Shows the Struggle for Abenomics: via @business @tomredjp
Armyworm Still Wreaks Havoc On Maize: #Ethiopia
Inside #Monopolys secret war against the Third Reich: @eurogamer #longreads
Economy Min Papadimitriou invites foreign entrepreneurs to #invest in food sector #Greece
#Colombias #FARC disarmament confirmed by United Nations
White House: Assad is potentially preparing another chemical attack in Syria
Pakistan’s illegal kidney trade is propped up by poor and wealthy
Trump urges @narendramodi to relax Indian trade barriers in maiden meeting
Time to stock up those Norwegian salmons.
Eleven of them now
Heineken offers to sell pubs to ease competition worries on Punch Taverns takeover
Mexico: Market Growth Index increases to the highest level in 17 months in June. #SMI
Throw a few more cajas on the pile
Museveni to Face Off With Besigye in Kyadondo: #Uganda
#Russia Corporate Profits at RUB3.2T
Arnold Lobels “Frog and Toad” endures as an amphibious celebration of same-sex love:
U.S. threatens Syria, says Assad is planning chemical weapons attack
And you thought the SP 500 Index was expensive! #smallcaps via @Callum_Thomas
Beyond Demographics: A New Way of Looking at Cities
Fires being brought under control in #Huelva #Andalucia #Environment
haha, amazing that ZeroHedge I love Dick take place in Marfa, Texas @alexandrascaggs
Climate change will make your coffee cost more and taste worse
Players Remember Marc Vivien Foe As They Leave Russia: #Cameroon
#Italy Business Confidence at 107.3
#Italy Consumer Confidence at 106.4
How humans can stay ahead of machines, according to Alibaba founder Jack Ma via @CNBC
Dems hold sit in on Capitol steps to protest GOP ObamaCare repeal bill
#Bulgaria Tourist Arrivals year-on-year at 7.2%
Will Tanzania Keep Street Named After Wanyama ? #Kenya #Tanzania
Security software player Trend Micro launches $100m venture fund
#Germany tells Erdogans bodyguards to stay away from #Hamburg #G20
Tag your best friend tell them what you value most about your friendship!
A timeline of Colombia’s peace process.
Children in Stalingrad hiding from bombing by German planes. 1942. Photographer L.I. Konov.
Highway in the sky! Chongqing residents drive on road built on rooftop
#Myanmar troops on high alert after spate of attacks blamed on #Rohingya insurgents
Investors await Bank of England report and Yellen appearance in London
Canadian soldier becomes first female infantry officer to captain UK queens guard
Brazil Food Price Index for June: 151.5, previous: 154.9 (change: -2.2%) #WPI
DOF Subsea wins pair of new contracts
Former PM Valls quits Socialists to join Macrons army of MPs in parliament
Greek owners stump up extra cash for state budget
Golden Energy awarded PSV contract by Total
#Libya #Libyaoil Petroleum Economist map of Libyas current oil/military dispositions tangle.
IN PICTURES: Modi meets Trump - Click
MUST WATCH: Uber vehicle set on fire as antibodies take to the streets -
Fox News reporter to Sean Spicer: The American people expect transparency
Ugandan Muslim Leader Tells Govt to Spend Less On Weapons #Kenya #Tanzania #Uganda
#ECB to stay loose for a very long time: HSBCs Major via @markets
Former Prime Minister Summoned By Police Over Uknown Reasons: #Tanzania
#Ethiopia: East Africas new economic power
Kenya reconciliation faces major election test: (@irinnews)
Troops in Myanmars Rakhine on high alert after killings of Rohingya
PES president: Unlike EPP, socialists do not impose decisions on member parties
Two arrested in Swiss anti-terror operation
Police arrest drug mule colleague
Sanders ignores Fox News question about FBI probe of his wife
Boy travels 230km from Morocco to Spain clinging under bus
guys weve been found out
Chinese blockchain salaries @ReutersGraphics
U.S. to list China among worst human trafficking offenders -sources
Worlds biggest wealth fund is refusing to be silenced: @ScouseView via @gadfly
One in five flights to popular holiday destinations are delayed by more than 30 minutes
Zimbabwe Warriors Massacre Mozambiques Os Mambas #Mozambique #Zimbabwe
U.S. judge halts deportation of Iraqis nationwide
Trolls Penis to be re-erected in Norway
Fresh landslide at site of disaster in #China
Good News as Worlds Whale Population Increases: #SouthAfrica
#JohnnyDepp may face perjury charge in #Australia over war on terrier
China customs mulls increasing checks on #thermalcoal imports, impeding flow, traders say
Burning bones helped prove that women were poisoned by glowing paint
At platform 9-3/4, Harry Potter fans mark 20 years of magic
The trash heap phenomenon
Nestles first activist investor may trigger more divestments
PM steps in in row between ministry and trash collectors
#Sweden Balance of #Trade at SEK 2.8B
Celebrate Labours electoral success - but dont forget the working class, writes @lisanandy
FBI questions Trump campaign adviser multiple times in Russia investigation: report
60-year-old Arkansas prison escapee recaptured after more than three decades on the run.
#Sweden PPI year-on-year at 7.2%
Founder of fintech platform being used in 95 countries shares his expansion strategy
The passive investing revolution is leaving opportunities in its wake @MylesUdland
#Sweden PPI month-on-month at 0.0%
Global yield curve flattening continues. German 2s/10s yield spread drops below 86bps.
Amendment for hirings in municipal sanitation services tabled in parliament #Greece
FM @NikosKotzias to participate in conference on #Cyprus issue in #Switzerland #Greece
RT if you owned this ball...
Debenhams warns of market volatility as sales fall
Germany brands Arab states’ Qatar demands ‘very provocative’
Tell @Apple, @SamsungMobile, @LGUSAMobile to give us repairable and long lasting products!
Want a laptop thats easy to repair? Look beyond Apple and Microsoft
Boniface Mwangi, Betty Kyallo, Victor Wanyama Scoop Social Media Awards: #Kenya
The 9,000-year-old history of booze, in photos
Ini adalah lokasi jebolnya tanggul lubang galian tambang batubara di Kalimantan Selatan beberapa hari lalu.
Most Australian residents born overseas are now from Asia, rather than Europe
Janchart takes its second handy bulker this year
Alec Baldwin will return to SNL as Trump
Merkel softens her opposition to gay marriage
Frenchwoman on trial for helping migrant lover smuggle into Britain
Save the Whale Campaigns Working, South African Summit Hears #SouthAfrica
Albanias Socialists take full control of parliament for first time since communisms end
Follow the Margaret Thatcher Conference on Security with CapX
The @WhiteHouse claims Bashar al-Assad planning Syrian chemical weapons
Police fired tear gas at LGBTQ supporters to enforce a ban on Pride parades in Istanbul
Another U.S. tech company shuns #Brexit fears with London office via @NateLanxon
Commission laments member states’ lack of ambition on energy saving laws
Why Nigerias Akinwunmi Adesina Won 2017 World Food Prize: #Nigeria
A little to the left. @roweafrs latest cartoon. For more: #auspol
Where the arts really make a difference might surprise you
Donald Trump, please kill Americans not more Syrians, signed- MAGA dipshits
Israel bombs Gaza after rocket fire
June 27, 1941 – Romania launched a pogrom in the city of Iaşi, resulting in the murder of at least 13,266 Jews.
No, the Fed didnt make a mistake by hiking interest rates via @BV
Huckabee hits Senate GOP healthcare bill: This isnt what Trump campaigned on
The ATM turns 50 - It all began with a newfangled bank machine in Enfield
British consumer confidence is now back at post-referendum levels
Last time short selling of #Lonmin was this high, it had an emergency rights issue #platinum #METL
UK royals to receive tax funding boost
Wall Street really hates giving any stock a ‘sell’ rating
Theres a safe and secure way for Chinese millennials to buy homes abroad
At platform 9-3/4, Harry Potter fans mark 20 years of magic
Italian Banking – Domino’s Just Started Falling - What is coming next?
@Renegade_Inc
@tracyalloway
Why Goldman Sachs pays such a high savings account rate
Fly Hi: Marine travel in the digital age #shipping
Peter Montalto: Rand to trade stronger, for now, but huge shocks lie in wait
Best and worst broadband speeds in UK revealed - but how does your area fare?
#Denmark Retail Sales month-on-month at 0.5%
Deutsche Bank growing more cautious on Gulf assets... Watch this space.
#Fintech in Hong Kong 2017 Startup and Ecosystem Report #vc
#Denmark Retail Sales year-on-year at 1.6%
Cyber Threat - Nigeria, 4 African Nations Among Worlds 10 Riskiest Countries: #Nigeria
13 Chinese sentenced to death for drug offences as thousands look on in public trial
Trump officially nominates new FBI director
Korean ports to offer alternative maritime power #shipping
GeoSea secures offshore wind installation work - Splash 247
How Singapore makes biodiversity an important part of urban life
Rowan lays off another 50 workers due to drillship cancellation
GeoSea secures offshore wind installation work
RT @shipping_latest: VLCC ordering scales heights not seen since 2008 #shipping
Chinas growth looks like it may already have hit its peak for 2017
EU to charge PPC with abusing position
It’s no coincidence
Ecuadors President grants pardon to 4 indigenous activists.
A storm chaser talks about the most dangerous storms of her career
Boxship master lays the blame for deadly collision on USS Fitzgerald officers #shipping
JAXPORT harbour-deepening project approved #shipping
Were creating a Facebook group to talk about American politics and we need your help
@thefreakywave reacts to news that the lifespan of ships is set to get younger #shippingnews
White House: Assad regime preparing for another chemical attack in #Syria -
Ugandan Scholar Seeking Kenyan Lover Boy to Marry Her: #Uganda
Lula leads Brazil presidential poll ahead of court sentence
MMA vs tai chi group brawl stopped by police in Shanghai
Blue Apron is among the IPOs estimated to bring in an aggregate $1.1 billion this week
Liquidation of Italian banks shows limits of banking resolution rules
This 3D-knit chair is made from a single piece of technical fabric
Key GOP senator: I dont have enough information to vote for ObamaCare repeal
Spacex had two successful launches in one weekend and has new titanium fins able to handle…
Cold, hard cash remains king in the digital age for one simple reason
Kyiv police confirms: driver is dead via @NPU_GOV_UA
How Italy’s bank rescue rewards investors’ political bets
Drones arent missiles, so dont regulate them like they are:


Francine McKenna
KPMG takes its turn with a Big 4 -sized scandal
2 months ago




 

“We are not enemies, but friends. We must not be enemies. Though passion may have strained, it must not break our bonds of affection. The mystic chords of memory will swell when again touched, as surely they will be, by the better angels of our nature.” Abraham Lincoln

 

It’s pretty bad in the Big 4. Again.

My colleagues Dave Michaels and Michael Rapoport at the WSJ got a scoop last week that five partners and another audit employee at KPMG had been fired, including a Vice Chairman who is was the top US audit partner and the former national managing partner for audit quality and professional practice.

KPMG Fires Partners Over Leak of Audit Regulator’s Confidential Plan

Big Four accounting firm improperly received information about which audits PCAOB planned to review

Five KPMG LLP partners, including the head of its audit practice, were fired after the Big Four accounting firm improperly obtained information about which audits its regulator planned to inspect, the company said.

The PCAOB also fired one employee who media reports said was allegedly the leaker.

KPMG issued a statement:

The firm learned in late February, from an internal source, that an individual who had joined KPMG from the PCAOB subsequently received confidential information from a then-employee of the PCAOB, and shared that information with other KPMG personnel. That information potentially undermined the integrity of the regulatory process.

KPMG immediately reported the situation to the PCAOB and the SEC, and retained outside counsel to investigate. The firm learned through the investigation that the six KPMG individuals either had improper advance warnings of engagements to be inspected by the PCAOB, or were aware that others had received such advance warnings and had failed to properly report the situation in a timely manner.

Investigations continue and no SEC or PCAOB enforcement actions or disciplinary actions have been announced, yet.  I expect the SEC will take the lead since the PCAOB’s processes and controls are part of the story.  My WSJ colleagues got the scoop and, it is clear to me, if someone had not made the call to the WSJ we would have been waiting a long time for the SEC or PCAOB to announce something.

That’s because KPMG is not going to announce until absolutely necessary and, of course, because the PCAOB can’t by law —the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002— say anything about an ongoing investigation until it is final and any actions are approved by the SEC.  The PCAOB has made numerous attempts to change the law to combat the firms’ desire to suppress public awareness of such activity by litigating it for years, but legislators end up dropping the bills from the agenda each time after campaign contributions are made.

KPMG also says, “This issue does not impact any of the firm’s audit opinions or any client’s financial statements.”

I find that odd,  unless all of the terminated partners were leadership/national office partners, currently not assigned to lead engagements.  The two names revealed so far—Scott Marcello, the head of the United States audit practice and David Middendorf head of of the national office— do not appear to have been assigned as lead partners on any audits for 2016, based on the new PCAOB engagement partner database.

If that is the case, these non-client facing partners could still impact audit opinions or financial statements because they, perhaps, used the inspection information not directly for their own personal benefit but to warn or advise engagement teams to backdate workpapers, clean up files or otherwise cover up audit failures before the PCAOB caught them.  The PCAOB says that when a firm does not provide sufficient evidence to support its audit opinion, then the opinion should not have been issued at all.

That would be an audit failure in my book.

I guess we will have to wait until we have more details to see whether KPMG’s statement was too optimistic, naive or regrettably incomplete.

Jim Ulvog, who pens the Attestation Blog, says, “From my auditor’s perspective, this situation has the feel of a ‘red flag’, meaning something that seems odd on the surface and which is actually a warning sign there could be a far more serious problem, potentially systemic and possibly quite material.”

I agree.

It’s not like Big 4 firm partners have never acted in their own self-interest, subverting the authority of the regulator, and corrupting more partners downstream in the process. It just happened at Deloitte Brazil. The PCAOB said in its complaint that a very senior partner of the Brazil firm knew in early 2014 that his colleagues had provided the PCAOB inspectors with improperly altered versions of the 2010 workpapers for its audit of airline Gol Linhas Aéreas Inteligentes S.A.

Back in 2002, a Brazilian auditor for Deloitte at the peak of his career questioned the firm’s Italian office about large, unusual balances between Italian dairy company Parmalat’s Brazilian operation and a Cayman Islands subsidiary called Bonlat.

Fourteen years on, that onetime whistleblower, Wanderley Olivetti, is being stripped of his responsibilities, as the most senior of 12 Deloitte partners sanctioned this week by the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB), the U.S. audit regulator. The board accused Olivetti of lying to it about faulty audits and a subsequent cover-up among senior partners.

My analysis in December of U.S. regulatory actions against Deloitte dating back to 2002 for MarketWatch showed that showed that Deloitte partners, too, have frequently been the reason that the Big 4 global audit firms are thriving financially, but audit quality and professionalism are not.  KPMG is no different.

After all, KPMG is the firm of Scott London, the convicted inside trader who served his own self-interest while the regional partner in charge of KPMG’s audit clients in Southern California and the southwest United States. KPMG lost the Herbalife audit to PwC as a result of London’s illegal and unethical actions. Skechers, whose CFO told the FT he bore no ill will towards London or KPMG London, also replaced KPMG as its auditor shortly after the revelations and had to re-audit two years of financials.

KPMG is also the firm that audits or audited some of the biggest bailouts, failures and forced acquisitions of the financial crisis.

KPMG has audited Wells Fargo for more than 85 years. The bank not only had a huge portfolio of fraudulent foreclosures after its forced acquisition of Wachovia during the crisis—also audited by KPMG — but WFC is now under severe scrutiny for  a fake accounts scandal KPMG seems to have missed, or worse, ignored.

KPMG was the original auditor of Fannie Mae before fraud, financial restatements and a lawsuit forced it out.

KPMG audited HSBC, notorious for its money laundering failures.

KPMG audits Credit Suisse which paid $5.2 billion in fines for selling toxic mortgage debt without proper disclosures.

KPMG audits Deutsche Bank, which has a rap sheet of legal and regulatory enforcement actions totaling billions.

KPMG audits Fifa.

KPMG was almost out of business once before, in 2005, as a result of an almost criminal indictment for tax shelter fraud. Looking into the abyss, regulators established the implicit “too few to fail” policy.

Every remaining Big 4 firm has has weathered, at one time or another, a similar critical mass of audit failures and litigation threats, sometimes verging on a full-blown crisis in confidence, in the 15 years since Arthur Andersen closed up shop and the Sarbanes-Oxley Act was passed to supposedly end all doubts about auditors.

Although all of the Big 4 were scrutinized and, in some cases sued, for crisis-era failures, all those cases were settled relatively cheaply.  There were no “going concern” opinions for the banks and other institutions that were bailed out, failed or essentially nationalized in the US.  You might get the impression the auditors were not there at all.  There was no mention of their presence or their role in any accounts of the crisis. (Until a much later revelation about PwC and AIG that did not cause even a stir in the media.)

There has been no admission,  similar to the one in the UK, that meetings took place between the auditors and the Federal Reserve or the Treasury leading to Lehman’s failure or afterwards. No one has asked them. The Big 4 were never called to Congress to testify about their role during the crisis.

EY felt the heat for a short moment over the failure of Lehman Brothers. The $99 million EY paid was more than Lehman’s officers and directors paid. Dick Fuld and the rest starred in “Too Big To Fail” but he and his directors only paid $90 million. That’s a big deal considering executives typically say, “The auditors said it was ok,” and the auditors say, “Management duped us.” But, I wrote at the time that it’s not that much considering that EY agreed to pay C$117 million ($117.6 million) just before that to settle claims in a Canadian class action suit against Sino-Forest Corp, a Chinese reverse merger fraud. That settlement is the largest by an auditor in Canadian history, according to the the law firms.

EY has survived and thrived since, and it audits some of the biggest names in tech like Google, Facebook, Amazon and Apple.

Deloitte was dinged but not seriously dented by the financial crisis. The firm lost some really big audit engagements as a result of the bankruptcies and forced acquisitions that were foisted on the firms by the U.S. Treasury during the crisis,  clients like Bear Stearns, Washington Mutual, Merrill Lynch and, much later, Royal Bank of Scotland.

One Deloitte client went bankrupt during the crisis and was taken over by the U.S. government for a time.  Deloitte still audits GM, now for more than 100 years, even though it has been sued by shareholders more than once..

Deloitte later paid an undisclosed amount to avoid going to trial to defend a claim of $7 billion for the crisis era failure as a result of fraud of audit client Taylor Bean & Whitaker. The firm paid $2 million to the PCAOB for putting a suspended auditor back to work in its national office advising other audit engagements partners.  Deloitte paid $10 million to the New York Department of Financial Services and accepted a one year ban from consulting to New York banks for allegedly losing its objectivity and independence when advising Standard Chartered —audited by KPMG—on its anti-money laundering compliance in response to a prior consent decree, according to the complaint.

PwC audits some big crisis players, too.  JPM Chase, Bank of American and Goldman Sachs were all integral to the resolution of the crisis as well as being both bailout recipients and bailout buyers of firms like Washington Mutual, Bear Stearns, and Merrill Lynch.

JPM Chase experienced a non-crisis related failure to control, and auditor PwC didn’t make a public appearance at all. The bank booked a restatement to recognize its bungling of the disclosures surrounding its $6 billion dollar loss for the “Whale” trading debacle.

At the beginning of 2016 PwC faced three trials for its role in alleged frauds and its alleged professional negligence based on the complaints filed with courts. The first trial started last August, a hearing on PwC’s role in allegedly enabling the crisis-era failure of Taylor Bean & Whitaker while auditing Colonial Bank, TBW’s partner in crime. Both Colonial Bank and TBW went bankrupt from the frauds and sent executives to jail. PwC paid an undisclosed amount after three weeks of testimony by the plaintiff, the Trustee in bankruptcy, ostensibly to avoid a much worse result if the verdict was unfavorable to PwC and resulted in an award approaching the $6 billion damages claim.

PwC’s second trial began in early 2017 when it faced a $3 billion claim by the Trustee in bankruptcy for MF Global, a firm that collapsed in bankruptcy in October 2010. PwC again settled for an undisclosed amount after a few weeks of testimony by the plaintiff’s witnesses, including testimony by the two PwC engagement partners, Linda McGowan and George Gallagher.

Guy Rolnik, a Clinical Associate Professor of Strategic Management at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business writes in the Stigler Center’s Pro-Market blog that the global firms not only push back on the public’s expectation they will detect fraud via their audits the Big 4 even avoids admitting that they serve a public watchdog role!

Crucial to MF Global’s case is the portrayal of PwC (and other auditing firms) as public watchdogs—a definition which PwC has resisted before. In a letter to the court last month, PwC requested that MF Global’s plan administrator be precluded from referring to its role in the U.S. financial markets as a “public watchdog.” On Friday, the court agreed and barred MF Global from arguing that PwC had a public watchdog role.

 The definition relies on a previous Supreme Court ruling, in the 1984 case United States v. Arthur Young, which determined that accounting firms have a “public watchdog” role that mandates they remain completely independent from clients. 

PwC was also sanctioned by the New York Department of Financial Services, like Deloitte, for allegedly selling out its objectivity to Bank of Tokyo Mitsubishi according to the complaint.  PwC, however, was fined 2.5X as much as Deloitte, $25 million, and banned twice as long, two years. The firm made the senior manager in charge of the engagement a partner.

In another case of failing upward, Tim Ryan, who was PwC’s engagement partner from 2005-2009 for the largest bailout and nationalization of all, AIG, is now the firm’s US Chairman.

After the crisis, three of the Big 4—all but KPMG—were actively involved in working with the big banks, the ones they didn’t audit, to support the failed foreclosure review process. KPMG, however, was of course the auditor of two banks with largest exposure to the foreclosure damages, Citigroup and Wells Fargo/Wachovia.  KPMG was also, of course, the auditor of two of the worst case subprime mortgage originators, New Century and Countrywide.

There are a number of partners and professionals from the Big 4 that have been sanctioned or jailed for insider trading in the last ten years. It’s a rogues’ gallery that includes Scott London from KPMG, as well as a senior tax partner from EY, and a Vice Chairman from Deloitte. Deloitte’s former chief risk officer was also charged with accepting a loan of gambling chips from an audit client, Caesars Entertainment Corp.  The SEC under Mary Jo White and the PCAOB have been more aggressive in the last few years than in the first ten years after Sarbanes-Oxley in enforcing auditor independence rules.  Some of the details are too salacious to repeat on this family blog.  Despite that,  there are still more matters that should be on their to-do lists.

It’s a terrible joke on investors and the capital markets that PwC’s screw-up regarding Oscar envelopes got more mainstream coverage than any of the stories I mentioned previously. According to Rolnik at the Stigler Center it’s because there’s a lack of general interest in the auditors.

Eight years after the calamity and subsequent bailouts on Wall Street, the role of the auditors—and the Big Four in particular—has never been fully investigated by regulators and legislators, nor the media.

The lesson (not the moral) is simple: if we want to better understand when markets work and when they fail, we should have a better understanding of the way reputation works, especially the way large players in the market manipulate reputation using complexity and a crowded media agenda, and how the public’s lack of interest is translated into a lack of regulatory urgency.

And in the end, as I predicted, PwC kept the Oscar’s gig.

Why does a seemingly severely damaged reputation no longer affect the business of the Big 4 firms?

When I interviewed Neil Barofsky the former TARP Inspector general, about his book Bailout: An Inside Account of How Washington Abandoned Main Street While Rescuing Wall Street, for American Banker, I asked him why the Big Four audit firms do not appear in the book at all. He said they are a nonentity.

“The auditors have proven themselves to me, over and over again, to be more concerned about the steady stream of fees than in doing their job.”

I agree with the sentiment but not his conclusion.  The Big 4 are a necessary evil, with audits required by listing exchange rules and consulting used as cover by big corporations.  Everyone needs someone to point a finger at once and a while.  For a large fee, corporate executives will say, “The auditor said it was correct,” and the auditor will say, “We were duped,” and prosecutors, judges, politicians and many regulators will say it’s just too hard to sort it all out.

Major settlements and occasional infamy is an acceptable cost of doing business they can handle, as far as we know.

Like the big banks, no one wants to plan for the consequences of taking a Big 4 firm out for being very bad once too often.  The stakes are just too high for everyone dependent on the “too few to fail” Big 4.