So basically #FyreFestival finally made a real-life version of Club Paradise
Will Ferrell brings George W. Bush to Samantha Bees Not Correspondents Dinner
Austin, Texas police officer faked his death and fled to Mexico, officials say
WATCH LIVE: Donald Trump holds Pennsylvania rally to celebrate first 100 days
New docs reveal details of Manaforts pro-Russia lobbying
Millennials are most likely to fall for an IRS scam
Trump: I would not be happy if North Korea conducts nuclear test
Yesterday’s 25% #VIX drop, only 4th time since 1990 smallest rally w/such drop. YS
Commercial paper outstanding grows by $5.3 billion in a week to $980.2 billion
Yale Republicans taunt hunger-striking union workers with a barbecue
What was @realDonaldTrump tweeting about in his first #100Days?
Holocaust Museum Opens Research Center to Public
US troops patrolling border between Turkey and Syria
Immigrants who joined military in exchange for faster citizenship facing extensive delays
ESPN is a Reminder That on the Market, No One Is Too Big to Fail | @ThoBishop
This was defined as corrupt in 1824. To think how far America has built out corruption since then...
Black cabin perched on steep slope in the Sierra Nevada mountains:
People just keep turning up and New Zealand is getting worried
Russians, in peaceful protest, call for Putin to quit
Montana GOP candidate has financial links to Russian firms sanctioned by US: report
Otherwordly photos of marble caves in #Chile
Oklahoma MAGA-man has a plan to save Trump’s border wall
Sunset photo by Scott Kuhn. He said, It lasted about 30 seconds. Once again, right place at the right time.
Wasserman Schultz slams Trumps agenda as irrational and extreme
Why NASA is running out of spacesuits
Another Race Hoax? Non-Student Created ‘No Black People Allowed’ Sign at USC #tcot
Mt. Fuji casting its Shadow almost to the Horizon at Sunrise
Comment: #DonaldTrump’s first #100days show ratings come first, not #AmericaFirst
Googles updated Earth app will destroy your free time @DanielHowley
Dust As: A flash fiction tale where a nonhuman cyborg surveys the fundamentals of earth
Chewy Cinnamon Roll Blondies @beamingbanana #vegan
Samantha Bee roasts Trump, CNN, Fox News during Not Correspondents Dinner
Snow sweeping across central U.S. into Monday may cause travel delays, school cancellations:
Trump: My trips to my golf clubs cost almost nothing
Falcon 9 and NROL-76 vertical on Pad 39-A. Launch window opens tomorrow at 7:00 a.m. EDT, 11:00 UTC.
Massive number of Dems step up to run in 2018 elections
computer, take the shittiest takes of 2016 put them in a random word generator and vomit out a 2017 take
Demo accuses Hungarys Orban of ties to Moscow
McDonalds: Expect fewer workers behind the counter @SallyPancakes
Jeff Bezos shows us in this photo exactly how many shares Amazon has bought back since 2012:
Από την εκδήλωση του DiEM25 στο Βελλίδειο στη Θεσσαλονίκη #DiEM25_Ellada #NewDealForGreece
Hacker leaks new season of Orange is the New Black after demanding ransom
Bacteria that eats and breathes electricity? Yep:
Lake Louise, Canada
Almost 20% of Pres. Trumps first 100 days were spent at Mar-a-Lago
USDA to undo Michelle Obamas school meal nutrition standards
Trump’s 100 days on Twitter: What he said, by the numbers From @kingdomofevan
The 4 questions to ask any politician waffling on about immigration
The Unlikeliest Innovations in Community Planning
Pope urges mediation to end North Korea crisis, avert devastating war
New test-firing of ballistic missile by North Korea
Trump team did do a background check of Flynn, knew about ties to Turkey: report
Its not every day a stark naked person tells you what youve done for Israel
Got some pretty serious sunburn at the #climatemarch
#Xiongan New Area the latest spectacle of an ambitious Beijing #ThisWeekInAsia
The best burger in Shenzhen
Five decades before Trump, the EPA was run by Republicans—and it thrived
Hollywood, DC come together for First Amendment-themed VIP party
Wikipedia appears to have been blocked in Turkey
In first 100 days, a reversal of fortune for Trump favorites on Wall Street
The Tories lied to the Crathes Public Hall Trust? Theresa Mays visit booked as a childs party.
French amphibious carrier arrives in Japan amid growing North Korea tensions
Former Afghan warlord returns to his country calling for peace
Live coverage: Trumps rally competes with White House correspondents dinner
Anthony Bourdain says the Unicorn Frappuccino is the perfect nexus of awfulness’
EU leaders agree Brexit negotiating guidelines
Dem lawmakers blast Trumps climate change policies during Climate March
Watch the latest episode of “Peer-to-Peer” with David Petraeus
EU leaders approve tough terms for Brexit talks
Schumer: NYC should refuse to pay for Trump’s security
GOP candidate has financial ties to Russian companies sanctioned by the U.S. government
1945 liberation of Dachau Nazi camp remembered
Climate March draws massive crowds to DC
Drinking four cups of coffee Is probably safe, writes @jameshamblin.
Miss the action from todays #ClimateMarchDC? Check out our in-depth multimedia coverage:
In Photos: The people seeking friendship on Craigslist
Whats behind the turmoil in FYR Macedonia?
Leonardo DiCaprio leads climate march holding climate change is REAL sign
Duterte to Trump: Keep cool over North Korea
EU sets Britain tough divorce terms, slams budget veto
They marched by land (and by sea) today in Copenhagen! #climatemarch #klimamarch. Pic via @Markus_Power
Men more stressed out by meditation  #menshealth #mentalhealth
It is a great weekend to garden. 32 inspirational gardening quotes
On views of race and inequality, blacks and whites are worlds apart #PAA2017
State public pension funds are increasing their use of complex investments. New findings:
Study confirms some men use anti-gay and sexist jokes to shore up their masculinity
When can we stop pretending that Republicans care about the deficit?
A Company Thats Having a Positive Impact on Angolan Lives #Angola
Why distracted drivers matter for self-driving cars:
Maher on Obama speaking fee: Isn’t that what cost Clinton the election?
When it comes to the environment, Richard Nixon was no Donald Trump.
Ban Zuma from May Day Celebrations - South African Unions #SouthAfrica
‘Sanctuary City’ No More: Michigan City Council Reverses Decision #tcot
Russian police arrest dozens of anti-Putin protesters
Algeria: From a 1959 Turbine to a $3 Billion Power Services Deal #Algeria
#Scientist invents way to trigger artificial #photosynthesis to clean air
That time Steven Spielberg and Sega built the arcade of your dreams
Chinas cute young boys in showbiz: can their careers outlast their looks?
Traveling This Summer? Here Are 5 Quick Tips to Minimize Your Environmental Footprint #eco
A disturbing number of humpback whales are dying off the east coast
Pathologizing Arabs is a bipartisan project at the NYT
Michael Moore: Im not rooting for Trump
Liberal Democrat candidate @Cajardine expected to win Edinburgh West on 8 June #GE2017
Trephining.
What your vacation preferences say about your personality #citylabarchive
#Earthquake magnitude 4,9 - 115,9 km from #Masaya - #Nicaragua
New to FRED: 2,402 annual series from FHFA featuring county-level house price data
US troops patrolling border between Turkey and Syria
Apr 29, 1917 - Cooks for a British artillery battery at work in their trenches near Arras. #100yearsago
Opinion: European countries should work with the US to deter attacks on Syrian civilians
Young Turks host: Im glad the press chased Trump out of town for #WHCD
The mind in the machine: @DemisHassabis on artificial intelligence
April 1917 - If you cant enlist - invest. Buy a Liberty Bond. #100yearsago
Apr 29, 1917 - New York Times: US Treasury Secretary dubs wartime bond issue Liberty Loans #100yearsago
New docs reveal details of Manaforts pro-Russia lobbying
A trick that hides censored websites inside cat videos, @kavehwaddell reports:
EUs Juncker urges Britain to stop blocking EU spending
Starbucks in China fixed the most annoying thing about carrying hot coffee cups
There’s a 40% chance the language you speak is rooted in this ancient tongue:
Trumps America? Not for long. Democratic women are taking our country back.
Is “Community” a Verb or a Noun? Provocations From Baltimore and Washington
COFINA Senior group statement on Puerto Ricos offer to bondholders #muniland
Ode to a philistine: Howard Jacobsons Pussy
British PM Mays Conservatives see lead slip to 17 points: Opinium poll
Rasheed is a top 10 NYC sunny-weather institution.
How reliant is each state on foreign trade? via @howmuch_net
#Earthquake magnitude 4,3 - 211,0 km from #Salta - #Argentina
People’s Climate March draws 200,000 protesters as Trump flees to coal country
We sleep less as we age because our brains don’t think were tired
Tesla recruiting engineers in Mexico for California plant
The Amazon reef is home to amazing biodiversity, but it is already under threat:
South African Court Sets Aside Govts Huge Nuclear Deal #SouthAfrica
Sharpton confronts Omarosa at conference
London mayor Sadiq Khan withdraws support for Thomas Heatherwick-designed Garden Bridge:
The Observer front page, Sunday 30 April 2017: Threat to Brexit trade talks as EU demands rights for citizens
EPA removes climate change page from website hours ahead of #climatemarch
Candies Wrapped in the Bitterness of Chinese Forced Labor
Neil Ty, The Scientism Guy | @NewmanJ_R
#Earthquake magnitude 4,1 - 109,4 km from #Arequipa - #Peru
Bailout or bust? Alitalia divides a nation, paralyzes Rome
This Is Yuuuge! Musk Retweets Climate March Video
Granddaughter of coal breaker becomes local leader against climate change
Massive number of Dems step up to run in 2018 elections
Russias Lavrov says ready to cooperate with U.S. on Syria: agencies
You’re never going to get $10,000 for your United seat
Maybe we shouldnt tell our enemies our step-by-step plan on how were going to crush them...
Half of those arrested in immigration raids only had traffic offenses or no record: report
Authors of Made With @creativecommons interview kicking off at #ccsummit @pgstacey @shinchpearson @ryanmerkley
How Woodrow Wilson’s propaganda machine changed American journalism @ConversationUS
A trick that hides censored websites inside cat videos, @kavehwaddell reports:
A look inside New Yorks most important new restaurant
Burns, lung cancer and carbon pollution—the high price paid by open fire cooking.
Study: People are Confused about Climate Change, Weather and Climate Definitions #tcot
Some #Russian #LNG projects are speeding ahead - while others lag behind #OOTT
Trump: My trips to my golf clubs cost almost nothing
Give your immune system a booger bust  #health #wellness #natural
EU says united Ireland would be automatic full member
Why not a probe of Israel-gate?
Googles CEO gets another massive pay package
New effort aims to inspire the next generation of pro-environment women candidates
Fargo, North Dakota official faces recall threat for statements about refugee resettlement
VIDEO: Watch Pioneering Spirit do worlds heaviest offshore lift
Lyft drivers sue Uber, saying it spied on them to gain an edge
apparently screaming are you Kevin James at everyone who walks out of here gets the cops called on you, weird
Japans Abe cautions against Brexit regulation cliff edge
Meanwhile in Kharkiv metro via @_Sovinskiy Said to be 4 phones connected with power bank inside with duct tape
Lone Tree, Mansfield, Victoria, Australia
Good read #Giant companies that won’t buy your #startup #fintech #insurtech @jglasner #VC
Immigrants who joined military in exchange for faster citizenship facing extensive delays
Ngoepe Is Africas First Gift to US Major Baseball League: #Africa
The most popular drunk food in 21 cities around the world
Its the longest wall in the world - and construction began in 770 BC:
This photographer documents the refugee camps of Western Sahara, Africas last colony:
Elephant Rock, Iceland
Music can be beautiful... Via @CollectiveEvol
Chinas naval task force begins its 6-month, 20-nation grand tour
10 Tricks and Tips to Slay the’ #Vegan Pizza Game #food
Duterte warns: Kim Jung Un wants to end the world
Despite the new ‘plan’, this is -still- a no-brainer tax strategy
The link between green space and well-being isnt as simple as we thought #citylabarchive
Philippine leader says North Koreas Kim wants to end the world, urges U.S. restraint
EU leaders try to clear unnecessary irritants before Brexit talks
Trump’s tax plan hits its first land mine: Blue-state Republicans
Yales College Republicans hold BBQ near a hunger strike to increase protesters anguish.
Own one of the finest #Caribbean addresses - #Barbados   #investing #realestate
Making America great again.
Peoples Climate March Stockholm. #climatemarch #whyIMarch
#PopeFrancis urges mediation to end #NorthKorea crisis, avert devastating war
Could a North Korean missile hit the White House? Heres what you need to know
Fine wine is ready to party
Wait — maybe globalization isnt dead after all!
Pollsters look for clues in French success with more elections coming up
Our cover story — Demetri Sevastopulo on the first 100 days of Donald Trump
Is it ok to wear camouflage to the office?
Emma Watson says The Circle brought home pitfalls of social media
Donald Trumps chief strategist Steve Bannon is reportedly back in the circle of trust.
Jeff Bezos is just $5 billion away from being the worlds richest person
Apple recruits NASA talent for its big AR push
12-year-old girl asked to change out of seductive dress to continue in chess tournament.
25 things to eat before you die – the ultimate foodie bucket list
Voting intent in upcoming #GE17 - Conservatives ahead of Labour in 8 regions
Roissy : 1302 hectares de prairie pour développer la biodiversité @ParisAeroport #partenaire
Labour is within 11% points of the Tories, according to an exclusive Telegraph poll
Frances Le Pen softens on timetable for dumping euro
Turkish authorities expel more than 3,900 from civil service in latest purge
The world is watching to see if France votes for Choisir or Ensemble
Nine clever signs from the Climate March
Could a North Korean missile hit the White House? Heres what you need to know
Walking with my dog in downtown NYC - amazing feeling to have the sun back finally! #enjoylyfe #t1d #cure
Merkel says she has good relationship with Trump despite frosty start
This Canadian auto-parts maker is at the center of Trumps Nafta clash
These are the 15 best cabernets under $50
EU throws down the gauntlet to Britain ahead of Brexit talks
EU suspects Brexit mind games in UK veto on budget
Brexit is causing problems for Labour - new Telegraph poll
How many people actually believe in astrology?
Amsterdam, Netherlands, 8000 march for climate action. #climatejustice #climatemarch #climatechange #climatemarchnl
Here we go. Join us for live coverage of #JoshuaKlitchsko from a packed-out Wembley Stadium
In one powerful tweetstorm, this woman demolishes the hypocrisy of fat shaming.
Tomorrows Sunday Telegraph front page: May rejects Brussels demands #tomorrowspaperstoday
Does Putin still favor his sidekick Medvedev?
US service member dies after explosion in Iraq
LIVE from the Climate March in Washington DC
Germany: Hundreds rally against Monsanto-Bayer mega-merger in Berlin
Hassan #Rouhani warns voters to prevent extremism returning to #Iran
Ten thousand IKEA refugee shelters left unused over fire fears, United Nations admits:
Todays Post: Measuring Perceptions of Uncertainty
This is a very curious idea
Revisiting the Rodney King verdict 25 years later
Humor
Fewer Twitter users engaging with Trump’s tweets: report
More US GDP
haha this is good
Pakistan army rejects PMs actions on security leak
Senator slams Trump tweet: Not reality TV
DiCaprio marches with climate protesters
#Resistance to Greet Trumps 100-Day Campaign Rally in Pennsylvania
Leonardo DiCaprio leads climate march holding climate change is REAL sign
You have one month to come up with a better system to govern the world →
Motor racing: Mercedes face a big battle as domination disappears
US GDP growth
Actors trek to Capitol Hill to lobby against funding cuts for arts programs
US service member killed after blast near Iraqi city of Mosul, coalition reports
How India’s Safecity gives women a voice against violence
Poland: The case for #EBA in the east #Brexit
New orders for durable goods rose by 0.7% in March after climbing by 2.3% in prior month
The NYSE Behaving Badly ..as told by Bloomberg. Chilling:
David Bowie’s 1987 slump held its own weird magic, writes @jason_m_heller
Speculative investor positioning


Gail Tverberg
The Economy Is Like a Circus
12 days ago




The economy is like a circus. It comes to town, and eventually it leaves town. We get paid in tickets to this circus. As long as the circus stays in town, we can use our tickets. Once the circus leaves town, we are pretty much out of luck.1

The reason the circus stays in town is because the economy stays in sufficient balance that the economy can go on. This is much like the way many other self-organized systems function. For example, our bodies continue to function as long as there are suitable balances in many different areas (oxygen, food, water, air pressure). Ecosystems continue to function as long as there is sufficient rain, adequate temperatures, and enough sunlight.

There are many different views as to what limits we reach in a finite world. Some people think we will “run out” of oil, or of energy products. Some think that the energy return will fall too low, as measured in some manner. I see the adequacy of the energy return as being very much tied to the financial system. Thus, the forecast by US Atlanta Fed GDPNow indicating that first quarter 2017 US GDP growth will only be 0.5% is likely to be a problem, assuming it is correct.

Our economy operates on economies of scale. Once we get too close to shrinking, or actually start shrinking, we reach a point where the economic circus starts to leave town. At some point, we will discover the circus is gone. The economy we thought we had, will have left us. If some people are survivors, they will need to pick up the pieces and start over with an entirely new system.

What the Economy Needs to Do to Keep Functioning

For our economy to continue functioning, a number of variables are important:

  • Prices of commodities – Prices cannot be too high for the consumer to afford goods made with them. They also cannot be low for producers. If prices of oil and other commodities are too low for producers (as they are now), producers need to keep raising debt levels to stay in business. There is a risk that production will stop from lack of adequate new investment, or from bankruptcy of producers.
  • Wages of non-elite workers – These wages need to be high enough so that workers can afford goods made with commodities, such as cars, homes and computers. These big purchases tend to use commodities even after they are made, adding to “demand” for commodities. If commodity prices such as oil are too low (as they are now), it is likely related to inadequate wages of non-elite workers.
  • Mandatory payments required of non-elite workers, such as taxes, health care, and education – It is not just wages of non-elite workers that are important. So are required payments, such as payments for taxes, healthcare and education. Clearly, the lower these payments are for non-elite workers, the better the economy functions.
  • Interest rates – Low interest rates are helpful for some parts of the economy, while high interest rates are good for other parts. Low interest rates help create affordable monthly payments for goods such as homes and cars. If interest rates decline, the market prices of assets such as real estate, shares of stock, and bonds tend to rise. These rising values are of great benefit to owners of these assets, since they can sell these assets and use the proceeds to add to current consumption. Conversely, high interest rates are important to pension plans and to others depending on investment income. Banks have a problem if there is not a big enough “spread” between short and long interest rates.
  • Increase in debt – An increase in debt indirectly makes the economy “look” much better. Increasing debt acts to raise wages, since some of this growing debt adds to funds available for wages. The higher wages tend to increase demand for goods, and thus indirectly raise commodity prices. A virtuous circle starts, pushing up economic growth, provided an adequate quantity of very cheap energy products is available (under $20 barrel oil, for example) that can be used to make goods and services. Increased debt works less and less well, as the price of energy products increases.
  • Inflation rates – The higher the inflation rate, the easier it is to repay debt with interest, since most debt is not adjusted for inflation. Also, high inflation rates help keep prices of homes and other buildings from falling as they age, making the use of mortgages more feasible. If the price of a commodity, such as oil or coal, is high and then falls, debt based on the prior high value of the commodity is likely to become a problem.
  • Quantity of energy products affordable by economy – It takes energy products to produce goods and services. If the price of commodities is low, it is possible for buyers to purchase a large quantity of these products, even on a low budget. Current relatively low prices tend to help the economy, even if producers cannot afford to make adequate investment in new production with such low prices. Thus, today’s low energy prices make the economy look good for at a short time. Afterwards, the outlook is less rosy.

Ultimately, the issue at hand in determining whether the “circus will leave town” is whether non-elite workers are able to adequately make a living. We know from biology that the return on the labor of animals must be adequate (animals must be able to get enough food by walking, swimming, or flying) or their populations will collapse. The same thing is true for humans. We also know that prior civilizations that collapsed often had wage disparity problems. When this happened, non-elite workers were no longer able to pay adequate taxes. Their nutrition became poorer. They tended to become more susceptible to epidemics. These were things that pushed the economy toward collapse.

The goods and services that non-elite workers can buy with their wages represent the benefits of our fossil fuel powered energy system, as distributed to the most vulnerable workers in the system. Once these benefits start falling too low, the system can no longer function.

There are some indications that benefits are already too low for the economy to keep functioning in a “normal” manner. A major such indication is the fact that energy prices have remained far too low since mid-2014, It is becoming increasingly clear that there really is no oil price which is both high enough for producers and low enough for consumers. We may be living on “borrowed time,” using an increasing amount of debt to support energy producers.

Thus, world economic growth rates may already be too low to keep the world economy operating. Regulators who consider only the US do not seem to understand the world situation. Because of this, they can easily make moves that make the situation worse, rather than better. For example, they have already started raising interest rates and are planning to sell securities currently held by the Federal Reserve.

A Few Graphs Giving Hints of Our Problem

Economists have not understood what our problems really are, so they have tended to omit some important issues from their analyses. I put together a few graphs that might give a little insight as to what is happening.

Interest Paid by Households 

Interest paid by households is important because this money is transferred to banks, insurance companies, and pension plans. It leaves the households who paid this interest poorer. Buying goods using debt is convenient, but it has a cost involved.

BEA Table 7.11 shows a category called, “Interest Paid by Households.” If we compare this to BEA “Wages and Salaries,” we find the relationship shown in Figure 1. Admittedly this is not an exact comparison; there are some people who are not wage earners who are making interest payments, for example. I have not tried to offset “interest paid by households,” against “interest received by households,” because the households benefiting from interest payments are likely very different households than those paying interest payments. They are likely richer, and at a later stage in their lives.

Figure 1. US Household Interest Paid (from BEA Table 7.11 Interest Paid and Received by Sector and Legal Form of Organization) divided by Wages and Salaries from BEA Table 2.11, “Personal Income and its Disposition.”

The pattern might be described as follows:

  • A rapid run-up in interest payments that took place until about 1986
  • A general flattening, with new peak in 2007
  • A rapid fall starting in 2008

It seems to me that the pattern up to 1986 reflects the general run-up in consumer debt levels during this period. The amount of interest paid is also affected by interest rates, such as ten-year treasury rates.

Figure 2. US Federal Bonds 10 year interest rates. Graph produced by FRED (Federal Reserve Economic Data).

Interest rates started falling in 1981. These higher rates only gradually worked their way into the system, because many people had bought houses earlier, and were able to keep their existing mortgages at low interest rates. The amount of debt outstanding continued to rise, allowing the total amount of interest paid to continue to rise until 1986.

After 1986, rising debt amounts and falling interest rates came closer to offsetting each other (Figure 1). By 2008, the economy was in a severe recession. In order to help get out of the recession, interest rates were lowered through Quantitative Easing. These lower interest rates, besides helping the economy in general, helped oil prices gradually increase back to the $100+ per barrel price level that they needed to be profitable. Oil prices had temporarily dropped below $40 per barrel in December 2008.

Figure 1 shows that interest payments for several years amounted to about 12% of wages for households. Interest payments are now down to 8% of wages. Even at this level they are significant. They are likely higher than this for those with low wages and high debt. If interest rates rise significantly, the most vulnerable are likely to find their discretionary income is reduced.

Rising Healthcare Costs 

Figure 3 shows a comparison of US healthcare costs to GDP and to wages. A huge increase in costs is evident in the 2001-2005 periods, and also in the 2008-2010 period, especially compared to wages.

Figure 3. US Healthcare costs as a percentage of GDP and as a percentage of wages. Healthcare costs form cms.gov. Wages and salaries and GDP from BEA.

The increase in healthcare costs since 2008 is one of the costs putting pressure on the economy, and leading to a need for lower interest rates.

The Affordable Care Act should be affecting amounts for the latest years, since the ACA started increasing the number of people with insurance starting about 2014.

Figure 4. Kaiser Family Foundation chart of percentages of non-elderly people without healthcare insurance, from this Source.

A person might wonder why 2014 and 2015 costs didn’t rise more, with so many more people added to the system. Perhaps care that was being given “free” by hospitals is now being charged back to patients. Or perhaps many of the people choosing to purchase coverage through the program were already insured elsewhere in the system, so were not really added to the healthcare system through the Affordable Care Act.

One very recent US healthcare change is the addition of an automatic penalty for not having healthcare insurance. This penalty began for tax year 2016, filed in the beginning of 2017. This provision particularly hurts young people, because rates are structured in such a way that the rates for young people subsidize the rates for older people. Thus, young people often find that buying health insurance is far more expensive than their out of pocket costs for health care would have been, without insurance.

Young people who are affected by this new requirement will find that they need to cut back on other expenditures (such as restaurant visits), if they are meet the requirements of the law–either buy healthcare insurance or pay the mandated penalty. This change will begin to adversely affect the economy in 2016. Bigger impacts are likely in early 2017, when taxes are filed.

Falling Wages Relative to GDP, and Rising Wage Disparity

The path to lower wages as a percentage of GDP has been a bumpy one. The general pattern is that when the economy is booming, wages tend to grow as a percentage of GDP. Recession tends to send wages down as a percentage of GDP. US wages seem to have increased somewhat since 2013, perhaps because the price of oil is down, and the US dollar has risen to a relatively high level. This is part of what allows some people to talk about the “tightening labor market,” and gives them confidence in the economy.

Figure 5. US wages and salaries divided by US GDP, based on BEA data.

There has been significant growth in wage disparity since about 1980, both in the US and in many other developed countries. Figure 6 shows some data for the US.

Figure 6. United States Income Distribution_1947-2007 in 2007$. The data source is “Table F-1. Income Limits for Each Fifth and Top 5 Percent of Families (All Races): 1947 to 2007”, U.S. Census Bureau, Current Population Survey, Annual Social and Economic Supplements. Graph is from Wikimedia Commons http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:United_States_Income_Distribution_1947-2007.svg

As the economy becomes more “complex,” in other words, “specialized,” wage disparity tends to be more of a problem. Work that could previously be done by manual laborers is done by machinery, or is transferred to low wage countries. Many people lose their jobs, and have difficulty finding good-paying replacement jobs. All of this contributes to inadequate wages for non-elite workers.

Role of Inflation and Rising Commodity Prices in the Economy

We rarely stop to think how important inflation is to the economy. For example, if inflation is sufficiently high, it will slightly offset normal depreciation in values of home values and business properties. Thus, home and business property values will tend to slightly rise over time. If banks can count on values of structures rising, rather than falling, over time, lenders can assume that mortgage loans are fairly risk-free, because the lender can count on getting its money back through the sale of the property, if the mortgage-holder defaults.

This same principle holds when energy properties, such as coal mines and oil fields are financed. As long as energy prices keep rising, there is a good chance loans can be repaid. Once energy prices fall, debt defaults become a problem. Oil exporting countries also find that the taxes they can collect fall significantly. As a result, energy-exporting countries are in far worse economic position once energy prices fall. Exporters of other commodities, such as metals, have a similar problem if prices fall.

In the last two paragraphs, I mentioned the impact on lenders and governments of rising or falling prices. Owners of properties are also affected by rising or falling prices. If prices rise, these owners can sell their assets, and make a profit. In fact, these owners have often purchased their properties with debt. If the price of the property rises, but the amount of debt is unaffected by inflation, the owner of the property can often get a disproportionate benefit of the price rise. Of course, if the value of a property falls, the property-owner is disproportionately affected by the fall of the price.

We are so used to a rising-price scenario that we have little understanding of how a flat or falling price scenario might work.

To get a little idea of how much inflation has in the past been working through to asset prices in the United States, I looked at some information provided by the US Bureau of Economic Analysis. I compared these amounts to GDP, rather than asset prices, to get an idea of how much impact they have, relative to each current year’s activities (Figure 7). There is about $3 of assets of the types BEA analyzes for every dollar of GDP, so the impact, relative to GDP is about three times as high it would be, relative to the asset prices themselves.

If this same relationship holds elsewhere, a person can see why a commodity-producing country might have a big problem, if the price of that commodity suddenly falls. There is huge “balance sheet” impact that doesn’t directly affect current GDP as reported (since GDP has to do with current goods and services produced). But it can have a major impact on the country, as it goes forward, because affected loans are much less likely to be repaid. Countries often try to be lenient with lenders, hoping that commodity prices will rise again. But if the drop in prices is permanent, countries must use more and more extreme measures to hide the problem of loans that have a low probability of repayment in a low-priced commodity environment. Eventually, these loans seem likely to default, if prices do not rise sufficiently. China and many commodity-exporting countries seem to be affected by this problem.

 

Figure 7. Changes to US Fixed Assets, based on BEA Table 5.10, Changes in Net Stocks of Produced Assets.

BEA shows three amounts of interest with respect to US assets (Figure 7):

  1. Inflation – Changes in asset values based on changes in the general price level
  2. Re-evaluation total – Changes to asset prices in particular; includes changes because assets are taken out of service because of disaster or because a business is no longer profitable. Note the spikes related to the housing bubble of the 2003-2006 period and the corresponding dip during the Great Recession of 2007-2009.
  3. Depreciation – Expected amount of new investment needed to offset “consumption of fixed capital.” This rate is quite high, (about 15.7% of GDP recently) because the asset base includes fairly quickly depreciating  assets, such as cars and computers, besides buildings of all types, and intellectual property such as computer programs.

The last year shown is 2015. Inflation (relative to GDP) was only 1.2%, and the re-evaluation total was only 0.3% of GDP. (Calculated as percentages of the assets involved, these inflation rates would be only a third of these amounts.) These low inflation rates make it very difficult to operate a debt-based economy. A shift from inflation to deflation would be a major problem. Unfortunately, it is very difficult to get much inflation, if the wages of non-elite workers remain very low.

Conclusion

We have kept our economy growing through growing debt use and growing energy use. I described this process in my post, What has gone wrong with oil prices, debt, and GDP growth?

Now we seem to be reaching the end of the line. The economy is getting very close to shrinking. When this happens, we are getting close to economic collapse–the economic circus is starting to “leave town.”

People who think our only problem is “running out” and “high oil prices” don’t see the problems the economy is reaching right now. These problems are much more subtle, but they can have a devastating effect. The Federal Reserve talks about inflation rates above 2% being too high, but inflation rates below 2% are at least equally problematic. Somehow, the debt system needs to keep operating for the whole system to work.

We are now at the point where the economy is decidedly unstable. Little things can affect it, like the Affordable Care Act requirement that uninsured people buy healthcare insurance, or pay a penalty. Low commodity prices make debt repayment more difficult in countries producing those commodities.

We should not be too surprised if the economic circus starts to leave to leave town. There are simply too many pieces that are now unstable. The US Government is facing a shutdown in the near future, unless its debt ceiling can be raised and funding can be enacted. The world is depending on China for economic growth, but China’s debt is becoming unmanageably high. Japan’s debt is also unreasonably high. Oil exporters are becoming increasingly unstable, with the continued low prices. We can find problems in almost every country of the world. It looks like it is only a matter of time, until one of these problems starts a downward spiral.

 

Note:

[1] Thanks to commenter “Lastcall” for this analogy.