How hot peppers and marijuana could help cure gut problems
Pope set to visit Egypt in call for peace
Top on #tiajobs today: Backend Developer at Pand.ai
Why dont voters get more angry about public spending cuts? asks @BobbyIpsosMORI
U.K. retail sales grew at their fastest annual pace in 19 months, according to the CBI
China military apologises for mocked photoshopped navy picture
Watch out for the fake hardware flooding the market
Sweet Pea Crostini @Simple_Seasonal #vegan
Overseas voters urged to have their say in the UK general election
Pradeep Rajans presentation on the #tanker markets at our #mumbaicommodityforum
New Aussie #solar start-up empowering rural farming villages
ASEAN to go easy on Beijing over South China Sea
Reading material just spotted in the local coffee shop.
New Buzzfeed News slogan: Reporting to You
Member states need to agree on a strong Circular Economy Package
Artist of the Year So Far: #Ghana
United Airlines CEO answers lawmakers on passenger dragging incident
Warren to Trump: You may not like it but the Constitution applies to you too
Liquidity: The Most Important of Fundamentals? $
Laugh out loud funny anecdote re Human Psychology via NASA via @dailydot
Trump rules out swift Nafta withdrawal in favor of renegotiation
Strong statement from Airbus CEO Tom Enders on being probed in Austria over a fighter jet sale.
If it looks like a trade war, swims like a trade war, quacks like a trade war (subscribers)
The world’s millionaires want this passport more than any other (hint: it’s European)
#Monacos expensive mansions beat Hong Kongs luxury homes via @bpolitics
Recode Daily: Trump’s first 100 ‘D’oh’s
Patagonia threatens to sue Trump over national monuments executive order
Markets are having a party, but Draghi wont be joining: @marcusashworth via @Bfly
There’s more undisclosed foreign cash in Jared Kushner’s business.
Trump backs off NAFTA withdrawal
‘Human Rights Nobel’ nomination for jailed Cambodians shines light on stifling of dissent
How ’13 Reasons Why’ essentially promotes teen suicide
Boris Johnsons mugwump line hides the fact the Tories message isnt true, says @stephenkb
Trump to sign executive order to easily oust bad VA employees
#IRAN is deepening its oil price index discounts to the world market in May. #OPEC #OOTT
Chinas #gold consumption up 14.73% in Q1 - China Gold Association - via @XHNews
Nationalist AfD party congress opens in Cologne
Asylum-seekers fleeing U.S. may find cold comfort in Canada’s courts:
How the selfie could make elections safer
Swiss watch exports in 1Q2017 vis-à-vis 1Q2016: -6.8% (= CHF323mio) chart EZV
Overseas voters urged to have their say in the UK general election
Overseas voters urged to have their say in the UK general election
Overseas voters urged to have their say in the UK general election
Overseas voters urged to have their say in the UK general election
Overseas voters urged to have their say in the UK general election
Overseas voters urged to have their say in the UK general election
Overseas voters urged to have their say in the UK general election
Norway ranked first for press freedoms in post-truth era
Zimbabwe Reacts to South African Police Ministers Comments #SouthAfrica #Zimbabwe
Italian president asks parliament to approve new electoral law urgently
Dem rep: Trumps tax plan voodoo economics on steroids
Hackers exploited #Word flaw for months while @Microsoft investigated
Frances Hermes joins trend of accelerating luxury sales growth
Lauri Love opens up about his fight against extradition to the US
#Burma up in arms over ‘first’ locally-made HD #porn flick
No One Should be Doomed to Just One Story: our roundtable on the popular podcast, S-Town.
How can Britain get fit for Brexit? asks @rcolvile
Anti-government protests have escalated again in Indian-administered Kashmir
Trump used to think the top rate of tax in the US should be raised to 50-60% #inequality
Overseas voters urged to have their say in the UK general election
Italy’s bad loans, chart @Bfly
Poll: Trump has lowest approval rating of any elected president at 100 day mark
Peyto Lake, Banff, Canada
Rooney insists hes got much more to offer is still young at 31 #mufc
Here are the national monuments being reconsidered under Trump. The full list at @latimes:
Cheater Sharapova should not be allowed to play again: Bouchard
Merkel warns Britons: Dont delude yourself over Brexit
Ireland’s strategy for EU and UK relations amid #Brexit via @bsurveillance @nejracehic
SAOTAs award-winning mountainside villa provides spectacular views of Cape Town:
#Philippines: #Duterte says no point raising #SouthChinaSea row during #aseansummit2017
Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-wen says phone call with Trump may happen again
Heres how to eat like @EmmaWatson
The best films about business
North Korea seeks #Asean support in row with US
Total Inventories and Prices Both Up - Drillinginfo
Latin American drilling hits record low
The truth behind the Uber flying cars headlines
Will California Say “Yes” To Volkswagen’s $800 Million Settlement?
Tech hype drives Didi Chuxing to $50 bln valuation
GOP vs Trump tax plans, from Citi. Take a moment and appreciate the figures involved here
Lawmaker calls grandmother of Internet troll who used slurs against him
Facebook, Google need to accept they are media not tech companies, says Martin Sorrell
Nintendo sees Switch console doubling full-year profit
10 disgusting ways your body betrays you in space:
Gold Regains Status As Tanzanias Top Export: #Tanzania
27 April 1956 - Heavyweight champ, Rocky Marciano, retires undefeated from boxing.
What do Parisians make of Marine Le Pens chances? #Presidentielle2017
Justin Trudeaus got to learn: Never try to make friends with a bully.
.@realDonaldTrump spent a quarter of first 100 days at Mar-a-Lago.
Study: People are Confused about Climate Change, Weather and Climate Definitions #tcot
Beauty App Meitu Reports 6.26 Billion Yuan Loss in 2016 #Meitu
#Malaysia: Nationalist group raises spectre of historic #May13 racial riot
Can anyone name a display-only data product on Wall Street (that has any value)?
UK could join fight in Syria without MPs approval
#Estonia says Russia may put troops in Belarus to challenge NATO By @rdfemmott via @Reuters
Palestinians on general strike in solidarity with hunger striking prisoners
Speak up! Why some TV dialogue is so hard to understand @thepengineer
Difficult legal path forward for Trump in sanctuary cities case
State and local governments extremely concerned with Trumps tax plan
End of Joseph Kony Hunt Breeds Frustration and Fear: #EastAfrica
Call for Defining Role of Parties in Burundi Talks Process: #EastAfrica
Zhejiang Jinzhou wins CNOOC Ltd pipeline supply contract
Rosneft and Statoil strike out in Sea of Okhotsk
Following The 1Q17 OCTG Inventory Audit Trail
SABIC/Exxon settle on Texas site
#NAFTA: Trump plans to negotiate the trade agreement rather than canceling it
#Philippines to pay #SouthKorea token $100 for anti-submarine warship
South Africa: Business confidence wanes in April. #SMI
#Israel Industrial Production year-on-year at 0.5%
#Israel Industrial Production month-on-month at -2.5%
Grass-free lawns FAQ lots more info Native plants keeping pollinators happy! CC @Sydney843
How to vote.
Reprieve for the peso and the loonie after Trumps flip-flop on Nafta via @business
GOP senator warns Trump: Leaving NAFTA would be disastrously bad
Interview with Geetam Tiwari: Mobility and Climate Solutions in Indian Cities
Hermes boosts Made in France as Macron, Le Pen joust over jobs via @RobW_U
8 endangered @UNESCO sites to see now:
Asias football governing body charges Guangzhou Evergrande over British dog banner
Heres my column on the Trump tax plan:
South Korea at a turning point
Bourses lower, Wall St pulls back | Market Minute
Hanks celebrates Demmes inclusive nature
This is Other services in China yesterday and today. No other data has changed
US dollar holds gains; Canadian dollar, Mexican peso surge on NAFTA relief via @Reuters
Harvard Study: Minimum Wage Hike Forcing Businesses to Close in San Francisco #tcot
Pressure on #Indonesia as #WorldPressFreedomDay looms @maxwalden_
Monacos expensive mansions beat Hong Kongs luxury homes v
3 questions to re-evaluate your business model in the midst of the sharing economy
A portrait of Americans who have never been to libraries
Fox News host under fire for remark about Ivanka Trump
Heres what you need to know today in finance, business and dealmaking
Opinion: Has resistance become a way of life for Kashmiri youth? by @aziakashmir
Put a price on the costs of disasters, says U.N. risk chief #ClimateChange
Our closest look ever at #Saturn’s atmosphere and giant hurricane. #GrandFinale
Amazing x-axis duration I still think they should have bitten the hand off $PFEs offer... $AZN
Former MP Bob Marshall-Andrews: Why I’m leaving Labour and joining the Lib Dems
Samsung rejects push to convert into a holding company a profit tops estimates
The Savamala case: A year without progress
I see Angela Merkel is stating the obvious again
If you speak only Arabic, you can operate in 1/3 of Africas GDP, English gives you at least 2/3, French is 1/4
Comment: 100-day record of Donald Trump’s imagination is a far cry from the reality
#Gold falls, but doubts over Trump tax plan cap losses via @ReutersIndia
ZTE to Build World’s Largest vSDM in Bangladesh #ZTECorp #Bangladesh #VSDM
Poll: Majority of Americans believe Russia interfered in presidential election
Where are all the graduates? Italy has second lowest percentage in the EU
Policeman accidentally shoots colleague dead in eastern France
Country risk: Italy is the volcano waiting to erupt /Euromoney magazine
Israel linked to series of blasts in Damascus
#Gold Currency Index (Top 20 GDP Weighted) vs Gold in US Dollar (Apr. 26, 2017) - via
Deregulation of the net will be a huge step back for consumers - is all lost? asks @outline
Lets play spot the Taoiseach!
Top euro officials eye May agreement on Greek loans
LBMA #Gold Price (AM) is USD 1,264.30, EUR 1,160.63 (Apr. 27, 2017)
Ofo, Didi Chuxing Partner Up to Share the Ride #DidiChuxing #Ofo
Hot Switch sales boost Nintendo sales, trim quarterly loss
Another Race Hoax? Non-Student Created ‘No Black People Allowed’ Sign at USC #tcot
Cathay broadens and deepens eco initiatives
Trump says he’s “absolutely” considering breaking up court that ruled against him
Bitcoins DC Debut: All Eyes Watch the US Governments Response
Swedish woman shocked at SAS uniform policy banning headscarves
Global Manufacturing: New factory orders improve in April. #SMI
Trump and Putin may meet ahead of the G20 summit.
United to offer passengers up to $10,000 to surrender seats
Scared of crackdown? China’s stocks offer cheap sanctuary
Two referendums have revived the Tories and undone Labour, writes @georgeeaton
What a Macron victory in France means for markets via @bpolitics
RBC on #CAD and #MXN rallying after #Trump decision not to tear up #NAFTA #forex #FX #FXnews
End of Joseph Kony hunt breeds frustration and fear: (@irinnews)
This tactical pen is a gadget worthy of 007 himself
South African Music Duo Mafikizolo to Perform in Zimbabwe #Zimbabwe
The NS QA: @NaomiAllthenews on Oprah, Ovid, and Buffy The Vampire Slayer
If you want to #retire early, follow these 6 savings life hacks from people who actually did
#Israel Imports at $5689.7M
South Koreas economy grows at fastest pace in 3 quarters
#Israel Balance of #Trade at $-1036.1M
#Israel Exports at $4653.6M
Rigging up: How to pack for a month drilling oil
7 April 1865. The US steamboat Sultana exploded and sank in the Mississippi River, killing 1,800 people.
A technique called neurofeedback could be helpful for people with moderate depression
Laurene Powell Jobs and Kamala Harris are coming to Code
A fascinating look behind the scenes at North Koreas film academy
Orbán: Hungary has no big issue with EU, it has a problem with Soros
‘World’s most secure’ email service is easily hackable
Video: ATMs in Singapore get personal with live video support
GOP lawmaker: I dont think anyone expects literal border wall with Mexico
South African Chief Justice Named African Judicial Congress Chief #Africa #SouthAfrica
Commission supports Greek efforts to return to growth, #Avramopoulos says:
Ugandan Singer Bobi Wine to Run for MP Kyadondo East Seat? #Uganda
Action Needed to Help End the Killing of Feral #Cats and #Kittens! #AnimalRights #Pets
Fox News Jesse Watters takes abrupt vacation after controversial remarks about Ivanka Trump
Trump tells Canada and Mexico he wont terminate the NAFTA treaty after all
Syrias hexamine: a smoking gun |
The UK goes coconut crazy, says @Pret a Manger @BBCBusiness
France: ‘Neither Macron nor Le Pen’ - Students barricade school entrance in protest
POLL: Trumps border wall is voters lowest priority in the government-shutdown fight
Boris Johnson says it will be difficult to say no if Trump asks Britain to attack Syria
Stocks are giving a collective thumbs down to Trumps tax plan
Polio could make a comeback under Trumps budget, Gates Foundation fears
Observatories around the world to capture image of a black hole
Auray, en Bretagne
Could a New Single-Dose Drug Help Wipe Out Malaria?: #SouthAfrica
Why Jio is throwing money at market share, from Crisil:
Liberal Indoctrination Camps Start at Kindergarten #tcot
Merkel: Britain has illusions about how easy Brexit will be
.@GorillaSaver doing well on his epic #LondonMarathon. Nr westferry. Go #MrGorilla
#Italy 5-Year BTP Auction at 1.04%
Brief: China’s Didi to be valued $50b after reported $6b round
Carl Bernstein: Flynn a key to helping FBI unravel cover-up of Trump ties to Russia
Does #nuclear power still have a future?
Noam Chomsky on alleged Syria gas attack
Global Services: Business confidence remains strong in April. #SMI
A new report finds that NASAs spacewalking suits are in short supply
Secret no more, French candidates private lives scrutinised in 2017 presidential election
BioRxiv preprint server gets cash boost from Chan Zuckerberg Initiative:
#Spain Business Confidence at 0.1
Trump to sign executive order to easily oust bad VA employees
Hollande wasn’t destined to be president; his ascension was an aberration, says @politico
Chinese farmers deploy pesticide drones to overcome labour shortage
#Italy 10-Year BTP Auction at 2.29%
Our panel takes questions from the audience at the #mumbaicommodityforum
Mosquitos have adapted their feeding times to avoid bed nets, study finds. →
Poland to receive its first LNG supplies from US in June
Is Labour really as doomed as it seems? The polls have got it wrong before, says @gsoh31
Boris Johnsons mugwump line hides the fact the Tories message isnt true, says @stephenkb
Our quote of the day is from English writer and intellectual Mary Wollstonecraft
Macau Balance of #Trade at MOP-5.35B
@J_Dijsselbloem *tries* to defend his record on the Greek programme in the EP.
EXPLAINER: The limits of missile defense systems via @dw_scitech #THAAD #SouthKorea
Welcome to Conflict Zone, Mr @Nigel_Farage!
#SouthKoreas Q1 GDP expands at fastest in 3 quarters on exports, capex
Obama spokesman defends $400k speaking fee for Wall Street speech
Winners and losers from Trump’s new tax plan
What happens when @Google turns artists loose on its search data... more via @FastCoDesign
As Venezuela declines, so does its Latin American influence
Steve Bell, an economist at BMO Global Asset Management, talks Nafta and Trumps tax plan
The area is a major tourist hub and receives 45 million visitors each year.
China’s industrial profits soar on building boom but pace slowing
Worlds biggest cities in 2015 and 2030. (via HSBC)
This map of all the nuclear reactors in the world is a reality check:
#Turkey suspends more than 9,000 police officials on suspected #Gulen links
German soldier disguised himself as refugee to carry out terror attack
Marine Le Pens fake jobs cost EU parliament €5 million
The last time that Dubai-Brent #oil EFS traded at 50¢ a barrel I didnt have (almost) any grey hair #OOTT #OPEC
Empty Pearl River Delta branches a check on HSBCs China plan
Pound strengthens as Banco Santander says currency still cheap via @anoojad @johnainger
#Amazon to create 1,200 jobs at warehouse in Warrington, Cheshire
Taiwan has attracted the most equity inflows this year. Thats pushed the Taiwan Dollar exchange rate to 30
Heres the cold LinkedIn message that prompted a CEO to give the sender a job
Raw: Large Explosion Shakes Damascus, Syria


Tyler Durden
Scientific Proof ETFs Make Markets Dumber
8 days ago




One of the horses we have beaten to death starting in 2013 (with Why The TBAC Is Suddenly Very Worried About Market Liquidity) is that the relentless growth in ETFs in particular, and passive investing in general, is one of the greatest threats facing the US equity market for one main reason: "phantom liquidity", and specifically the thought experiment, conducted back in March 2015 by Howard Marks, of what happens if and when the ETF selling begins.

This is what we said one week ago:

The relentless growth of passive investing in general, and ETFs in particular, has been extensively discussed on the pages over the past few years, most recently overnight when we presented a note from Convergex which laid out some ideas how investors can profit from the unstoppable - for now - shift from active, and expensive, management to cheaper, passive forms of asset allocation. Others, such as One River's Eric Peters gave a decidedly more downbeat outlook on what the creeping growth of ETFs means for capital markets and price formation, warning that “there is no such thing as price discovery in index investing. And there will be no price discovery on the downside either. The stocks that have been blindly bought on the way up will be blindly sold."

 

That simplified analysis touches on the biggest threat facing ETF investors: namely "phantom liquidity" of what has effectively become the market's biggest quasi-derivative product. In a nutshell, the threat here is that what is traditionally considered to be the market's most liquid instrument, would be unable to satisfy a massive redemption wave due to a huge liquidity mismatch between the synthetic product, the ETF itself, and its underlying instruments, particularly in various types of debt ETFs.

The head of the BOE Mark Carney himself has warned about the risk of "disorderly unwinding of portfolios" due to the lack of market liquidity."

"Market adjustments to date have occurred without significant stress. However the risk of a sharp and disorderly reversal remains given the compressed credit and liquidity risk premia," Carney told a news conference after a meeting of the FSB.

 

"As a result, market participants need to be mindful of the risks of diminished market liquidity, asset price discontinuities and contagion across asset markets."

And then there was, of course, Howard Marks, who mused in his "Liquidity" note:

ETF’s have become popular because they’re generally believed to be “better than mutual funds,” in that they’re traded all day. Thus an ETF investor can get in or out anytime during trading hours, whereas with mutual funds he has to wait for a pricing at the close of business. “If you’re considering investing,” the pitch goes, “why do so through a vehicle that can require you to wait hours to cash out?” But do the investors in ETFs wonder about the source of their liquidity?

Now, in addition to the persistent liquidity threat from ETFs, we can add two more troubling concerns about ETFs: in addition to making markets more illiquid and discontinuous (recall August 24, 2015), a new scientific study has found that exchange-traded funds also make markets dumber... oh and more expensive.

That, as Bloomberg notes, is the finding of researchers at Stanford University, Emory University and the Interdisciplinary Center of Herzliya in Israel. They’ve uncovered evidence that higher ownership of individual stocks by ETFs widens the bid-ask spreads in those shares, making them more expensive to trade and therefore less attractive.

While it will hardly come as a surprise to traders who notice the pattern every single day, there is now scientific proof that of the phenomenon that stocks eventually turn into drones that move in lockstep with their industry. As Bloomberg points out, it makes life harder for traders seeking informational edges by offering fewer opportunities to capitalize on insights into earnings and other signals. The study is the latest to point out signs of diminished efficiency in markets increasingly overrun by the funds.

“ETFs are clearly an important development in financial markets, which have brought many well-documented benefits to investors,” researchers Doron Israeli, Charles Lee and Suhas Sridharan wrote in a paper last month. “Our evidence suggests the growth of ETFs may have (unintended) long-run consequences for the pricing efficiency of the underlying securities.”

What the study found is that a single percentage point increase in ETF ownership has demonstrable effects on an individual stock. Over the ensuing year, correlation to the share’s industry group and the broader market ticks up 9 percent, while the relationship between its price and future earnings falls 14 percent. Meanwhile, bid-ask spreads rise 1.6 percent and absolute returns grow 2 percent.

The cause? Unsophisticated investors and the ways they buy securities.

Before index funds, Bloomberg adds, traders who thought they knew something others didn’t could turn a profit in transactions with less informed buyers of individual stocks. That disadvantaged cohort now buys ETFs, locking up securities that traders once could pick off when price discrepancies arose.

The detrimental effects to the market snowball from there. Fewer trades occur, so liquidity in single stocks deteriorates, raising transaction costs. That only further discourages professional traders, so the price discrepancies remain without the informational arbitrage to close the gaps.

 

Making matters worse, the reduced interest in individual equities also results in less analyst coverage, the researchers argue.

To be fair, this is not the first time proof was demonstrated that tighter correlations and a dumber market are a consequences of index fund. In fact, as Bloomberg adds, it is well trodden territory in doomsday ETF literature. A Virginia Tech paper in 2014 found that fewer signals about corporate performance seeped into prices over time because of passive investing. Instead, the investors arrive all at once when earnings results are disclosed.

* * *

Incidentally, in a separate report posted over the weekdn by Goldman Sachs, the firm found that "unabated passive growth" and index investing has lead to "suboptimal allocations for capital." This is what Goldman reported on the issue:

  • Passive investing, led by ETF growth, has delivered superior returns at lower fees (in many cases) than active managers over the last decade. If the best measure of success in an investing world is performance (return per unit of risk) one other indicator would be AUM growth. Indeed the growth in these products, as seen below, has been unabated.
  • With the runaway growth of these products we ask if following an index is the optimal allocation for capital. Namely we run an analysis juxtaposing the ROIC v WACC of the S&P 500 by weights of the underlying stocks. We find that it is not.
  • FOMO. For market cap weighted instruments concentration of securities drives the need to not to stray too far away from benchmarks given the fear of missing a larger weighted name’s performance.

Obviously, the allegation that the market has become a more inefficient allocator of capital is simply another way of saying it has become dumber.

And all thanks to the Fed, which as we showed earlier this week is the primary cause for the "deplorable" returns by the active community, and hedge funds in particular.

Of course, as long as the general direction of the market is higher, all inefficiencies that have developed are masked by the proverbial "rising tide" but one day the selling will arrive, and what will make that particular sell off is that nobody has any idea how it will end.

We leave the parting word to Troy Draizen, global head of electronic trading at Convergex Executive Solutions, who said “ETF’s are a great innovation, but an over-population of any innovation could cause unintended consequences if left unmonitored. We have seen this in many market cycles, from dot-com to the credit crisis." This time won't be different.