Looking for a real soul connection? You can never ask enough questions @Ecochickie
Scientists brace for climate-fund cutoff From @ivansemeniuk
Incompetent Teachers Face Demotion, Dismissal: #Uganda
Hanging out at Hellfest
Suppliers Take Nakumatt to Court Over Debt: #EastAfrica
Govt Eyeing Cluster Centers to Fast Track Industrialization: #Ethiopia
#NotInMyName – Indians protest vigilante attacks on Muslims
Why have we had to rely on hackers to stop catastrophic ransomware again? asks @jm_stout
Will CNN learn from its mistakes? Prepare to be disappointed
#Venezuela’s supreme court attacked with grenades from police helicopter
Finance squeeze hits Afghan mine clearers
Florida wildfire cuts interstate highway
Evicted Tenant Leaves Boxes of Tarantulas Behind
Rate-cutting race among BRICS outliers rits Russia versus Brazil
Spicer will headline a GOP fundraiser in Rhode Island
.@USATODAY gets woke, discovers capitalism.
BOFI Federal Savings: Disclosing Little, And Saying Less $
Ex-police chiefs charged over UKs 1989 Hillsborough stadium disaster that killed 96:
This is how blockchains could revolutionize international aid:
Opposition Manifesto Promises Higher Wages for Kenyans #Kenya
The New York subways success is causing it to fail
Paddington Bear creator Michael Bond dies at 91 From @GlobeBooks
Minister Samuel Moncada We will capture him and bring him to justice.
Is social mobility beyond the government’s control?
May signals UK public-sector pay may rise ahead of key vote via @TimRoss_1
If Americas 55 million Latinos were a country, it would be the worlds 7th-largest economy:
SIGN UP to receive a free daily digest of best in energy news + my research notes by emailing john.kemp@tr.com
Why the conservative gainsaying of Medicaid’s effectiveness is so infuriating.
German audience laughs and cheers after Trump Cabinet members speech cut off
Japans JXTG settles Q2 #HSFO price 6.2% lower from Q1 on weaker #oil price. Full story
Minister Samuel Moncada We will capture him and bring him to justice.
Fresh cyberattack likely ‘more sophisticated’ than WannaCry: Europol
Stamped from the Beginning: Ibram X. Kendi on the History of Racist Ideas in U.S.
Meat processor cuts deal with ABC in pink slime defamation case
A Look at Uncertainty in the UK, Post-Election | Daniel Lacalle
@mises
The WOKEST take on Goldilocks youll see today
Democrats have hired Raffi Krikorian, a former Uber exec, as their chief technology officer
Grenades dropped from helicopter on Venezuela’s Supreme Court building
Learners Allegedly Strip Searched for Cheat Notes - Opposition Party: #SouthAfrica
Trump’s lawyers will postpone filing a complaint against Comey with DOJ, source says
CFTC Chief Asks Congress for More Money to Oversee Blockchain
Pakistan issues landmark transgender passport; fight for rights goes on
NSA spying scandal committee presents controversial final report
Obama received much higher ratings at the end of his presidency than Trump gets today
Por vezes ainda me surpreende que estejamos só agora a resolver enormidades deste calibre (do @JNegocios de hoje)
Yemen: Worlds worst cholera outbreak mapped
When trying to survive while homeless is made illegal
The Mathematics of Machine Learning #machinelearning #mathematics
What is lost when teachers cant afford to live near students? asks Andrew Simmons
CNN launching new brand featuring Chris Cillizza
US Recreation Index for June: 78.2, previous: 77.3 (change: 1.1%) #WPI
Beijing is weakening Hong Kongs rule of law. How far will it go? #HKSAR20
Verizon jumps on the AI-security bandwagon @BankingTechno
How mirror trades moved billions out of Russia
Trump calls Washington Post fake news over report about fake Time magazine covers:
Euro v. pound: which one will come out on top?
A sign to go slow on raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour, says @Noahpinion
These charts show U.S. threat from foreign steel is overblown via @daniel_flatley
Global #Stocks Fall on Jitters over #CentralBanks Policy
Paddington Bear creator Michael Bond dies aged 91
Kenyan author ditches Swedish book fair over far-right newspaper
Clarity Or Confusion $
10 facts about smartphones as the iPhone turns 10
Magufuli Bids Farewell to Presidents Delivery Bureau Workers: #Tanzania
How a computer virus spread from Ukraine to disrupt world business: #ReutersCyber #CyberRisk
Mouse droppings, beetle bits found in German bakeries
CNN reporter fires back: Sean Hannity needs a hug
Ashton Kutcher: Were getting close to the point where acting can be automated
‘Evil’ Brussels vs. ‘good’ Prague: Czech MEPs want to change EU’s image
#German legislators approve disbursement of loan installment to #Greece
#Iran Annual #Inflation at 11.8%
Carney makes his Mark. Sterling rises vs dollar for 6th day in a row, its best run since March last year.
The changing face of jihadism in Switzerland
How Vienna solved homelessness (via @crosscut) #500khomeless
Will grad students lose the right to unionize under Trump? asks @AlanaSemuels
Russia doubles down on criticism of US for alleging Syria is planning a new chemical attack
Global borrowing hits record as big central banks prepare to tighten credit via @Reuters
@sigrunda
Trump is waging a new kind of Cold War — and millions of jobs are on the front line
Philippines: Market Growth continues to grow but at a reduced rate in June. #SMI
Opinion: Will Albania descend into chaos as Macedonia did? by @dimitarbechev:
Meal-kit maker Blue Apron slashes its valuation expectations by a third. More here:
The New Statesman Leader: Labour and the Brexit debacle
France to legislate on assisted reproduction
Chinese reporters say blocked from #SichuanLandslide coverage
Scarborough: State Department is rotting under Tillerson
BlackRocks Rosenberg doubts market misjudged Draghi via @markets
Our must-read @CapX email now comes with a Stat of the Day. Like this bad boy
11 of the best new low-budget projects in the US:
Trump lawyer routed millions of dollars to his family through nonprofits: report
Five Primary Beneficiaries Of Rising U.S. Oil Exports
Lacy Hunt: The Fed Has Undermined The Economy’s Ability To Grow $
4/6: Municipal #default volume driven by local governments and #utilities #muniland
President Jacob Zuma Congratulates BET Award Winner Yvonne Chaka Chaka: #SouthAfrica
Graphic - Trump, Draghi, Fed doubts: is the US dollar rally done? via @Reuters
JUST IN: Trump accepts Macrons invitation to visit France next month
Women fire fighters during a training exercise at the Pearl Harbor Naval Shipyard, during World War II, circa 1941.
The Supreme Court just made it harder to survive death row
Is Korroding trying to steal Carnage’s wedding ring?!
Narrower U.S. trade gap may boost growth pace in second quarter
See the latest addition to Chinas rapidly expanding navy:
Groom A Successor, Minister Tells Mugabe #Zimbabwe
Yes, Bitcoin is a bubble and it’s about to burst by @jessefelder
German judge Kabisch removed from Auschwitz trial for bias
Iron ore jumps back above $60
Winning: New poll shows only 12% of Americans support the Senate version of #TrumpCare.
Notes abt commodities $JJG $DBA $DBC $GSG u know...
2 Out of 6 Aspirants Qualify to Run For Rwandas Presidency #Rwanda
Rand Paul: These weak-kneed Republicans need to get over themselves
Latest API Report Causes Drop in Prices
The living wage debate cant ignore healthcare
Google should try a little harder for online shoppers
Plans to address fund manager failings unveiled by City watchdog
Cathcart signs new deal with Watford to stay until 2021
Were in! Nearly 200 U.S. mayors have already joined the 2017 #MayorsChallenge. Will you?
Energy deals drive Canadian MA to the strongest start in a decade
Reporter who went off on White House during press briefing: It was a long time coming
Idaho restaurant owner apologizes for tasteless ‘blackface’ ad campaign
New Post: #Crude Oil Sinks 20%: Why Oversupply Isnt the Half of It #EconMatters
Democrats had good turnout in the special election Georgia. But that wasnt enough.
Many units of measurements are named after scientists. Here are their stories:
Can Melbourne lower its temperature by 4 degrees?
#DonaldTrump to visit #Paris for #BastilleDay at Macron’s invitation
U.K. cabinet cracks are appearing as Theresa May seeks to negotiate a Brexit deal
This is what it sounds like when doves screech via @robbrand @markets
Trump is to stocks as pensions are to bonds
Kushner is adding a seasoned scandal lawyer to his team
The beauty products Meghan Markle is rumoured to love
Djokovic bumped up to two in Wimbledon seedings
Commentary: The biggest victims of the Senate healthcare bill (and other Trump plans)
Germany Durable Goods Price Index for June: 115.6, previous: 115.6 (change: 0%) #WPI
Montreals reputation as affordable housing haven strained by rising prices in some areas
We’re Working More—and Sleeping Less by @andrewvandam
Google wont take the Brussels onslaught lying down via @gadfly
Stocks have become so expensive that central bankers are weighing in again
The Bank of England hawks are not for turning via @BW
Take a peek inside Ben Westerman from HM Capital Managements portfolio #ETFs
#AAPL Daily Please RT + Register for next weeks Free Webinar: …
A failed $6 billion deal shows how index funds can ruin your takeover
University of Cape Town Denies Evictions for Non-Payment of Fees: #SouthAfrica
NAFTA: Price inflation eases in June but remains firm. #SMI
Latest API report causes drop in oil prices
Morocco Offers Lessons for Regional Integration: #Africa
Six-month-old baby was found dead in mothers arms following #GrenfellTower fire
Nuclear waste-carrying ship sets sail for first time on German river
Model Miranda Kerr turns over $8 million worth of jewelry to the Justice Department
Hamburg discharges Berlin police after drunken party
FBI Interviews Employees of Russia-Linked Cyber Security Firm Kasperky Lab via @SteveKopack
Pound jumps as Carneys hawkish tone sends gilts tumbling via @johnainger
Interesting, Breitbart has nothing about the EU-Google decision on its front page. Drudge does.
.@NATOmission_ru: NATO troops are now in places of Eastern Europe where they never have been and never should be
U.S. DISTILLATE STOCKS fell -0.2 million bbl to 152 million bbl in week to Jun 23
New museum opens for finance fans
Rockwave | Athens | June 30 - July 2
A perfect day on Oahus north shore #hawaii #travel
Kazantzakis in England | Iraklio | July 12-16
A new tool from @MIT_Picower and @Stanford researchers offers snapshots of neuron activity.
The first evidence that painful memories can be safely erased.
Parthenon Film Festival | Halkidiki | July 14-16
Petra Diamonds shares tumble as setbacks test debt covenants
BP pushes Artificial Intelligence Beyond Limits
Evicted Student Doctor Takes University to Court: #Zimbabwe
Cabin Crew to Lay Corruption Charges Against SAA Execs, Board: #SouthAfrica
CNN war with Trump gets personal:
Hamas creates no-go security zone on border with Egypt
UAE unaffected by new wave of global cyberattacks - TRA
Mexican singer Lila Downs rejects Trump’s anti-Cuba policies
Britains big new warship runs Windows XP
#BREAKING: Trump accepts Macrons invitation to visit France
Conservatives’ excuses for kicking millions off of health care don’t make any sense.
Last nights moon with earthshine near bright star Regulus via Eliot Herman in Tucson
A tale of two networks: How Fox News and CNN handled recent retractions
In Western European countries, confidence in the U.S. president has declined sharply.
ECB worried by US plan for looser bank rules
US EAST COAST GASOLINE STOCKS rose +0.6 million bbl to 68 million bbl in week to Jun 23
U.S. EAST COAST GASOLINE STOCKS continue to tighten versus 2016 and 10-yr average as regional glut slowly clears
Enjoy Arbys.
Florida wildfire cuts interstate highway
Cobie Smulders meets Friends from College
Magic Spot: Camp Cecil on Mexicos Isla Santo Espiritu
Le discours du gouvernement sur les migrants inquiète les ONG via @EurActiv_FR
Cash-rich Sweden squirrels away ahead of demographic time bomb
The moment @joshuawongcf was forced into a police van #HKSAR20
#Venezuela: Helicopter Strafes Court in while #NicolasMaduro Speaks in ‘Terrorist Attack’
Colombias Marxist guerrilla group the FARC, officially disarm, ending 52 years of fighting.
Prince William and David Cameron implicated in Fifa #WorldCup corruption scandal
France says Trump accepts invitation to attend July 14 Paris celebrations via @Reuters
Madrid metro drivers call strike during WorldPride
Paul Singer Says Joke Is On Developed World Economies Who Steal Growth From the Future $
ICYMI: North Koreas chemical weapon deterrent #sarin #VX
More Than 250 US Mayors Commit To 100% Renewable Energy Amidst Adoption Of New…
NSA spying scandal committee presents controversial final report
GOP senator says Trump doesnt understand basic elements of healthcare bill: report
Newest burger at Sonic blends beef w/ mushrooms so you eat less meat | @FastCompany #climate
Euro Hits High Against The US Dollar, UK Pound And 10 Year Sov Yield Rise as BofE and ECB…
congratulations to the person who found the most threatening way to phrase this appeal
The Supreme Court just made being on death row even worse
Research Affiliates On Equity Returns By Political Party – An International Look $
Minister acted unlawfully in not stopping Lough Neagh sand dredging says court of appeal
Let science be a springboard for politics. Do you agree?
Haley and Mattis credit White House statement with stopping Syria chemical attack
Approach All Claims Of Market-Beating Formula With Extreme Skepticism
Paddington Bear creator Michael Bond dies aged 91
GTM Predicts 27% Drop In Solar Prices By 2022
EURUSD is up even though the ECB is pumping speculators breaks. Cable is up because of Carney. Real winner: $EURGBP
Warren Buffett: GOP healthcare bill should be called Relief for the Rich Act
Italy threatens EU with closure of ports to rescue boats
U.K. Cabinets Mixed Message on Brexit Bridging Deal @simonjkennedy @tomkeene @guyjohnsontv
COSAFA Cup - Sable Antelopes, Taifa Stars in Goalless Draw: #Angola #Tanzania
FREE: Markets want #US #shale producers to slow down - for the sake of prices #OOTT
#IPCapitalPartners 1Q17 – Pricing Power
:LOL - Dual mandate. Theres only one mandate.
David v Goliath battle between one woman and a corporate giant. Coming soon. Watch this space!
U.S. GASOLINE STOCKS fell -0.9 million bbl to 241 million bbl in the week to Jun 23
Even the Magic 8-ball prefers Gmail.
Pound climbs towards $1.30 as BoE gov Mark Carney hints at interest-rate hike
I was told there would be no Peterson Institute today.
Namibia Ruling Party Politician Hikopua in Car Crash: #Namibia
Dont Regulate Drones Like Theyre Missiles | @mchorowitz @BulletinAtomic
This AI can predict how rich your neighborhood is from space
Wave Power Could Contribute 10% Of Global Electricity Demand By 2050
Malawi to Impose Curfew On Night Buses, Trucks - Report: #Malawi
Carney says #BOE may need to remove stimulus as slack erodes via @UKeconews
Police Arrest Student Leaders After Fees Demonstration: #Zimbabwe
Six charged over #Hillsborough stadium disaster
China frees activists arrested after investigating labor conditions at Ivanka shoe factory
Dont Abandon Patriotism, Kaunda Reminds Africa: #Africa
Equities Turn So Hot Even Central Bankers Are Taking Notice via @SofiaHC1 @markets
The Feds Bullard crashes the panel!
#Gold edges higher as dollar faces further weakness @MarketWatch
Blockchain Startup ChromaWay to Launch Hybrid Database Product
Is it really possible to make an ethical smartphone?
In 2012, the global satellite industry generated 189.5 billion dollars.
India Petrol Price Index for June: 100.6, previous: 103.4 (change: -2.8%) #WPI
Protest against nationwide mob lynchings at Delhi’s Jantar Mantar, as part of #NotInMyName campaign
Gasoline demand
U.S. REFINERY THROUGHPUT fell -262,000 b/d to 16.9 million b/d in the week to Jun 23
Entitlement reform is finally here—and its ugly
The ocean is a powerful, but fragile force. Now its changing in unpredictable ways
Fecal bacteria found in Costa, Starbucks and Caffe Nero
Designing dignity in housing for Chicagos most vulnerable (via @nextcity) #500Khomeless
Medicaid funding cuts will have painful consequences for seniors
What Was So Innocent about the Gilded Age? | @jeffreyatucker
#FairTax17 .@LehtoKatja @etuc_ces about to take the floor on Stakeholders role in shaping taxation policies
Britain is shifting TO THE LEFT as the public rejects austerity, study finds. #ToriesOut
US NET CRUDE IMPORTS remained very steady at 7.5 million b/d in the week to Jun 23 (little changed from prior weeks)
Making Ivanka Trump shoes: Long hours, low pay and abuse
Most Uphold Baker’s Right to Refuse Gay Wedding Cake... #BeakingPoll


Timothy Taylor
State and Local Government Business Incentives: Data Tells a Story
1 month ago




When a state or local government offers a tax incentive to a business for locating or expanding in its jurisdiction, cross-cutting motives are at work. For the business, it's a chance to get a tax break--maybe for a business decision that would have happened anyway. For the government, it's a chance to show that it's "doing something" to help the economy and to claim credit for the location or growth of certain businesses--even if those are business decisions that would have happened anyway. The issue of the extent to which tax incentives actually alter business decisions or help a local economy overall is difficult to sort out, but for any social scientist, the starting point is to have some actual data.

Timothy J. Bartik has compiled "A New Panel Database on Business Incentives for Economic Development Offered by State and Local Governments in the United States" (Upjohn Institute, February 2017). For a short overview of this work, see Bartik's article "Better Incentives Data Can Inform both Research and Policy" in the Upjohn Institute Employment Research newsletter for April 2017. As Bartik writes in the newsletter:
"Using data from 1990 to 2015, the “Panel Database on Incentives and Taxes” estimates marginal business taxes and business incentives for 45 industries in 33 states; the industries compose 91 percent of U.S. labor compensation, and the states produce over 92 percent of U.S. economic output. The database has data for a new facility starting up in each of 26 “start years.” Compared to prior studies, the new database provides more incentive details, such as how incentives are broken down by different incentive types (e.g., job creation tax credits vs. property tax abatements), and the time pattern by which incentives are paid out over a facility’s life cycle." 
For some questions, it can be hard to extract an answer from data, and involved a lot of assumptions and calculations. But for some questions, the data comes close to telling the story. 

For example, are state and local tax incentives for business rising or falling in the last 25 years? Here's a figure. Here's a time trend in business incentives, expressed as a percentage of the gross stat and local taxes paid by business. Clearly, the level is dramatically higher than 25 years ago. Bartik notes that a big reason for the jump around the year 2000 is the expansion of the "Empire Zone" incentives in New York. 


Of course, this overall increase conceals differences across states.
"From 2001 to 2007, big increases in incentives occurred in New Mexico, Missouri, Indiana, North Carolina, Nebraska, and Texas. This includes some Southern and Midwest states plus the Great Plains state of Nebraska and the southwestern state of New Mexico. Over this same time period, New York significantly reduced incentives, from 5.79 percent to 5.20 percent, although New York incentives remained high. From 2007 to 2015, big incentive increases occurred in Tennessee, New Jersey, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Colorado, Oregon, and Arizona. What is noteworthy here is that some states that previously had very low incentives, such as Tennessee, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Colorado, and Oregon, began to use incentives at a much higher level. But over this same time period, big decreases in incentives occurred in New York, Michigan, and Missouri. The big decreases in New York were due to the demise of the Empire Zone program. In Michigan, Governor Rick Snyder jettisoned the expensive MEGA incentive program as part of a policy package that rolled back general business taxes. The Missouri decrease is due to the Quality Jobs program (a JCTC) being replaced with a less costly job creation tax credit, Missouri Works."
Looking at the data also can raise some basic questions about the structure of these incentives, both in terms of the form in which the incentives are being provided and in terms of the extent to which such incentives are front-loaded.

Here's the issue with front-loading incentives. A business thinking about making a location or an expansion decision is focused on the relatively short-term. Bartik cites an estimate that businesses often discount revenues earned off in the future by about 12% per year. As a result, a tax break that is 10 or 20 years in the future decisions has relatively little effect on their decision. However, for the government, that tax break is very likely to end up being cashed in--at least if the business continues over that time.

Thus, if a state or local tax incentive is spread over a long period of time, the government is effectively offering something of real cost (the tax break), which doesn't affect the business decision all that much. If business incentives are to be offered at all, it makes more sense to front-load them. The figure shows the pattern of tax incentives over tine in Oregon (black line), which heavily front-loads incentives, and in Tennessee (green line), which doesn't front-load much. The blue line shows the overall pattern in the data in 2000, and the red line shows the data pattern for 2015--showing that front-loading has become just a little more common in the last 15 years.
Bartik writes: "As of 2015, in the average U.S. state, incentives are substantially front-loaded. This front-loading has increased over time, but front-loading is arguably not as great as it should be. And some states tend to provide very long-term incentives that probably do not have large payoffs in swaying business location decisions."

What about the form in which incentives are given? The data from the survey reveals: 
"[O]f the total cost of incentives in the average state in 2015, the largest incentive type was JCTCs [job creation tax credits], which were almost half of total incentive  costs (44.9 percent). Another quarter of incentive costs (27.4 percent) were due to property tax abatements. The remaining three incentive types (ITCs [investment tax credits], R&D tax credits, customized job training) together constituted about one-quarter of incentive costs. ...
"Over time, how has the use of different incentive types changed? ... [A]veraged across all states by far the biggest change is that JCTCs have gone from virtually nothing in 1990 to 45 percent of all incentives today, or from 0.01 percent of value-added to 0.64 percent of value-added. Of the 0.96 percentage point increase in overall incentives from 1990 to 2015 (from 0.46 percent to 1.42 percent), about 0.63 percent is due to increased JCTC usage, or about two-thirds of the total incentive increase. ...
"Although nationally JCTCs were most important, some states whose overall incentives were above the national average had little or no JCTCs: Alabama, DC, Iowa, Kentucky, and Pennsylvania. Property tax abatements were particularly important (greater than 1.30 percent of value-added versus the national average of 0.39 percent) in DC, Michigan, New Mexico, Pennsylvania, and Tennessee. Investment tax credits were particularly large (greater than 0.9 percent of value-added versus the national average of 0.20 percent) in Alabama, Kentucky, Nebraska, and South Carolina. R&D tax credits are usually not very large, but in some states with overall low incentives (less than 0.55 percent in overall incentives as percent of value-added), R&D tax credits were a large share of what incentives are provided: California, Maryland, Massachusetts. Customized job training is also usually not a very large incentive, but it was well above the national average (greater than 0.30 percent versus national average of 0.07 percent) in New Mexico, Iowa, and Missouri."
Which approach is most likely to be effective? Bartik is suitably cautious here, and careful to label various results as preliminary. But he does write in the newsletter (citations omitted): 
"Incentives designed as customized services may be more effective than tax incentives. For example, customized job training is a very effective incentive. Research suggests that, per dollar, customized job training might be 10 times more effective than tax incentives in encouraging local business growth. Other effective customized services include manufacturing extension programs, which have been shown to improve productivity. Why are such customized services more cost-effective? They tend to be more targeted than tax incentives at small and medium-sized businesses, whose location and expansion behavior is easier to affect than large businesses’. Because obtaining quality job training services or business advice may be difficult for smaller businesses to do on their own, the value of such services may exceed their costs. Finally, customized services provide up-front assistance, helping the business be more productive immediately. However, despite the greater cost-effectiveness of customized services, state and local incentives are more focused on tax incentives. For example, the typical state only spends $1 on customized job training for every $20 devoted to tax incentives."
What about the hardest question of all--that is, in how many cases does the incentive actually alter the choice a business makes, rather than just adding a little gravy to the choice that would have been made anyway? Appropriately hedged, Bartik writes:
The database suggests incentive effects toward the low end of prior estimates: the average incentive package, 1.4 percent of value-added, might tip the location decision of 6 percent of incented businesses— the other 94 percent of the time, the state would have experienced similar growth without the incentive. This typical 6 percent tip rate of incentives is a low batting average. To have benefits greater than costs, incentives must do something special— they either need unusually high benefits per job created, or incentive designs must exceed the typical batting average, lowering costs per job created. ...
Although the rate of growth of incentives has slowed down, it is still more likely that states will significantly increase rather than decrease incentives. New states have entered more vigorously into the incentive competition. Incentives are still far too broadly provided to many firms that do not pay high wages, do not provide many jobs, and are unlikely to have research spinoffs. Too many incentives excessively sacrifice the long-term tax base of state and local economies. Too many incentives are refundable and without real budget limits. States devote relatively few resources to incentives that are services, such as customized job training. Based on past research, such services may be more cost-effective than cash in encouraging local job growth.
So if your state or local government is considering incentive, the first step is to think  a second, and then a third time, and perhaps even a fourth time about whether it actually makes sense. If the decision is to proceed, then the discussion should move to issues of design: for example, a front-loaded payment that supports customized training for a high tech firm that has a good chance of  generating local spinoffs has a better chance of being a good deal for the taxpayers and the local economy than a 20 year tax break.