This program is redesigning hospitals, with grieving family members in mind:
House Democrats launch push for single-payer healthcare
Alabama governor to sign law giving thousands of felons their right to vote back
Dong looks weak
Fox News pushes to dismiss lawsuit from ex-host Andrea Tantaros
VERBATIM: Republicans care about poor people
Mason: Sky-high condo prices aren’t a supply problem From @garymasonglobe via @GlobeDebate
Could this experiment with lab mice give us clues to living way longer?
Exclusive: U.S. Senates McConnell sees tough path for passing healthcare bill
ASH NYC adds pops of pink to Dig Inn Boston restaurant:
Failure to floss can lead to more serious health conditions #dental #teeth #health
Liberia Risks EU Sanction Over New Fishing Law: #Liberia
Tom Cruise confirms Top Gun sequel ready for takeoff
The Luxury Business of Bespoke Menswear: #Kenya
A broken Ariana Grande returns to the U.S. after deadly Manchester Arena attack.
BREAKING
Trump, Clinton campaign aides launch their own bids:
When the night calls, they answer
There’s another American economy facing talk of presidential impeachment
Obamas photographer trolls Trump with photo of Pope Francis
Weaker Malls in the Crosshairs of Some 2011-2013 U.S. CMBS
Exclusive: U.S. Senates McConnell sees tough path for passing healthcare bill
The incident that ignited Frances largest riots seen in 40 years
Tasmanias gorgeous, glowing water is a sign of something sinister
Govt Working Together With Oppressive Media Regimes: #SouthAfrica
Military strike too risky to solve #NorthKorea nuclear crisis, warns US admiral
Its Time We Made Money From Our Love for Meetings: #Kenya
The bond market bodes badly for the Euros eye-watering surge
Distillate Demand
Gasoline Demand
Oh dear…
Who?
If Trump is innocent, seriously, why is he acting so guilty? @thehill op-ed: #trumprussia
Combative farm workers in only indigenous-led US union win labor rights defenders award.
Dem lawmaker: Democrats must reform party, encourage new leadership
UPDATE: Two confirmed dead in Jakarta after double explosions hit public-transport terminal
CRACKING READ on a glorious sunny evening in London, and absolutely nothing to do with energy:
How big a deal is the new U.S.-China Trade Deal?
Trumps SoHo hotel plans to lay of dozens of workers: report
How financially literate are U.S. 15-year-olds? - from @EdNCES
Which Companies Have the Highest Revenue Per Employee?
Starting to worry that @julieverhage is going to beat me up in the office just for kicks
Metropolis Policy Transfer Platform Shares Urban Best Practices Worldwide
Trump takes a huge bite out of his voters food stamps
Why informal ridesharing will survive Uber
This is what 20 years of mentorship looks like
ESPN and the Bursting of the Sports Bubble | William L. Anderson
Ciao Roma
Five charged with insider trading involving a U.S. health agency:
The typeface everyone loves–or loves to hate–is now a coffee
Major indices continue to rely on large cap stocks as their source of fuel in new 52-week highs.
Could Injuries Cost Nigerias Super Eagles? #Nigeria
Top Education official resigned over dispute with DeVos: report
Despite Moodys downgrading China (and in turn Hong Kong), neither $USDCNH nor $USDHKD offered a serious response:
Fox News finds itself in 3rd place, looking up at MSNBC and CNN
Sign up to our newsletter () to stay up to date with our election coverage and more #GE2017
Chaos in Libya is setting the stage for an ISIS comeback
How loss helped one artist find beauty in imperfection: @alyssamonks
Trireme Olympias on show at Zea marina in Piraeus
Get the free report Why Industrial Insights Matter for Business Strategy #B2B #mrx
What to watch for in the new CBO score of the GOP ObamaCare repeal bill:
Chelsea cancels victory parade after Manchester bomb attack From @Globe_Sports
Messi tax fraud sentence upheld
13 designers reimagine the shaving brush for Good Thing collection:
Malta Leaks: Playing the Shell Game in the Mediterranean
Activist recantation demoralizes civil society in Kazakhstan
There are horrible things lurking on your counterfeit contact lenses
See What It Takes to Move a 1,100-Ton Stone Tomb | National Geographic
Here are the hilariously awkward photos from Trumps visit with Pope Francis at the Vatican
Assange: Wikileaks to continue to operate
Syrian opposition meets De Mistura in Geneva
#Greece - Private Public debt via @ProfSteveKeen
SP500 futures painting itself into a corner. $ES_F $SPY Chartists be like: dat pennant!
Sanders delegate defeats Republican in district that Trump won by double digits:
Oversupply of #Crude Foils #Oil Price Recovery, Impacts #Ports by @PortVisionNews
Trump revealed U.S. submarine moves to Duterte: NYT
BNP Paribas pays $350 million to settle New York currency probe by @Reuters
Why Japan’s emperor isn’t amused
EXCLUSIVE: U.S. Senates McConnell sees a tough path for passing healthcare bill.
Uber admits underpaying New York drivers approximately $45 million
How financially literate are U.S. 15-year-olds? - from @EdNCES
The ‘below average’ fund fee could eat your retirement
National Lottery results live: Why tonights jackpot must be won
New Cairo museum hopes Tutankhamuns chariot will draw tourists.
UK Deploys 1,000 Soldiers to Protect Key Sites after #ManchesterBombing
Theyre stunning, exceedingly rare -- and in the fight of their lives
White House feud with government ethics office escalates:
Mongolias Market Growth Index hits highest level for over 3 years in May. #SMI
Hundreds of Fight for 15 protesters target McDonalds shareholder meeting:
BREAKING: Larry Kudlow tries to explain that his mouth is numb from dental work this morning
Trump revealed U.S. submarines to Duterte: NYT
I checked the Kim Dot Com website (can you guess the domain?). Not sure what I was expecting but it wasnt this.
Sigurd Larsens Roof House features intersecting slanted roofs:
The Manchester attackers younger brother has been arrested in Tripoli, a spokesman said
Blast hits #Jakarta bus terminal
DJIs tiny, affordable Spark could be a great first drone
How Zika conquered the Americas, by @edyong209
Landslide Buries Scenic California Highway #NASA
Why the US should be wary about Rouhani’s reelection in Iran
House Democrats seek information from Deutsche Bank on Trump accounts:
Texas lawmakers war over how to discriminate against LGBTQ people
This is quite the hed-and-byline combo.
Beijing Crackdown Cuts Chinese Investments in US Assets
America needs a brand consultant.
The thing about having a repeatable process. By @BackrowMacro
Moreno, who was born in the Amazon region, says he will protect the jungle and its resources #CambioDeMando
Trump failing to track foreign cash at his hotels
Paul Ryan: I just discovered GIFs three weeks ago
Aarhus to pay back 341,000 kroner in parking fines
Harsh conditions fishing in the Bering Sea can sometimes create scenes of beauty
As oil prices languish, signs emerge of Algeria changing its energy ways
A new device from MIT may speed up quality control for drugs made by living cells.
#UnitedStates 5-Year Note Auction at 1.831%
Getting to know the Big Island of #Hawaii inside and out: by @AlexMHoward #lp #travel
Turkish NBA player has passport revoked by ‘the Hitler of our century’
Dem Sen. Al Franken rules out 2020 run against Trump
These beautiful paintings are made from an unusual medium — bacteria: @Inkfish
In vitro fertilization in Iran - it’s a taboo subject
New Post: Natural Gas Market Analysis 5-24-2017 (#Video) #EconMatters
You cant be required to turn over unconstitutional emoluments if you dont know where they are.
Leader: Mourning in Manchester
#Famine in #SouthSudan - communities at breaking point:
Most homeowners would have mortgage trouble if payments rose by more than 10 per cent: poll
Hunger to hit emergency levels in Ethiopia despite rains
Keep it real — say no to algorithm porn! #machinelearning #datascience #analytics
Trumps food stamp cuts face hard sell in Congress
Women in Artificial Intelligence – A Visual Study of Leadership Across Industries
President Trump set for NATO summit
Refugees, mostly toddlers, drown off Libyan coast
Scammers are peddling Anti-WannaCry Android apps, but WannaCry only targets Windows.
When the Pope met the president
RT @CaplinSystems: . @CFTC looks to modernise with #fintech plan via @TabbFORUM
US army lost track of $1bn worth of arms
Eerie, Ominous Feeling in Manchester After Attack: #SouthAfrica
Blockchain consortium R3 raises $107 million via @techcrunch
A historic first in Asia, Taiwan will legalise gay marriage
5 ways to get your soil ready this #Spring
This new matchmaking website makes seed swapping easier than ever @OrganicLifeMag
bout to block my own dad FB Messenger
Lyrical and passionate from @chrisdeerin on what Manchester means to him
Softer US flats outlook could deflate CIS BPI price. Full analysis here: #metals #steel
MIT used bacteria to create a self-ventilating workout shirt
Not Priced In.
The story of the most dangerous wine in the world—Syrias fractious vintage. @jenniduggan
Trump’s business isn’t keeping the receipts from foreign governments
Comey friend: If I were Trump, I would be scared
Dem Sen. Al Franken rules out 2020 run against Trump
Daily Digest 5/24 - CA Single Payer Proposal Could Run $400B, LA Budget A Train Wreck
People here are praying for the victims of the #manchesterattack #DEKT17
What’s the best way to dispose of prescription medication? From @Globe_Health
HBO cancels Jon Stewarts animated series due to technical issues:
A slide from my talk today: The Zigs and Zags of Inequality in Human Evolutionary History Barcelona, May 24 2017
Man with suspicious package arrested in Wigan in connection with Manchester bombing
Ecuador inaugurates new leftist President Lenin Moreno.
God is like a father, god is like a mother says pastor Christina-Maria Bammel. #DEKT17
Drones and robots weave carbon-fibre pavilion based on moth webs:
Trumps crisis of legitimacy
Editor’s Note: How would Ted Rogers feel about firing Guy Laurence? from @GlobeBusiness
Dynamite sign work at #TrumpNotWelcome
Trump Hires Lawyer for Investigation into Campaign Ties with Russian Officials
Europes bond buyers are taking a swim in the deep end: @marcusashworth via @gadfly
Theres flat and then there is flat...
David Letterman: It makes me sick that Trump represents the country
Sabancaya Keeps Puffing #NASA
Volatility 411 05/24/17
If Trump wants real success in the Middle East, rhetoric must match reality
#Colombia Business Confidence at -8.5
Daily #French #photooftheday Magnificent Medici Fountain at the Luxembourg Gardens, Paris - so beau!
UNMs athletic director used $64,949 in public money to pay for a golf trip.
Photo Gag At Sex Workers Exhibition: #SouthAfrica
HBO finally dropped the first full @GameofThrones season 7 trailer — and its incredible
Mexicos ruling party battles leftist nemesis in key state vote.
Islamic State-Linked Militants Besiege Philippine City
#China runs out of reasons to support Kim Jong-un’s #NorthKorea
Trump administration rocked by intense debate over Afghanistan troop levels: report
What could derail the markets? Probably nothing, expert says @bySamRo
Scientists find a simple trick to boosting childens understanding of evolution
Asia: Sales growth continues at a rapid rate as prices easy in May. #SMI
MT: Kind community comes together to save stuck #orcas. via @OneGreenPlanet
Lenin Moreno becomes the first head of state to be in a wheelchair #CambioDeMando .@Lenin
Democrats want Deutsche Bank info on Trump accounts
Let these migratory marvels rest their wings in your yard
Taiwan to become first Asian nation to legalize gay marriage
Fox News shrugs while Sean Hannity has a meltdown over Seth Rich conspiracy via me
Al Shabaab bombing in Somali capital kills five, injures six (FILE PHOTO)
Join me for a live webinar in 20 minutes with my friend @TechCharts - See
Trump records robocall for Montana Republican in special election
US officials continue to leak intelligence on Manchester terror attack despite UK complaints
AfDB to Make Africas Food Imports History: #Africa
Coastal adaptation program zeroed out in Trump budget proposal
Trumps Budget Cant Diffuse Bush Obamas Timebomb
Here are the 66 federal programs Trump wants to eliminate:
How our ears listen to sounds inside of our bodies:
Is Labor Flexibility Holding Down Japan Inflation? $
Manchester bomb attack: police say they are looking for a network of conspirators
Zimbabwean Nurses March Over Job Grading Anomaly, Salaries #Zimbabwe
Sub-Saharan Africans Trade Europe for Morocco: #Morocco
.@lenin We have recovered pride and a sense of belonging in Ecuador #CambioDeMando
Trevor Noah Makes Bill Gatess List of Good Reads #SouthAfrica
‘White genocide in space’: Racist fans seethe at diversity in new ‘Star Trek’ series
Neoliberal identity politics is all about dividing the working class in service to capital.
$142 million paid for vaccine injuries while vaccine death are unreported #antivax #vaccines
Debt Levels Suggest a Major Contraction is Ahead: #debt #housingmarket #deflation
Next bolded Bradley date (in red too fwiw) is June 20th, just after the FOMC Meeting.
Longest-serving governor in American history steps down
DARPA and Boeing team up to build a hypersonic spaceplane
Deaths reported in Jakarta double bombing
Love Grrr AMAZING! GREAT!!! WTF RoW :
Correa next to his family as he leaves the National Assembly in Quito #CambioDeMando
Existing home sales fall as tight supply lifts prices
Average Bid-Offer spread on Chinese bonds over the past two weeks
.@stephenkb on what the debate over troops on the streets is missing:
.@stephenkb on what the critical UK terrorist threat level means
Wait until working-class voters realize theyve been betrayed by Trump budget
Silicon Valleys big three vs. Detroits golden-age big three, by @alexismadrigal
Michael Flynns businesses to be subpoenaed.
Remembering the Eritrean dream on Independence Day
A Canadian teen is allegedly behind notorious dark web hacking forum
War on sugar takes toll; Asia, Brazil struggle to make up shortfall
From the PopSci archives: 100 years of mastodon fossil fascination
African Scientists Are Punching Above Their Weight #Africa
Nepals Prime Minister resigns, leaving a leadership vacuum weeks before local elections
Arms for Nintendo Switch set to pack a punch
Suspect arrested in Wigan in connection with Manchester suicide attack
How To Transition From A Standard 40-Hour Work Week To Living Your Dharma - By @KaleeBrown -
Changes in Inequality over time in the US
How sonicification charts inequality in NYC subways.
U.S. Bank Deregulation Advances, But Hurdles Remain #Fitchwire
Barclays looks to bolster private bank with 100 hires
AARP launches seven-figure ad campaign targeting GOP senators
@ryanmerkley vision for a digital commons based on Ostroms work #otsummit17
Sea level rising at triple speed since 1990
Habesha to Expand in Budding Brewery Industry: #Ethiopia
How cities fought the White House, and won, in the 1980s
The Economist Films team is seeking an Audience Development Manager
Minutes silence for #Manchester victims to be held across UK at 11am on Thursday
Imam of #Manchesters largest mosque: I am proud Northerner and Mancunian. I am here to be part of all of you.
Peter Turchin talking about cultural evolution today at UPF-Barcelona
Britain takes on social media giants after terror attack
Ultimately, the path forward for drone law is going to be a real balancing act. ⚖️
How Sybian, a family-run business in rural Illinois, remains the Cadillac of sex toys:
Poll: Majority says mainstream media publishes fake news
More Than 1.1 Million Sign Petition Supporting Impeachment of Trump
Here Is The Latest Breakdown Of Fed Hawks And Doves
UPDATE: Two dead in suspected suicide bombing in Jakarta - police.
#Philippines: Duterte’s hometown Davao City in lockdown
Blast in Somali capital kills five, injures six - official
Economic inequality drives climate change, economist finds
Move over, IKEA: This ultra-portable furniture adapts to any apartment


Timothy Taylor
State and Local Government Business Incentives: Data Tells a Story
8 days ago




When a state or local government offers a tax incentive to a business for locating or expanding in its jurisdiction, cross-cutting motives are at work. For the business, it's a chance to get a tax break--maybe for a business decision that would have happened anyway. For the government, it's a chance to show that it's "doing something" to help the economy and to claim credit for the location or growth of certain businesses--even if those are business decisions that would have happened anyway. The issue of the extent to which tax incentives actually alter business decisions or help a local economy overall is difficult to sort out, but for any social scientist, the starting point is to have some actual data.

Timothy J. Bartik has compiled "A New Panel Database on Business Incentives for Economic Development Offered by State and Local Governments in the United States" (Upjohn Institute, February 2017). For a short overview of this work, see Bartik's article "Better Incentives Data Can Inform both Research and Policy" in the Upjohn Institute Employment Research newsletter for April 2017. As Bartik writes in the newsletter:
"Using data from 1990 to 2015, the “Panel Database on Incentives and Taxes” estimates marginal business taxes and business incentives for 45 industries in 33 states; the industries compose 91 percent of U.S. labor compensation, and the states produce over 92 percent of U.S. economic output. The database has data for a new facility starting up in each of 26 “start years.” Compared to prior studies, the new database provides more incentive details, such as how incentives are broken down by different incentive types (e.g., job creation tax credits vs. property tax abatements), and the time pattern by which incentives are paid out over a facility’s life cycle." 
For some questions, it can be hard to extract an answer from data, and involved a lot of assumptions and calculations. But for some questions, the data comes close to telling the story. 

For example, are state and local tax incentives for business rising or falling in the last 25 years? Here's a figure. Here's a time trend in business incentives, expressed as a percentage of the gross stat and local taxes paid by business. Clearly, the level is dramatically higher than 25 years ago. Bartik notes that a big reason for the jump around the year 2000 is the expansion of the "Empire Zone" incentives in New York. 


Of course, this overall increase conceals differences across states.
"From 2001 to 2007, big increases in incentives occurred in New Mexico, Missouri, Indiana, North Carolina, Nebraska, and Texas. This includes some Southern and Midwest states plus the Great Plains state of Nebraska and the southwestern state of New Mexico. Over this same time period, New York significantly reduced incentives, from 5.79 percent to 5.20 percent, although New York incentives remained high. From 2007 to 2015, big incentive increases occurred in Tennessee, New Jersey, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Colorado, Oregon, and Arizona. What is noteworthy here is that some states that previously had very low incentives, such as Tennessee, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Colorado, and Oregon, began to use incentives at a much higher level. But over this same time period, big decreases in incentives occurred in New York, Michigan, and Missouri. The big decreases in New York were due to the demise of the Empire Zone program. In Michigan, Governor Rick Snyder jettisoned the expensive MEGA incentive program as part of a policy package that rolled back general business taxes. The Missouri decrease is due to the Quality Jobs program (a JCTC) being replaced with a less costly job creation tax credit, Missouri Works."
Looking at the data also can raise some basic questions about the structure of these incentives, both in terms of the form in which the incentives are being provided and in terms of the extent to which such incentives are front-loaded.

Here's the issue with front-loading incentives. A business thinking about making a location or an expansion decision is focused on the relatively short-term. Bartik cites an estimate that businesses often discount revenues earned off in the future by about 12% per year. As a result, a tax break that is 10 or 20 years in the future decisions has relatively little effect on their decision. However, for the government, that tax break is very likely to end up being cashed in--at least if the business continues over that time.

Thus, if a state or local tax incentive is spread over a long period of time, the government is effectively offering something of real cost (the tax break), which doesn't affect the business decision all that much. If business incentives are to be offered at all, it makes more sense to front-load them. The figure shows the pattern of tax incentives over tine in Oregon (black line), which heavily front-loads incentives, and in Tennessee (green line), which doesn't front-load much. The blue line shows the overall pattern in the data in 2000, and the red line shows the data pattern for 2015--showing that front-loading has become just a little more common in the last 15 years.
Bartik writes: "As of 2015, in the average U.S. state, incentives are substantially front-loaded. This front-loading has increased over time, but front-loading is arguably not as great as it should be. And some states tend to provide very long-term incentives that probably do not have large payoffs in swaying business location decisions."

What about the form in which incentives are given? The data from the survey reveals: 
"[O]f the total cost of incentives in the average state in 2015, the largest incentive type was JCTCs [job creation tax credits], which were almost half of total incentive  costs (44.9 percent). Another quarter of incentive costs (27.4 percent) were due to property tax abatements. The remaining three incentive types (ITCs [investment tax credits], R&D tax credits, customized job training) together constituted about one-quarter of incentive costs. ...
"Over time, how has the use of different incentive types changed? ... [A]veraged across all states by far the biggest change is that JCTCs have gone from virtually nothing in 1990 to 45 percent of all incentives today, or from 0.01 percent of value-added to 0.64 percent of value-added. Of the 0.96 percentage point increase in overall incentives from 1990 to 2015 (from 0.46 percent to 1.42 percent), about 0.63 percent is due to increased JCTC usage, or about two-thirds of the total incentive increase. ...
"Although nationally JCTCs were most important, some states whose overall incentives were above the national average had little or no JCTCs: Alabama, DC, Iowa, Kentucky, and Pennsylvania. Property tax abatements were particularly important (greater than 1.30 percent of value-added versus the national average of 0.39 percent) in DC, Michigan, New Mexico, Pennsylvania, and Tennessee. Investment tax credits were particularly large (greater than 0.9 percent of value-added versus the national average of 0.20 percent) in Alabama, Kentucky, Nebraska, and South Carolina. R&D tax credits are usually not very large, but in some states with overall low incentives (less than 0.55 percent in overall incentives as percent of value-added), R&D tax credits were a large share of what incentives are provided: California, Maryland, Massachusetts. Customized job training is also usually not a very large incentive, but it was well above the national average (greater than 0.30 percent versus national average of 0.07 percent) in New Mexico, Iowa, and Missouri."
Which approach is most likely to be effective? Bartik is suitably cautious here, and careful to label various results as preliminary. But he does write in the newsletter (citations omitted): 
"Incentives designed as customized services may be more effective than tax incentives. For example, customized job training is a very effective incentive. Research suggests that, per dollar, customized job training might be 10 times more effective than tax incentives in encouraging local business growth. Other effective customized services include manufacturing extension programs, which have been shown to improve productivity. Why are such customized services more cost-effective? They tend to be more targeted than tax incentives at small and medium-sized businesses, whose location and expansion behavior is easier to affect than large businesses’. Because obtaining quality job training services or business advice may be difficult for smaller businesses to do on their own, the value of such services may exceed their costs. Finally, customized services provide up-front assistance, helping the business be more productive immediately. However, despite the greater cost-effectiveness of customized services, state and local incentives are more focused on tax incentives. For example, the typical state only spends $1 on customized job training for every $20 devoted to tax incentives."
What about the hardest question of all--that is, in how many cases does the incentive actually alter the choice a business makes, rather than just adding a little gravy to the choice that would have been made anyway? Appropriately hedged, Bartik writes:
The database suggests incentive effects toward the low end of prior estimates: the average incentive package, 1.4 percent of value-added, might tip the location decision of 6 percent of incented businesses— the other 94 percent of the time, the state would have experienced similar growth without the incentive. This typical 6 percent tip rate of incentives is a low batting average. To have benefits greater than costs, incentives must do something special— they either need unusually high benefits per job created, or incentive designs must exceed the typical batting average, lowering costs per job created. ...
Although the rate of growth of incentives has slowed down, it is still more likely that states will significantly increase rather than decrease incentives. New states have entered more vigorously into the incentive competition. Incentives are still far too broadly provided to many firms that do not pay high wages, do not provide many jobs, and are unlikely to have research spinoffs. Too many incentives excessively sacrifice the long-term tax base of state and local economies. Too many incentives are refundable and without real budget limits. States devote relatively few resources to incentives that are services, such as customized job training. Based on past research, such services may be more cost-effective than cash in encouraging local job growth.
So if your state or local government is considering incentive, the first step is to think  a second, and then a third time, and perhaps even a fourth time about whether it actually makes sense. If the decision is to proceed, then the discussion should move to issues of design: for example, a front-loaded payment that supports customized training for a high tech firm that has a good chance of  generating local spinoffs has a better chance of being a good deal for the taxpayers and the local economy than a 20 year tax break.