Is #Healthcare ‘the Military Industrial Complex of the 21st century’?
Carl Mydans, Kitchen in the Ozarks- Missouri, May 1936.
Massive tunnels in South America are likely the work of long-extinct giant mammals:
Today in #TheLabReport: Slashing the safety net, and more
One killed as protesters and police clash in Bahrain
RIP Roger Moore. The best Bond ever!
Islamic State claims responsibility for Manchester concert attack
Is a wave election forming for Democrats?
U.S. plan to sell oil reserve shows declining import needs
Elderly couple’s dead bodies eaten by pet dogs in #Mallorca #Lead #Mallorca
plans to strengthen network, raise new funds next year
Intel chief wont comment on whether Trump asked him to deny Russia investigation evidence
An MF Global/Corzine Story You Have Not Heard $
#EuropaLeague: Ajax youngsters look to upset more experienced Manchester United
Munich police crack gang behind up to fifth of all German burglaries
Is Cyril Hanouna the most unpleasant person on French television?
Police raid Daimler offices nationwide in emissions fraud probe
Brody Leven on finding solace among the challenges
Curses! Todays editorial cartoon by David Parkins. More cartoons: From @GlobeDebate
Protesters target MSNBC headquarters to support Lawrence ODonnell
You can buy a replica of Carl Sagans famous Pioneer Plaque
Ten Afghan soldiers killed in Kandahar army base attack
French VW probe identifies 22.78 billion euros in diesel sales: paper
Unstable #Venezuela Has 5,000 Russian Missiles, And They Could End Up in the Wrong Hands
. @ArianaGrande: the anodyne teen favourite hit by bombing tragedy
Solar-Friendly Florida Utility Hammers Trump On Coal Policy
You can send ThinkProgress information and tips securely on WhatsApp
Police raid Daimler offices nationwide in emissions fraud probe.
New Home Sales decrease to 569,000 Annual Rate in April
Charlene Barshefsky, America’s top trade negotiator in 2001 talks about China today
Canadas North West Mounted Police was established by Queen Victoria on 23 May 1873.
Happy world trade week!
Where you can make the most money renting your stuff @melodyhahm
This cant be shared enough. #gorsuch #SCOTUS
Inflatable Greenhouse From NASA Could Feed Astronauts on Mars - Via @CollectiveEvol -
Trumps education budget takes aim at the working class, @aliaemily reports
Experts say Trump’s speech deterioration is a clear sign of early dementia
JUST IN: Rubio is not optimistic about Trumps plan for Middle East peace
Renting out space in your home: Is the stress worth it?
Gay Men Publicly Caned in Indonesia
Portuguese minister: Southern cities better placed to host medicines agency
Live from the European Business Summit
House of Cards actress on Trump: I am shocked every morning
PETITION: Tell advertisers to boycott LBC until they sack Katie Hopkins #Manchester
U.S. new-home sales fall more than forecast via @mljamrisko
Sino-American Interests Aligning on N Korea, OBOR and the S China Sea @LinkedIn
Abigail Johnson of @Fidelity on the difficulties of using bitcoin. But not giving up. #consensus2017 @coindesk
US intel chief: No confirmation ISIS was behind Manchester attack
Five of the best installations to see at this years Clerkenwell Design Week:
ADB Sells $46 Million Green Bonds To Fund Renewable Energy Projects In India
lol
How concert venues keep fans safe
Seoul’s new High Line acts like a plant nursery for the rest of the city
.@Fidelitys Abby Johnson making pleas to #bitcoin community. Listen up #Consensus2017, heres your biggest advocate
Longest-serving James Bond star Roger Moore dies at 89
Still one of my favourite Twitter moments. RIP Roger Moore.
Are you middle class in Western Europe? Try our country-by-country income calculators
The 35 worst celebrity Photoshop fails of all time
Dem senator: Manchester attack shows importance of CIA and intel community
Manchester: This is the scene of the suspected attack–the worst on British soil since 2005
Threaten our way of life? The terrorists have barely made a dent
Alex Jones criticizes “liberal trendies” who were victims of the Manchester terror attack
Pensions Gone Wild! Chicago Teachers Pension Fund Paid Out $1.5 Billion in ’16, Earned…
Stocks of homebuilders tank on 11% mm drop in April sales $LEN $PHM $DHI $MHT $HOV $CAA
President Trump’s proposed budget seeks cuts to taxes, Medicaid, food stamps via @WSJ
#Indonesia: Aceh publicly shames couple for gay sex
Hackers unlock Samsung Galaxy S8 with fake iris
Canada’s prison agency closes in on new solitary confinement rules From @Nut_Graf
This is good news! Top trends for business as focus on #wellbeing gathers steam.
A VFX artist couple shot an amazing DIY fantasy film in their own home:
Federal Election Commissioner calls for expanded Trump-Russia investigation:
Bank of England Governor tricked by email prankster who conned Barclays boss Jes Staley
The UN Global Compact Cities Program for Sustainable Cities
Republicans in red states are panicked over upcoming elections — thanks to Donald Trump
Noble Group `fighting for its life as SP sees default risk
@PeopleinMind @30percentclubIE #30pcopenminds great agenda for today at BBH @SMTuffy
Former #JamesBond star Roger Moore dies aged 89
This is Fleet Week
62% of Americans now hold a favorable view of #NATO, up from just over half in 2016
Today! Dont miss our exclusive interview with PM @ComradeRalph streaming live on our FB!
South African Minister Grilled About Power Utility Heads Return #LynnBrown #BrianMolefe
Swiss National Bank pulling the plug on #NIRP. EuroSwiss monthly/weekly charts rolling over $ES1 Comdty $S_F $LU_F
Gas apocalypse looms amid a power plant construction boom
These new lenses could turn us all into tetrachromats — giving us super color vision:
In Home Capital’s mortgage mess, blame the ‘unlucky’ brokers #business
Sorry, but the Avocado Theory on why millennials are struggling is toast, writes @lloydalter
The Mick Mulvaney budget hits the Hill, @russellberman reports
So much for the Trump bump
CEOs of Target, ADM to square off on U.S. border tax at hearing
Trump budget asks for small fraction of funds needed for border wall
7. About half of people in Sweden support becoming a #NATO member
Cartoonists respond to the terror attack in #Manchester: w/ @vascogargalo @swahacartoons
Israel’s diverse religious landscape
Stuttgart prosecutors search Daimler offices in #dieselgate probe
How Google and Facebook drive internet traffic by topic
BREAKING: Fidelity CEO Talks Love For Bitcoin, Why Blockchain Will Change Markets
Is #Cybersecurity A Second Coming For #AI? #fintech @juliettesultan
1917: Mexico Faces Ruin as Strikes Spread
NEW POLL: Majority of voters disapprove of Trump decision to fire Comey
Rediscovered fossil suggests surprising origin for human ancestors From @ivansemeniuk
Join keynote speaker Craig Pirrong of @UHouston at FOW Trading Chicago this June
Roger Moore, the actor who held the James Bond role the longest, has died at 89
Germany is quietly building a European army.
#NATO Democrats more supportive of NATOas partisan gap widens
Lawrence O’Donnell’s Days at @MSNBC May be Numbered #tcot
The Nifty Inboard M1 Electric Skateboard
Apple and Nokia avoid court battle over patents
British combat airpower in the form of a Typhoon, Lightning and Tornado.
Mall troubles threaten a rite of passage: the teen job via @WSJ
Gay Couple Publicly Caned in Indonesia
Brazils latest political scandal is putting CEOs dreams in jeopardy
British James Bond actor Roger Moore has died, aged 89
The U.K. should publish a detailed list of Brexit priorities after the June vote, IoD says
Bank of England Governor, Mark Carney. Apparently is not up for the type of party I like to throw.
3. NATO solidarity is higher among people who consider Russia a major threat
#AI: When a robot AI doctor misdiagnoses you, whos to blame? — Quartz #News
Fox News employees disgusted after network pushes Seth Rich conspiracy
21 drivers arrested in Hong Kong in a fresh crackdown on Uber
Trump proposes selling off half the U.S. strategic oil reserve
BHP hires Barclays to divest U.S. shale gas assets: sources
LATEST: Former James Bond star Sir Roger Moore has died, his family says
#SouthAfricas rand firms on rumours that ANC to discuss Zumas removal
Blood donor centres inundated with people helping any way they can after Manchester attack
The horror of an attack targeting young women and children, by @sophieGG
Zuma Banned from Speaking at South African Trade Unions Events #SouthAfrica
Three upcoming House elections will test whether Trump is hurting Republicans
Election paused after Manchester attack - @GaryGibbonBlog writes:
Business lessons anyone can learn, from the founder of Nike
EURUSD - get out while you still can!
Blood donor centres inundated with people helping any way they can after Manchester attack
James Bond actor Sir Roger Moore dies, aged 89
Get unlimited access to HBR’s best charts, infographics, and slide decks. Subscribe Now!
Majority of Americans oppose funding Trump’s border wall
Coffee Tim tams - true Aussie style at #consensus2017 @Austrade
This is the first all-female panel Ive moderated in my life - @schaeferdaniel at #wfs2017
Ready for Coachella
Zumas ousting will be raised at key ANC meeting, sources say
Matt Levines Money Stuff: Money Laundering and Quant Code
$EUR: market still an unbeliever in the European inflation story, seeing inflation 1% early 2018
Renegotiating Nafta might actually be a good idea
Greek debt deal is delayed as a 15-year extension fails to lure the IMF
N + E + W =
India plans to expand its drug regulator
Hoping for a Child Who Survives: #Sudan
A guide to $400 billion in Saudi-U.S. deals
Do you regret not saving enough for retirement? Youre not alone
G7 leaders expect Trump to make a decision on the Paris accord this week
Trump budget would cut $610 billion from Medicaid despite pledge not to touch program:
Trumps no help in recruiting Silicon Valley techies for U.S. work
Lululemon is in talks to fill Sephoras 5th avenue vacancy, sources say
OPEC set to prolong oil cuts as delegates predict smooth meeting
Paytm launches niche bank, to offer interest of 4 pct a year on savings accounts
Centrism takes on the extremes. @Noahpinion makes the case for neoliberalism via @BV
Stephen Colbert Mocks Trump with Side-by-Side Comparison to Obamas Scandals
Centrism takes on the extremes. @Noahpinion makes the case for neoliberalism via @BV
NICER: Launching Soon to the Space Station
Sir Roger Moores family says he had a short battle with cancer before his death aged 89
Really too young to drink. 2014 will need time. But this is classic Zingy puligny Montrachet village app.
Manchester Arena: Weve been inspired by the way the people of Manchester rallied round
Top Clinton aide: Trump adopted most of Putins foreign policy
Chinese backlash over US graduation speech, Cannes ‘flag’ dress
NEW: NATO’s Image Improves on Both Sides of Atlantic
NEW: NATO’s Image Improves on Both Sides of Atlantic
Tesla earns back some points from @ConsumerReports with its automatic emergency braking
America’s cities are running out of room via @business
Toyota CEO Sounds Ambivalent About EVs, But EV Plans Still On Track
#Manchester suicide bombing lays bare the limits of high security measures
Instagram rolled out a location Stories feature, just like Snapchat’s
Kenyan medics say US health aid cuts will mean more abortions
#UnitedStates New Home Sales at 569K
Top on #tiajobs today: Frontend Web Developer at BandLab
Caution pervades ahead of Polozs rate decision
White House affirms President Trump is in Jerusalem, Israel. (Tillerson be damned.)
Woman asked the City Council to ban the wearing of shorts in public, Fort Worth, Texas, May 1952.
Who are the victims of the Manchester terror attack?
GRAD missiles hit Kolosova street in Avdiivka. No casualties via @rechnikato
Tzanakopoulos says Greece can get clear deal at June Eurogroup
Greek stocks slide, yields spike after hopes for debt deal dashed
In the footsteps of Leonidas
Signs of unity across #Manchester today after last nights horrific attack. #ManchesterBombing
An Odd Symmetry: Argentina After Dark #NASA
North central Melbourne is becoming a test bed for smart, integrated transport
#UnitedStates Richmond @federalreserve Manufacturing Index at 1
Donald Trump’s Muslim tolerance only extends to tyrants.
Tipping point for Apple Pay as majority of UK tills accept limitless payments @telegraphtech
Mexicos staffing levels continue to fall in May. #SMI
#Fintech revolution will ‘create’ more #jobs than it cuts @StuartSFarquhar @TheScotsman
Russia’s hearts-and-minds campaign in Syria is aimed at Muslims at home.
Trump (accidentally) makes Corsica Italian again
Trump administration requests $1.6 million for bricks and mortar for border wall
Puligny Montrachet domaine bzikot village appellation. 2015. Young but sooooo ready to drink!
It was the best of times, it was the worst of times $
Toronto police invited to march in uniform in New York City pride parade
Topps Tiles shares on the slide after housing market hits profits
11 judges will soon decide the fate of a polarizing US agency
PPG boss still wants to negotiate AkzoNobel takeover despite three failed bids
BTFD FTW. While not obvious on the surface, these markets are very weird, says BofA.
@jeffreyatucker
The world’s most controversial element.
Mueller reviewed private Comey memos on Trump: report
Yorgos Lanthimos at Cannes: ‘The Killing of a Sacred Deer’
Stephen Colbert mocks Trump with side-by-side comparison to Obamas scandals
Smoke of the clashes near Avdiivka via @LuftGanza
More bubble talk as techs just keep charging ahead
African-American Caucus leader: Why was Maxine Waters speech cut off?
Pakistan spokesman on ICJ ruling in The Hague
Rouhani and Raisi supporters rally in Tehran
Pakistan reacts as 2 envoys freed by Afghanistan
Euro area nominal growth has peaked, but theres an issue with the metrics. cc @ClausVistesen
NASA replaces a critical computer on the ISS during emergency spacewalk
Former James Bond star Roger Moore dies after battle with cancer
Does biomedical research has a claims inflation problem?
Three restaurant companies stick out from all the others, this earnings season:
Converting parking spots into patios gains traction – but some cities are still lagging
#Hedgefunds - letters, conferences, profiles and more for Q1 2017 - updated frequently
The story of how N.Y.C. created modern tattoos
[no comment] Bullfighting Banderas hits the catwalk in Cannes
South Africas Zuma Questioned on Nkandla, Intelligence Report #SouthAfrica
RIP
Amnesty International: Qatar is still abusing World Cup workers.
Google AI beats Chinese master in ancient game of Go
Fantastic work by #Newsround. They should just take over the rolling coverage:
Mogherini: It is clearly an attack to the European youth
Badass with a sense of humor. RIP Mr. Moore
Ada Tsang, Hong Kongs first woman to conquer #Everest, is safe at base camp
Supreme Court strikes down North Carolinas racial gerrymander
.@NickTimiraos of WSJ tries a metaphor to explain big gimmick in Trump budget
#UnitedStates Markit Services PMI Flash at 54
#UnitedStates Markit Manufacturing PMI Flash at 52.5
#UnitedStates Markit Composite PMI Flash at 53.9
How does Trump budget get to 3% growth? In part by making people work for safety-net help
Queen Elizabeth responds to Manchester attack: An act of barbarity
May 23, 1917 - Western Mail: British PM Lloyd George tries to clear the way towards an Irish settlement #100yearsago
Trump has requested $1.6 billion to help build his ‘beautiful’ border wall in 2018
It’s time to rethink prisoner re-entry
Dem senator on Infowars White House press credentials: I want to throw up
LONGWave - 05 11 17 - MAY - Here is What Will Bring Down the Market!
A brief history of SETI@Home, by @ScolesSarah
Job of the day from @dezeenjobs is for a sales manager for Lee Broom:
Deadly Flash Floods Set to Worsen Poverty and Hunger, Experts Say: #Kenya
May 23, 1917 - German Junkers J.I (J 4) two-seat reconnaissance biplane. #100yearsago
See the secret hotel suite hidden inside Disney Worlds Cinderella Castle
National Endowment for the Humanities chairman announces resignation
President Trump on the Manchester plotters: “They’re losers.”
This super-efficient renovation is a model for lowering a house’s energy footprint:
Ice Tunnel, Tarfala Valley, Sweden
LIVE: AI beats 19 year-old Go champ -
Us old folks remember when cov-lite was not the norm in markets... Moodys:
For Trump’s budget to work, the US will need the biggest technology boom since World War II
21 #Uber drivers in #HongKong arrested for illegal driving


Shaun Richards
Are we measuring the wrong type of productivity?
6 days ago




Today gives us an opportunity to look at the latest data on what is the key economic number these days which is wages growth. After yesterday’s inflation data we will be able to look at both nominal and real or inflation adjusted wages growth. The reason it has become a key number is that in countries like the UK ( and US and Japan..) is that the employment situation is strong and recorded unemployment has improved considerably but wages growth has been weak. In the extreme case of Japan there has so often been no wages growth.

An associated influence on this has been problems with productivity as of course it has helped drive wages growth in the past. Whereas according to Bank of England Chief Economist Andy Haldane that happy situation has been replaced by this.

Productivity growth has consistently underperformed relative to expectations, since at least the global financial crisis. This tale of productivity disappointment, in forecasting and in performance, has been extensively debated and analysed over recent years. Some have called it the “productivity puzzle”.

Indeed we have been on something of a road to nowhere.

For the past decade, average productivity growth has been negative. This is unusual, if not unique, historically. You would have to go right back to the 18th century to see a similarly lengthy period of stagnant productivity.

In case you were wondering it compares to this.

there has been a near-monotonic rise in UK productivity. UK TFP growth since 1750 has averaged 0.8% per year. Since the Industrial Revolution, GDP per capita has doubled roughly every 65 years and productivity roughly every 85 years.

Actually some of Andy’s numbers are a little contradictory as he suddenly agrees with the theme on here that things were deteriorating even before the credit crunch.

From 1950 to 1970, median global productivity growth averaged 1.9% per year. Since 1980, it has averaged 0.3% per year.

I find that fascinating because is not that the same period where we saw the influence of increasing globalisation and internationalisation which were badged as bring significant economic benefits?

The United States

The international scale of the issue has been highlighted by the Financial Times today.

US productivity is set to grow this year at around a third of the pace prevailing before the financial crash………..
US labour productivity — a driver of the economy’s fortunes — is forecast to expand 1 per cent this year, an improvement on the 0.5 per cent recorded for 2016 but far shy of the 2.9 per cent growth seen from 1999 to 2006, according to Conference Board projections shared with the Financial Times.

This is true of others as well.

The EU will see 1 per cent growth in GDP per hour, an improvement on last year’s 0.8 per cent but short of the 1.9 per cent seen in 1999-2006.  Japan is on course for 1.1 per cent productivity growth, up sharply from 0.5 per cent in 2016 but still well shy of the 2.2 per cent pace seen before the crisis.

I cannot move on without pointing out that the pre credit crunch figures were inflated in many places by booming housing and banking sectors which then went bust.

the figures lag far behind the 4.9 per cent pace in 1999-2006.

Is it the service sector?

To my mind a large factor in the productivity puzzle has been the switch from actual things being produced to more intangible types of economic growth. If we look at it in a stereotypical sense we see output of cars replaced by output of haircuts or teaching or nursing. The latter is much harder to measure in productivity terms as who wants teachers to be more productive via larger class sizes? It is even worse for nurses as who would want to be in a hospital ward with fewer nurses? The problem here is we need a measure of quality of the output and we struggle to define and measure that. Even worse some areas of production face a future of possible enormous gains in labour productivity by the use of robotics and artificial intelligence but where does that leave the labour? Can we have too much of something that is usually considered to be good.

Looking forwards as Sarah O’Connor points out we are likely to see more growth in the service sector.

The undramatic truth is that many of the jobs of the future are also those of the present. Prime among them are jobs that involve humans looking after other humans. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics has predicted the top 30 fastest-growing occupations for the next 10 years; more than half are some variety of nurse, therapist, healthcare worker or carer. This feels like a safe bet — and not just in the US.

She also points out that this growth will be in jobs that we tend to not value.

Social care jobs, for example, are defined by economists everywhere as low-skilled or unskilled…….Personal care and home health aides in the US make roughly $23,000 a year on average. In Britain, a prolonged squeeze on public spending has had knock-on effects on care workers, many of whom work for private companies that rely on public sector contracts. In England last year, 43 per cent of care workers earned less than £7.50 an hour.

There are plenty of thought-provoking issues here as raising productivity here would involve paying them more as that is the only measure of output we have here. Indeed both GDP and productivity fail us when we cannot measure economic output. On this road no wonder both metrics have problems. If a service sector producer gets more efficient and reduces its price then as money is often the only measure we record lower productivity when in fact things have improved. In other words we are in a something of a mess of our own making.

Today’s data

Not the cheeriest I am afraid to say.

Output per hour – our main measure of labour productivity – fell by 0.5% in Quarter 1 (January to March) 2017. This compares with growth of 0.4% in Quarter 4 (October to December) 2016.

My explanation given above may well work though.

was a result of hours worked growing faster than output;

What about wages?

Growth has been pretty consistent at what seems to be something of a new normal.

Between January to March 2016 and January to March 2017, in nominal terms, total pay increased by 2.4%

It is in fact marginally higher but as we look for real wage growth and note that nominal growth in March was 2.4% we see that it was a mere 0.1% and should it remain the same in April then wage growth will be negative. Of course if we use the RPI then annual wage growth was negative again in March at -0.7%. Sadly such numbers come on the back of a credit crunch era decline.

The Resolution Foundation has a somewhat enduring if increasingly lonely faith in officialdom so it still takes the forecasts of the OBR seriously and has switched to the CPIH inflation measure. I think though like so many places today it was so revved up to say real wages were falling again that it has used the regular rather than total pay data.

Comment

There is much to consider here as we find yet another set of statistics that are failing us in the credit crunch era. Our outdated concept of productivity needs to change and it is being challenged at both ends of the spectrum. At one extreme we have the sort of situation covered by Skynet in the Terminator series of firms where robots rule and at the other we have what we might call 100% human occupations. Do we really want to say that one provides a sort of 100% productivity and the other 0% because that is where we are heading right now?

Let me add in another sector which is the self-employed which these days is 15% of our workforce or 4.78 million people. For those in the service sector our main measure of output and hence productivity will be their pay. The very pay numbers that are ignored by the official average earnings data. What could go wrong?

Number Crunching

Regular readers will be aware of my love for football. The numbers game at The Emirates where Arsenal were playing Sunderland had me intrigued. You see pictures of a ground that was a long way from full were all over social media and BBC 5 live reported it was at least a third empty, and yet.

the official number for Tuesday’s game was 59,510. ( ESPN)

Actually Arsene Wenger claimed it was “sold out” but of course he has a long history of eyesight problems and myopia so let’s pass on that. But could we one day see the first empty ground that is counted as sold out?