German audience laughs and cheers after Trump Cabinet members speech cut off
Japans JXTG settles Q2 #HSFO price 6.2% lower from Q1 on weaker #oil price. Full story
Minister Samuel Moncada We will capture him and bring him to justice.
Fresh cyberattack likely ‘more sophisticated’ than WannaCry: Europol
Stamped from the Beginning: Ibram X. Kendi on the History of Racist Ideas in U.S.
Meat processor cuts deal with ABC in pink slime defamation case
A Look at Uncertainty in the UK, Post-Election | Daniel Lacalle
The WOKEST take on Goldilocks youll see today
Democrats have hired Raffi Krikorian, a former Uber exec, as their chief technology officer
Grenades dropped from helicopter on Venezuela’s Supreme Court building
Learners Allegedly Strip Searched for Cheat Notes - Opposition Party: #SouthAfrica
Trump’s lawyers will postpone filing a complaint against Comey with DOJ, source says
CFTC Chief Asks Congress for More Money to Oversee Blockchain
Pakistan issues landmark transgender passport; fight for rights goes on
NSA spying scandal committee presents controversial final report
Obama received much higher ratings at the end of his presidency than Trump gets today
Por vezes ainda me surpreende que estejamos só agora a resolver enormidades deste calibre (do @JNegocios de hoje)
Yemen: Worlds worst cholera outbreak mapped
When trying to survive while homeless is made illegal
The Mathematics of Machine Learning #machinelearning #mathematics
What is lost when teachers cant afford to live near students? asks Andrew Simmons
CNN launching new brand featuring Chris Cillizza
US Recreation Index for June: 78.2, previous: 77.3 (change: 1.1%) #WPI
Beijing is weakening Hong Kongs rule of law. How far will it go? #HKSAR20
Verizon jumps on the AI-security bandwagon @BankingTechno
How mirror trades moved billions out of Russia
Trump calls Washington Post fake news over report about fake Time magazine covers:
Euro v. pound: which one will come out on top?
A sign to go slow on raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour, says @Noahpinion
These charts show U.S. threat from foreign steel is overblown via @daniel_flatley
Global #Stocks Fall on Jitters over #CentralBanks Policy
Paddington Bear creator Michael Bond dies aged 91
Kenyan author ditches Swedish book fair over far-right newspaper
Clarity Or Confusion $
10 facts about smartphones as the iPhone turns 10
Magufuli Bids Farewell to Presidents Delivery Bureau Workers: #Tanzania
How a computer virus spread from Ukraine to disrupt world business: #ReutersCyber #CyberRisk
Mouse droppings, beetle bits found in German bakeries
CNN reporter fires back: Sean Hannity needs a hug
Ashton Kutcher: Were getting close to the point where acting can be automated
‘Evil’ Brussels vs. ‘good’ Prague: Czech MEPs want to change EU’s image
#German legislators approve disbursement of loan installment to #Greece
#Iran Annual #Inflation at 11.8%
Carney makes his Mark. Sterling rises vs dollar for 6th day in a row, its best run since March last year.
The changing face of jihadism in Switzerland
How Vienna solved homelessness (via @crosscut) #500khomeless
Will grad students lose the right to unionize under Trump? asks @AlanaSemuels
Russia doubles down on criticism of US for alleging Syria is planning a new chemical attack
Global borrowing hits record as big central banks prepare to tighten credit via @Reuters
Trump is waging a new kind of Cold War — and millions of jobs are on the front line
Philippines: Market Growth continues to grow but at a reduced rate in June. #SMI
Opinion: Will Albania descend into chaos as Macedonia did? by @dimitarbechev:
Meal-kit maker Blue Apron slashes its valuation expectations by a third. More here:
The New Statesman Leader: Labour and the Brexit debacle
France to legislate on assisted reproduction
Chinese reporters say blocked from #SichuanLandslide coverage
Scarborough: State Department is rotting under Tillerson
BlackRocks Rosenberg doubts market misjudged Draghi via @markets
Our must-read @CapX email now comes with a Stat of the Day. Like this bad boy
11 of the best new low-budget projects in the US:
Trump lawyer routed millions of dollars to his family through nonprofits: report
Five Primary Beneficiaries Of Rising U.S. Oil Exports
Lacy Hunt: The Fed Has Undermined The Economy’s Ability To Grow $
4/6: Municipal #default volume driven by local governments and #utilities #muniland
President Jacob Zuma Congratulates BET Award Winner Yvonne Chaka Chaka: #SouthAfrica
Graphic - Trump, Draghi, Fed doubts: is the US dollar rally done? via @Reuters
JUST IN: Trump accepts Macrons invitation to visit France next month
Women fire fighters during a training exercise at the Pearl Harbor Naval Shipyard, during World War II, circa 1941.
The Supreme Court just made it harder to survive death row
Is Korroding trying to steal Carnage’s wedding ring?!
Narrower U.S. trade gap may boost growth pace in second quarter
See the latest addition to Chinas rapidly expanding navy:
Groom A Successor, Minister Tells Mugabe #Zimbabwe
Yes, Bitcoin is a bubble and it’s about to burst by @jessefelder
German judge Kabisch removed from Auschwitz trial for bias
Iron ore jumps back above $60
Winning: New poll shows only 12% of Americans support the Senate version of #TrumpCare.
Notes abt commodities $JJG $DBA $DBC $GSG u know...
2 Out of 6 Aspirants Qualify to Run For Rwandas Presidency #Rwanda
Rand Paul: These weak-kneed Republicans need to get over themselves
Latest API Report Causes Drop in Prices
The living wage debate cant ignore healthcare
Google should try a little harder for online shoppers
Plans to address fund manager failings unveiled by City watchdog
Cathcart signs new deal with Watford to stay until 2021
Were in! Nearly 200 U.S. mayors have already joined the 2017 #MayorsChallenge. Will you?
Energy deals drive Canadian MA to the strongest start in a decade
Reporter who went off on White House during press briefing: It was a long time coming
Idaho restaurant owner apologizes for tasteless ‘blackface’ ad campaign
New Post: #Crude Oil Sinks 20%: Why Oversupply Isnt the Half of It #EconMatters
Democrats had good turnout in the special election Georgia. But that wasnt enough.
Many units of measurements are named after scientists. Here are their stories:
Can Melbourne lower its temperature by 4 degrees?
#DonaldTrump to visit #Paris for #BastilleDay at Macron’s invitation
U.K. cabinet cracks are appearing as Theresa May seeks to negotiate a Brexit deal
This is what it sounds like when doves screech via @robbrand @markets
Trump is to stocks as pensions are to bonds
Kushner is adding a seasoned scandal lawyer to his team
The beauty products Meghan Markle is rumoured to love
Djokovic bumped up to two in Wimbledon seedings
Commentary: The biggest victims of the Senate healthcare bill (and other Trump plans)
Germany Durable Goods Price Index for June: 115.6, previous: 115.6 (change: 0%) #WPI
Montreals reputation as affordable housing haven strained by rising prices in some areas
We’re Working More—and Sleeping Less by @andrewvandam
Google wont take the Brussels onslaught lying down via @gadfly
Stocks have become so expensive that central bankers are weighing in again
The Bank of England hawks are not for turning via @BW
Take a peek inside Ben Westerman from HM Capital Managements portfolio #ETFs
#AAPL Daily Please RT + Register for next weeks Free Webinar: …
A failed $6 billion deal shows how index funds can ruin your takeover
University of Cape Town Denies Evictions for Non-Payment of Fees: #SouthAfrica
NAFTA: Price inflation eases in June but remains firm. #SMI
Latest API report causes drop in oil prices
Morocco Offers Lessons for Regional Integration: #Africa
Six-month-old baby was found dead in mothers arms following #GrenfellTower fire
Nuclear waste-carrying ship sets sail for first time on German river
Model Miranda Kerr turns over $8 million worth of jewelry to the Justice Department
Hamburg discharges Berlin police after drunken party
FBI Interviews Employees of Russia-Linked Cyber Security Firm Kasperky Lab via @SteveKopack
Pound jumps as Carneys hawkish tone sends gilts tumbling via @johnainger
Interesting, Breitbart has nothing about the EU-Google decision on its front page. Drudge does.
.@NATOmission_ru: NATO troops are now in places of Eastern Europe where they never have been and never should be
U.S. DISTILLATE STOCKS fell -0.2 million bbl to 152 million bbl in week to Jun 23
New museum opens for finance fans
Rockwave | Athens | June 30 - July 2
A perfect day on Oahus north shore #hawaii #travel
Kazantzakis in England | Iraklio | July 12-16
A new tool from @MIT_Picower and @Stanford researchers offers snapshots of neuron activity.
The first evidence that painful memories can be safely erased.
Parthenon Film Festival | Halkidiki | July 14-16
Petra Diamonds shares tumble as setbacks test debt covenants
BP pushes Artificial Intelligence Beyond Limits
Evicted Student Doctor Takes University to Court: #Zimbabwe
Cabin Crew to Lay Corruption Charges Against SAA Execs, Board: #SouthAfrica
CNN war with Trump gets personal:
Hamas creates no-go security zone on border with Egypt
UAE unaffected by new wave of global cyberattacks - TRA
Mexican singer Lila Downs rejects Trump’s anti-Cuba policies
Britains big new warship runs Windows XP
#BREAKING: Trump accepts Macrons invitation to visit France
Conservatives’ excuses for kicking millions off of health care don’t make any sense.
Last nights moon with earthshine near bright star Regulus via Eliot Herman in Tucson
A tale of two networks: How Fox News and CNN handled recent retractions
In Western European countries, confidence in the U.S. president has declined sharply.
ECB worried by US plan for looser bank rules
US EAST COAST GASOLINE STOCKS rose +0.6 million bbl to 68 million bbl in week to Jun 23
U.S. EAST COAST GASOLINE STOCKS continue to tighten versus 2016 and 10-yr average as regional glut slowly clears
Enjoy Arbys.
Florida wildfire cuts interstate highway
Cobie Smulders meets Friends from College
Magic Spot: Camp Cecil on Mexicos Isla Santo Espiritu
Le discours du gouvernement sur les migrants inquiète les ONG via @EurActiv_FR
Cash-rich Sweden squirrels away ahead of demographic time bomb
The moment @joshuawongcf was forced into a police van #HKSAR20
#Venezuela: Helicopter Strafes Court in while #NicolasMaduro Speaks in ‘Terrorist Attack’
Colombias Marxist guerrilla group the FARC, officially disarm, ending 52 years of fighting.
Prince William and David Cameron implicated in Fifa #WorldCup corruption scandal
France says Trump accepts invitation to attend July 14 Paris celebrations via @Reuters
Madrid metro drivers call strike during WorldPride
Paul Singer Says Joke Is On Developed World Economies Who Steal Growth From the Future $
ICYMI: North Koreas chemical weapon deterrent #sarin #VX
More Than 250 US Mayors Commit To 100% Renewable Energy Amidst Adoption Of New…
NSA spying scandal committee presents controversial final report
GOP senator says Trump doesnt understand basic elements of healthcare bill: report
Newest burger at Sonic blends beef w/ mushrooms so you eat less meat | @FastCompany #climate
Euro Hits High Against The US Dollar, UK Pound And 10 Year Sov Yield Rise as BofE and ECB…
congratulations to the person who found the most threatening way to phrase this appeal
The Supreme Court just made being on death row even worse
Research Affiliates On Equity Returns By Political Party – An International Look $
Minister acted unlawfully in not stopping Lough Neagh sand dredging says court of appeal
Let science be a springboard for politics. Do you agree?
Haley and Mattis credit White House statement with stopping Syria chemical attack
Approach All Claims Of Market-Beating Formula With Extreme Skepticism
Paddington Bear creator Michael Bond dies aged 91
GTM Predicts 27% Drop In Solar Prices By 2022
EURUSD is up even though the ECB is pumping speculators breaks. Cable is up because of Carney. Real winner: $EURGBP
Warren Buffett: GOP healthcare bill should be called Relief for the Rich Act
Italy threatens EU with closure of ports to rescue boats
U.K. Cabinets Mixed Message on Brexit Bridging Deal @simonjkennedy @tomkeene @guyjohnsontv
COSAFA Cup - Sable Antelopes, Taifa Stars in Goalless Draw: #Angola #Tanzania
FREE: Markets want #US #shale producers to slow down - for the sake of prices #OOTT
#IPCapitalPartners 1Q17 – Pricing Power
:LOL - Dual mandate. Theres only one mandate.
David v Goliath battle between one woman and a corporate giant. Coming soon. Watch this space!
U.S. GASOLINE STOCKS fell -0.9 million bbl to 241 million bbl in the week to Jun 23
Even the Magic 8-ball prefers Gmail.
Pound climbs towards $1.30 as BoE gov Mark Carney hints at interest-rate hike
I was told there would be no Peterson Institute today.
Namibia Ruling Party Politician Hikopua in Car Crash: #Namibia
Dont Regulate Drones Like Theyre Missiles | @mchorowitz @BulletinAtomic
This AI can predict how rich your neighborhood is from space
Wave Power Could Contribute 10% Of Global Electricity Demand By 2050
Malawi to Impose Curfew On Night Buses, Trucks - Report: #Malawi
Carney says #BOE may need to remove stimulus as slack erodes via @UKeconews
Police Arrest Student Leaders After Fees Demonstration: #Zimbabwe
Six charged over #Hillsborough stadium disaster
China frees activists arrested after investigating labor conditions at Ivanka shoe factory
Dont Abandon Patriotism, Kaunda Reminds Africa: #Africa
Equities Turn So Hot Even Central Bankers Are Taking Notice via @SofiaHC1 @markets
The Feds Bullard crashes the panel!
#Gold edges higher as dollar faces further weakness @MarketWatch
Blockchain Startup ChromaWay to Launch Hybrid Database Product
Is it really possible to make an ethical smartphone?
In 2012, the global satellite industry generated 189.5 billion dollars.
India Petrol Price Index for June: 100.6, previous: 103.4 (change: -2.8%) #WPI
Protest against nationwide mob lynchings at Delhi’s Jantar Mantar, as part of #NotInMyName campaign
Gasoline demand
U.S. REFINERY THROUGHPUT fell -262,000 b/d to 16.9 million b/d in the week to Jun 23
Entitlement reform is finally here—and its ugly
The ocean is a powerful, but fragile force. Now its changing in unpredictable ways
Fecal bacteria found in Costa, Starbucks and Caffe Nero
Designing dignity in housing for Chicagos most vulnerable (via @nextcity) #500Khomeless
Medicaid funding cuts will have painful consequences for seniors
What Was So Innocent about the Gilded Age? | @jeffreyatucker
#FairTax17 .@LehtoKatja @etuc_ces about to take the floor on Stakeholders role in shaping taxation policies
Britain is shifting TO THE LEFT as the public rejects austerity, study finds. #ToriesOut
US NET CRUDE IMPORTS remained very steady at 7.5 million b/d in the week to Jun 23 (little changed from prior weeks)
Making Ivanka Trump shoes: Long hours, low pay and abuse
Most Uphold Baker’s Right to Refuse Gay Wedding Cake... #BeakingPoll
#Euro DROP - Breaking News on @TheTerminal right now
Why Uganda Should Visit Ethiopia Before Reviving Airlines: #EastAfrica
House prices to stay high forever, predicts ex-Bank of England guru 
What we can learn from Harry Potter’s “mad women”, by @bethanylamont #harrypotter20
LBMA #Gold Price (PM) is USD 1,248.00, EUR 1,098.24 (June 28, 2017)
The Senate health care bill is far from dead.
See what Trump and his administration are saying about China
Theresa May has signalled an end to the UKs 7-year long public sector pay freeze
Accused NSA leaker has trial set for October
The #GrenfellTower fire death toll rises to around 80 people
London luxury home values fall 6.8% in year since #Brexit vote
How Brexit could break the cycle of poverty
Navigant Research Identifies 1,842 Microgrid Projects Worldwide, Totaling Nearly…
Groups that observed Cambodias local election will be investigated by Hun Sens government
#CryptoGreen! #bitcoin
.@jeremycorbyns badge today says scrap the cap. Self knowledge is a wonderful thing
U.S. CRUDE OIL IMPORTS accelerated slightly to 8.0 million b/d in week to Jun 23 from 7.9 million b/d the prior week
British expat probed after causing bomb scare in Spanish shopping mall #Crime_Law #Lead
The real stars! #Andalucia #Food_Drink
New US Energy Dept. Grid Study Even Gives Oil Gas The Heebie-Jeebies
Shania Twain back after 15 years
Sex Tape Rocks Liberias Ruling Party: #Liberia
One nation, one tax, one market! India braces for major tax overhaul
The Petya ransomware attack made roughly $20k less than WannaCry in its first 24 hours
Trump moves to withdraw US water protection
Another dive for the $DXY Dollar Index now puts the mid-point (50% Fib) of a 30-year range in view at 95.70
Zimbabweans in South Africa Demand Voting Rights #Zimbabwe

The importance of randomness
1 month ago

The greatest strength of a truly free market economy, where money is sound and does not corrupt prices, is the absence of cyclical action. With sound money, and consumers deciding for themselves their wants and satisfactions, having to choose between this or that instead of deploying unbacked credit to have this and that, there can be no cycle of credit, and no credit-driven business cycles.

Central bank manipulation of money is intended to force everyone to act the same way at the same time. Central banks direct the quantity of money and credit to encourage us en masse to spend money we do not have, supplanting the randomness of Schumpeter’s “creative destruction” with a synchronised destruction, deferred to the end of the credit cycle.

The constructive and continually evolving process of reallocation of capital from uneconomic projects to more productive uses is ruined by unsound money. To this damage can be added extensive regulation, promoted by governments as being in the public interest, but more accurately, designed to protect established businesses from competition. You cannot sell ice cream without a license, and even then, its composition is regulated by the state.

Economic progress brought about by technology has always been despite government economic planning. Horse power was replaced by the internal combustion engine, but all the muck-shifters, coachmen and blacksmiths found re-employment in other trades. Drudgery in the home was replaced by labour-saving equipment, and domestic servants gained other employment and a higher level of personal freedom. Computers have automated all the things we want to automate.

These advances have been driven by enormous shifts in consumer demand, but the individual investments in new, up-and-coming industries still have their successes and failures, and in free markets these successes and failures are just as non-cyclical as in any other line of business. That is why we can describe economic activity in free markets with sound money as essentially non-cyclical and therefore random. But government bureaucrats don’t do random. It goes against their controlling nature. This is why repeating cycles in the economy have their origin in government intervention and will continue, as will unsound money, until the fiat money system collapses.

Even under the gold standard money was unsound, because banks were free to expand unbacked credit at will, formalised by the 1844 Bank Charter Act, which endorsed fractional reserve banking. Not long after the creation of the Federal Reserve Board, central banks colluded with each other to manipulate the quantity of money. Central banks have been generally free from criticism of their actions, arguing that evolution of monetary policy renders the past irrelevant. To combat this nonsense, the few critics left standing can only use reasoned theory, which given the general disinterest in monetary affairs, is an uphill struggle.

However, the logic that in a sound-money economy credit-driven cycles do not exist, is irrefutable, because it takes unbacked credit expansion to get economic actors to abandon random activity and act in concert. The question then to be answered is can there be any other source of cycles? The answer must address human behaviour itself, which is undoubtedly prone to being driven by fads and fashion. But in the absence of easy credit, a person buying into the latest fashion must divert funds from buying something else, or compromise personal cash liquidity. He or she cannot have both. We can therefore assume that while ephemeral shifts in the use of money and savings can take place in a sound money environment, they are bound to be more limited without the expansion of unbacked credit.

Booms and busts that have their origin in human behaviour rather than credit have occurred. The South Sea Bubble, which popped in 1720, could be cited as an example. The lure of easy profit tempted people living in London, or within a day or two’s coach ride, to divert their gold and silver from other uses into speculating in the stock market. The same had happened with the tulip mania in Holland in 1636. We cannot say these events were totally free of unbacked credit, debased or clipped coinage, but they were relatively so. In the absence of freely available unbacked credit, these speculative booms are too rare to be called cyclical. Rather, they are instances of the extraordinary popular delusions and madness of crowds that drive them, as Charles Mackay aptly described it.

The Mississippi bubble in France was different, because it’s architect, John Law, used a combination of money-printing and share issuance to fuel it. Eight decades later, France made the same error of debasing money by issuing assignats as a means of paying down the royal debts. This currency collapsed rapidly, as did the mandats currency that followed the revolution. Even this was not cyclical: true cyclicality only came with the validation of bank credit in the 1844 Bank Charter Act in England.

The origins of modern credit cycles

We must accept the possibility of mass speculation in an economy based on sound money, but any tendency towards regularly repeating human behaviour requires the rocket-fuel of unbacked money and credit. We are now addressing formalised bubbles: the 1844 Act led to a repeating cycle of bank credit increasing in good times, leading to speculative excess, banking crises, slumps, then recovery. This was the pure credit-driven business cycle. The Bank of England first developed the modern function of lender of last resort in the years following the 1844 Act, to rescue failing banks central to this cycle of credit.

After the Fed was established in 1913, a dialog with the BoE gradually developed, which in the 1920s grew into a close working relationship between Benjamin Strong, Chairman of the Fed, and Montague Norman, Governor of the BoE. Their cooperation over monetary policy, expanding credit while maintaining the gold standard, fuelled industrial production in the 1920s with restrained price inflation. This was followed by the greatest credit bust in history, apart, that is, from the Mississippi bubble. The legacy of global unemployment in the 1930s hung over politics until the 1980s, and changed mainstream economic thinking to this day.

The twenties boom and thirties bust were made more violent and prolonged by cooperation between the two central banks, which were the issuers of the most important currencies at the time. The natural randomness of the free markets of the two greatest nations had been fatally compromised.

Following WW2, a new cycle of intervention commenced, comprising greater government involvement in Britain and Europe, supported by monetary expansion. In the US, the government stimulated the economy through defence spending and the expansion of American corporations, paid for by exporting dollars, which were guaranteed under the Bretton Woods Agreement, as well as expanding domestic bank credit. A new super-cycle of US dollar credit was created, whereby it was expanded without the consequences of runaway price inflation, that is until the Bretton Woods Agreement failed in 1971. Subsequently, prices began to rise despite attempts to restrain them.

The Bank of England was forced to increase interest rates in November 1973 sufficiently to create a slump in the economy, though they didn’t peak until 1979. The Fed finally ended the dollar’s post-war credit cycle by raising the Fed funds rate to over 20% in 1981.

The 1945-1980 period was something of a super-cycle, where Keynesian intervention ameliorated end-of-cycle crises, leaving distortions to accumulate from one credit cycle to another. Since then, the world has embarked on a new super-cycle of credit, this time fuelling asset prices, while the production of goods in America entered a long-term decline. Commodity prices have been suppressed by the expansion of artificial supply through paper derivatives. Cheaper production in emerging markets and the suppression of raw material prices have kept price inflation below where it would otherwise be, allowing the creation of fiat currency and unbacked credit to continue for a prolonged period. The focus of credit expansion, particularly after the regulatory changes in the mid-eighties, has been debt-fuelled consumption and speculative investment.

But this cycle has its roots before 1981, in the post-war years.

The current super-cycle of speculative investment

It started with the cult of the equity in the 1950s, when the risk-reward of investment tipped away from bonds towards equities. This was justified by the prospect of mild price inflation. While modest at first, it threatened to get out of control after President Nixon abandoned the link between the dollar and gold in 1971. A growing consensus was developing, that buying equities gave investors greater financial security than a portfolio of bonds. But this was only true at certain stages of the credit-driven business cycle, when the central bank suppressed interest rates below their natural level and encouraged the expansion of bank credit. At other times, exposure to equities could and did lead to substantial portfolio losses.

The simplest way for a member of the public to benefit from the enhanced returns of equities without being tripped up by investment risk, cyclical or otherwise, was to hand over money to an expert. The investor is reassured. These so-called experts, fund managers, began to tout for business by comparing their returns with an appropriate index. Again, this works well during the initial stages of a central bank induced credit cycle, when even a fool can make money. All the fund manager must do is avoid the more obvious dogs and go for investments leveraged to the stimulus of credit. But when the credit cycle advances, and money begins to flow from financial instruments into the productive economy, the financial bubble is pricked. But few fund managers are concerned with these dynamics, because they have a greater interest in keeping assets under management growing, instead of paying attention to cyclically-changing risk factors.

Over time, even fund managers have become disillusioned with their inability to stock-pick. They regularly underperform the benchmarks they set themselves, and get stick for it. Since the technology bubble of 1997/2000, which was a major set-back for value investment, they have increasingly given up on active management and turned to index tracking, and more recently exchange-traded funds, or ETFs.

At first sight, ETFs are a good way to play investment cycles, or themes. They are available for all categories of investment, so a fund manager or even the individual investor can buy into baskets of commodities, bonds, currencies, foreign markets, inverse ETFs and leveraged ETFs. These ETFs, marketed as a means of controlling investment risk, instead add a potential risk to investment, which emanates from the manager, the structure, and the derivatives used. These risks are hard to quantify, are buried in the small print in the prospectus, and so are generally ignored.

The transition from bond diversification in the 1950s to the ETFs of today has encouraged everyone in capital markets to expose increasing quantities of their savings to trend risk. A savings super-cycle has developed, incorporating several credit cycles, ending up with investors disregarding risk assessment almost entirely.

There can be little doubt that in a sound-money economy, shorn of the distortions created by unbacked money and credit, investment opportunities would tend to be selected on their individual merits. This is because a bad investment cannot be bailed out by monetary expansion. Investment returns in sound money come from its increased purchasing power over time, the consequence of economic progress. A portfolio of ten stocks and bonds purchased for ten ounces of gold in ten years’ time might only be worth twelve or thirteen ounces, but those ounces would buy more than they did ten years before.

We have yet to see how this credit-driven investment super-cycle will end. But we can conjecture that the concealment of risk in modern portfolios comprised of index-trackers and ETFs, is a dangerous mirage, and could end badly. A parallel example is how banks convinced themselves that risky mortgages were not risky if packaged together in a securitisation. That miscalculation and the derivatives built upon it led to the great financial crisis of nine years ago, threatening a systemic collapse of the entire banking system.

The removal of apparent risk by synthetic financial engineering is always an illusion, and when the investing public begins to smell a rat, baskets of seemingly riskless portfolios could be rapidly liquidated, leading to indiscriminate selling of stocks.

In a properly functioning market, where investors are driven by perceptions of entrepreneurial and economic value, lower prices are an opportunity. Today, value considerations are overwhelmed by the trend-chasers and their utilitarian investment vehicles. All that the owners of equity ETFs understand is that prices always rise, so what could go wrong? The risk that is rising interest rates, or a final stalling of credit-fuelled consumption, will undermine the trend. There will be too few buyers to stop it.

If it hadn’t been for the emergence of sovereign wealth funds and quantitative easing (central banks supporting markets by buying bonds and even equities), markets would probably have crashed already. It is the last and most extreme form of market-rigging by governments and their central banks issuing unbacked money.

The cyclical accumulation of debt

The distortion of investment returns by credit cycles is reflected visibly in the prices of securities. Less obvious is the accumulation of debt, which in parallel with financial markets has evolved its own super-cycle. Gone are the days of bank credit being expanded initially for the benefit of large businesses, followed by other businesses, and then finally for consumers borrowing a modest mortgage to buy a house. Nowadays, debt has been securitised. Banks and their associated credit vehicles feel insulated from individual risks. Money is loaned to students, partially underwritten by state and local taxes. Automobiles are sold on credit. Credit card debt is securitised as well. Consequently, on every credit cycle the amount of debt facing liquidation accumulates, and more and more ordinary people are drawn into debt earlier in the credit cycle.

Since the great financial crisis in 2007/08, student debt in the US has more than doubled, up 132%. Total consumer credit (or debt, ex-mortgages) has increased by 46%, including car loans by 40%. So, despite the greatest financial shock ever faced by consumers less than ten years ago, they have continued to accumulate debt. The other side of this debt is the assets and consumption being financed. That new neighbour, who recently paid more than you did a few years ago for a house in your street, with two new cars in the drive and frequent foreign holidays, is likely to be deeply in debt, owning nothing outright. Wealth has become a middle-class illusion.

This illusion increases on every cycle, and every cycle the innocent consumer, egged on by the financial system, in turn egged on by the central bank, believes the threat of an economic bust has been banished for ever. And with salaries not keeping pace with price inflation, easy credit has been a lifeline for the average consumer. But like every fairy-tale, not only is there a beginning and a middle to the credit cycle, there is always an end, and it’s not “they lived happily ever after”.

The end of our tale always involves a greater rescue effort from widespread insolvency than the last time it was told. Last time, the Fed’s open cheque was estimated to be worth about $13tn, on a GDP of about $14.5tn when the crisis hit. This time GDP is over $19tn, and bank credit has risen from under $9tn to $12.5tn. The Fed’s open cheque to save the system will have to be larger accordingly. This time, if it’s ETFs and index trackers that need rescuing, the prevention of another Wall Street crash would require the Fed to buy massive quantities of stocks and bonds to save the system.

Randomness is banished from banking as well

Making this credit cycle even more dangerous are the G20 meetings of finance ministers and central banks, where it is formally agreed to coordinate monetary policy. Randomness has become completely subverted to the global coordination of the credit cycle through regular group-thinking sessions at the highest level. Furthermore, the imposition of common standards on the banks through Basel II and Basel III, means the banks are loaded up with the same asset classes. By holding the same assets, all the banks are gaming the system when it comes to capital ratios, so they can pass the stress tests. Consequently, stress tests are meaningless.

For example, the European Banking Commission in 2010 stress tested 91 of the largest European banks. All the Irish banks passed, only to be bailed out four months later. A stricter stress test was devised by the ECB in 2011, which passed Dexia and Spain’s Bankia as sound, as well as the whole Cypriot banking system. Dexia, based in the Low Countries, failed within three months, Bankia was so obviously insolvent it’s a mystery how they were ever passed, and the whole Cypriot banking system collapsed two years later.i

It’s not just the Europeans either. We should take note that the global banking system has not been fixed in the ten years since the onset of the great financial crisis. Professor Dowd’s extensive work on this subject (an example of which is referred to in the end-notes) is required reading for anyone who erroneously thinks that regulation of banks removes or lessens systemic risk.

The reason this is so important is the banks are the intermediaries between the continuing increase in private sector debt and the asset prices they hold as collateral. The banks have provided the credit for their customers to inflate assets, which they take on board as collateral against loans. If the odd bank behaved like this, we would draw parallels with banking at the time of John Law’s Mississippi bubble, withdraw our deposits and say good riddance when it collapses. But all banks are doing this at the same time in multiple jurisdictions, and the systemic protection afforded by variety in banking business models, typical of free markets, is gone. Worse still, banks are pressured to standardise risk management tools and procedures, so in a crisis they are likely to make things considerably worse by taking the same avoiding action by selling the same asset classes at the same time.ii

Gone is the protection of randomness. For the regulators, who are meant to be experts in assessing and controlling bank risk, it really is a case of see no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil. They all agree with each other that they are open minded, constantly reviewing the situation, but are instead trapped by political pressures, bank lobbying and their own groupthink, which incidentally, they are quick to deny.

For the investing public seeking to protect and preserve their assets, the onset of the crisis stage of the credit cycle is always a surprise. Let’s hope that for readers of this article it will be less so.

Summary and conclusion

It is hard for even experienced analysts to appreciate the accumulation of risks that result from central banks managing the credit cycle. This is partly because of a natural inclination to believe that the Jeremiahs have been discredited by the passage of time from the last crisis. But while we can all see some obvious threats, such as a dicky Eurozone banking system, the derivatives mountain or the bank lending bubble in China, no single threat jumps out as certain to cause the collapse the world’s financial and economic system.

The threat is in the credit cycle. Credit cycles always, without fail, end in a crisis. We can say this as certainly we expect the tide to continue its ebb and flow. How the next credit crisis is expected to manifest itself is a matter of judgement, as is its timing. This article has attempted to point the reader towards a greater understanding of the factors involved, so that he or she can better judge relevant developments. If consumer prices continue to rise (US producer prices are already rising at 2.5% year-on-year), interest rates will have to rise until they cause the crisis. Same ending, every time.

The following is a summary of the main points in this article, which individually are not necessarily cause for alarm, but most probably are when taken together.

  • Central banking’s monetary policies have destroyed the randomness of economic activity that with sound money leads to economic progress without meaningful disruption.
  • The overriding mistake is to believe that business cycles are endemic to free markets. The cycle is one of credit imposed on the economy. Central banks have put the cart before the horse.
  • Successive credit cycles accumulate debt, until there is a crisis of larger magnitude. The current cycle has been of declining interest rates since 1981, generating a valuation boom that has driven bond yields to all-time lows, and equities to all-time highs. This cycle is unlikely to survive the current trend of rising consumer prices, because of the unprecedented accumulation of private sector debt.
  • The evolution of equity investment has probably reached its end-point with the widespread use of ETFs. ETFs have convinced the investing public that investment is risk-free, for the same psychological reason banks thought that securitisation of mortgages banished lending risk.
  • Successive credit cycles have seen the expansion of consumer debt earlier and earlier. The result is consumer wealth is apparent rather than real, adding to the general complacency.
  • The banks are stuffed full of overvalued assets, which they have helped to puff up by lending money for further purchases of the same asset classes. Market purchases by central banks and sovereign wealth funds have made financial distortions even worse.
  • Regulators have compounded systemic risk, not reduced it. Their focus has been directed by internal groupthink and the construction of artificial risk criteria such as Basel II and Basel III, which fail to address risk properly. On this and capital adequacy, banks both lobby and game the system, and are considerably more fragile than regulators would have us believe.


Monetary inflation transfers wealth from most ordinary people on Main Street to the banks on Wall Street and their favoured customers. Growing numbers of ordinary people are finding it impossible to make ends meet, with their credit cards becoming maxed out. Even if interest rates do not rise, it is possible for the credit crisis to be brought on by a combination of loss of wealth and unsupportable debt. In any event, the crisis should be initially signalled by strains in the wholesale money markets.

iSee Kevin Dowd’s summary of how ineffective various bank regulators are at judging bank solvency: p.518

iiibid, p.513

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not reflect those of Goldmoney, unless expressly stated. The article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute either Goldmoney or the author(s) providing you with legal, financial, tax, investment, or accounting advice. You should not act or rely on any information contained in the article without first seeking independent professional advice. Care has been taken to ensure that the information in the article is reliable; however, Goldmoney does not represent that it is accurate, complete, up-to-date and/or to be taken as an indication of future results and it should not be relied upon as such. Goldmoney will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage, or inconvenience caused as a result of any information or opinion contained in this article and any action taken as a result of the opinions and information contained in this article is at your own risk.