Investors Wait Anxiously for Nigeria Presidents Speech #Nigeria
Floods, landslides kill more than 800 people across South Asia
UN voices concern after #Rome migrant eviction
Libya Halts Biggest #Oil Field Loadings in Latest Disruption via @S_Elwardany #OOTT
#Croatias 10 most jaw-dropping beaches by @PeterDragNZ
Crackdown on Riots - Kenyan Police to Be Sued Over Babys Death #Kenya
Ex-CIA official knocks Trump: He only wants intelligence that fits his preconceived notions
France Petrol Price Index for August: 95.6, previous: 95.6 (change: 0%) #WPI
A mini Bluetooth TV soundbar with an unexpectedly big bark
@neilhimself Technically a snow sculpture rather than a statue. My dad and I built it in the 70s.
#Gold up in European trading today (Aug. 21, 2017)
French presidency gives official role to #BrigitteMacron after public outcry
Credit Card Giant Visa Hints at Digital Asset Service Plans
Stefanidi wins 12th consecutive pole vault competition
Trump Official Once Praised a Defender of Holocaust Deniers
BG Foods gobbles up SnackWell, Back to Nature brands
Africa: Business confidence remains high. #SMI
Thais to deploy 4,000 police for ex-PM #Yinglucks negligence trial verdict
Raqqa families make daring escapes from Islamic State stronghold
LBMA #Gold Price (AM) is USD 1,287.60, EUR 1,096.52 (Aug. 21, 2017)
A Cosmic Theory and a 2-Inch Lump of #Gold via @natalieobiko
Popescu Report - #Gold and North Korea
#China urges halt to US-S.Korea military drills #UlchiFreedomGuardian
Military drills by South Korea and US #WarGames
#China calls US intellectual property investigation ‘irresponsible’
#Eclipse parking: $100 a day. Cashing in on the eclipse, USA-style:
.@vanceserchuk on how trying to leave Afghanistan forced America to stay
#Jordan PPI year-on-year at -0.1%
CNN Balks at Trump Campaign Ad Calling Media ‘Enemies’ [Video]
#IvoryCoast Industrial Production year-on-year at 1.8%
Chinas trophy hunting crackdown wont deter the shadow bankers
The humanitarian situation in #SouthSudan is the worst I’ve known in two decades,
2040 2050 Pollution Car Bans Not So Bold
EUR remaining out of favor...? CBs have not joined the EUR comeback (yet)...
When is Eid al-Adha 2017?
Americas most prominent CEOs knew they had a problem well before Trumps Tuesday comments
#Latvia PPI year-on-year at 3.6%
#Latvia PPI month-on-month at 0.4%
The case for #Ukrainian #energy independence - and what the government needs to do #OOTT
Trump attacks dishonest Fake News reporting as he ends vacation
Unplugging is nearly impossible now; by 2026 it will be even tougher experts say
Chinas Great Wall confirms interest in Fiat Chrysler
Greek bears are ready for business. From shop window in Monastiraki #Greece
#Oman Budget Balance at OMR -397.8M
The economic and moral case for global open borders, by @georgeeaton
After 38 years, Angola will soon get a new president, but what is the electoral process?
Taiwans KMT pulls pro-unification plank from party platform
This mod makes GoldenEye 64 different every time you play
The NS Leader: Trumps dangerous nation
Monte dei Paschis OBG Upgraded to A+; Outlook Stable
Formula One launches eSports world championship
who says were not as stupid about anything today..?
Mini thread/rant here about what Brexit does and doesnt mean for refugee protection in the UK.
SPECIAL REPORT | #Greece beyond the second review: Challenges and opportunities
Merkel attacks Turkey’s ‘misuse’ of Interpol warrants
Uber’s huge Hong Kong price hike gives advantage to taxis
Burger Joint Shake Shack Shimmies Into Shanghai #shakeshack #shanghai #Restaurant #KFC
Silting a growing problem at Latin America’s largest port
Police Intensify Hunt After Many Women Killed in Same Area #Uganda
On eFinancialCareers: Goldman Sachs is doing some big hiring in equities algo trading
UK Durable Goods Price Index for August: 76.5, previous: 78 (change: -2%) #WPI
How Mysuru became India’s ‘cleanest city’
Total solar eclipse: US braces for rare astronomical event:
This, on Trump...
Assault-Accused South African Ministers Resignation Too Late? #SouthAfrica
Londons property sellers lower their expectations as the slowdown shows few signs of easing
Greek #bond yield falls after Fitch upgrade:
Millions of Americans await awe-inspiring total solar eclipse
Government moves against pension scammers
Central banks’ diverse mandates via @endacurran
Danish submarine builder dumped body of ex-SCMP reporter in sea after ‘accident’ on vessel
Everyone on twitter hates everything
Spotted on Brussels metro. Roughly translates to Do you like wearing socks and sandals? Then learn German!
BREAKING: One killed in car-ramming at Marseille bus stop, French police
Italy increases protection of key sites after Spain attacks
Bodyguard accidentally shoots gun during boarding at Berlin airport
Spanish mother cut in half by hospital lift doors minutes after giving birth
Is this a good thing ? Some of them do reg arb, aggressive tax and questionable culture - plus this
US sharply scales back visa services in Russia after diplomatic row via @Reuters
China has expressed a strong dissatisfaction with a U.S. trade probe
10 years after The Crash: A Scientific Review Of BBC Bias - @BiasedBBCblog
Myanmar man faces two years in jail for speaking about his ordeal as a child soldier
Why schools are getting education all wrong
Prime Minister says Estonias story far from being finished
Weekend paper review – The young ones
Our union backed Brexit, but that doesnt mean scrapping freedom of movement
Wait And See Approach On Brexit - 21 Aug 17 | Gazunda
Dont Expect US Policy Change - 21 Aug 17 | Gazunda
Watching Euro For Signs Of Further Weakness Against The Dollar - 21 Aug 17 | Gazunda
Why This Strategist Is Positive On Base Metals - 21 Aug 17 | Gazunda
Professor - Brexit Will Boost U.K. Economy - 21 Aug 17 | Gazunda
North Koreas Next Step - 21 Aug 17 | Gazunda
Aberdeen - The U.S. Dollar Is Oversold - 21 Aug 17 | Gazunda
Oil is near a one-week high after U.S. drilling slows again
One killed in Marseille, France after car crashes into bus shelters: police via @Reuters
CNN pushes live town hall with Ryan for Trumps Afghanistan announcement
Yellen, Draghi Head to Jackson Hole Amid Inflation Unease
Lithuanian media watchdog to consider steps against 2 Russian TV channels
Singapore: 10 Sailors missing after USS John McCain collides with oil tanker
Erdogan in war of words with Merkel
Earthquakes Hit Off Coast of Liberia #Liberia
On Las Ramblas: the symbolic heart of Barcelona
Australian citizenship crisis erodes support for government
Brazil Recreation Index for August: 131.6, previous: 130.3 (change: 1%) #WPI
Why news algorithms are the enemy of civil society.
French unions fret as Macron readies his promised labor-law upheaval via @AngelineBenoit
Debt Rattle August 21 2017 | First of all: stop hating each other. It doesnt lead anywhere
Erdogan says Turkey and Iran discussing joint action against Kurdish militants
Danish sub inventor dumped body of Swedish journalist Kim Wall in sea: police
World In Pictures
Why Professor Minford says #Brexit will boost UK economy via @Brexit
If you own or follow bitcoin, here are 3 things to watch in the coming months
Debt Rattle August 21 2017 | Youre being played in a fake culture war
India is facing record defaults
Greece not a terror target, minister says
Greek government bond yields dip after Fitch upgrade
Greek current account surplus shrinks in June, tourism revenues rise
US Navy destroyer USS John S. McCain collides with Stealth Maritime tanker off Singapore
Here are the U.S. states where your money will go furthest in retirement
Can Trump make a deal with North Korea? @UriLF looks at the options:
Insurance: A Valuable Incentive for Small Farmers’ #Climate Resilience via @ipsnews @WFP
Opinion: Facing an inconvenient truth, Hong Kong’s monetary authority chooses to stay mum
Only 2.5 factors out of 18 are worrying in Citi Global Bear Market Checklist.
Debt Rattle August 21 2017 | Absolutely everything on the eclipse by Stephen Wolfram
Debt Rattle August 21 2017 | China coal and steel, German carmakers: Too Big to Fail
Jack Ma, Aliko Dangote and Lloyd Blankfein will meet world leaders at a Bloomberg event
Five reasons to live in Londons South Kensington
Meet the meat-free Hong Kong parents on a vegan mission
Anti-Semitism: The terrible fright of “Unite the Right”
Lithuanias Klaipeda remains Baltics No 1 container port
U.S. gas traders are doing more deals based on the price of physical supplies more on @theterminal via @naurtorious
Captain’s log. Stardate: 21:08:2017.47 - Damage Report
The trouble with a second Brexit referendum, by @georgeeaton
Jack Ma, Aliko Dangote and Lloyd Blankfein will meet world leaders at a Bloomberg event
Fitch Affirms Andorra at BBB; Outlook Positive
This map could change the way we treat cancer
Oil tanker hit by U.S. warship laden with fuel oil; no spill
Rosneft completes acquisition of Essar Oil stake
Today’s Top Performing #ActivistManagers Share Traits With #BenjaminGraham $
Bio-Hacking: Doctor Implanted 6 MicroChips Under His Skin to Unlock Doors and Secure Data
Maersk Oil sold to Total for $7.45bn #shipping
Silting a growing problem at Latin America’s largest port
Two general cargo ships collide near Fujian, three dead and six missing
Fujian Anda Shipping orders bulker at Fujian Southeast Shipbuilding #shipping
Explosion kills four at STX’s main yard in South Korea
U.S. and South Korea practice virtual war against the North
Lithuanian president proposes to increase fines for crimes
Core inflation momentum - whos the one in the toughest spot going into Jackson Hole?
Marseille - Driver arrested, motive unclear for now via @MarQs__
France Food Price Index for August: 95.4, previous: 95.7 (change: -0.3%) #WPI
Britain will not exclude possible EU oversight of Irish border
Why Great Wall should steer clear of Jeep @sbanjo via @gadfly
These are the most pressing challenges facing Europes leaders
Eclipse chasers descend on Illinois town
A quick guide for those who cant figure out a nairas worth
A perfect start to a sunny Sunday. Open water swimming at Shepperton Lake. #lpinuk #swim
China set to build on its dominant crude oil import position
Residents of this US town are likely to become climate refugees in under 50 years
Opinion: Three ways Singapore can benefit from China’s belt and road
WATCH: CNNs Zakaria torches elites mealy-mouthed response to Trump on Charlottesville
Merkel stands by her decision to open German borders via @BerlinTony
Finlands ambitious school redesign program
Total to buy Maersk Oil Gas for $4.95 billion in shares
New Zealand opposition leader embroiled in second sexism row
Is Google Maps discriminating against people with disabilities? @Anoosh_C reports:
Mongol Empire at its peak in 1279 -
Stealth Maritime sells ageing MR for $8m
Mask your hangover: five overnight skin solutions
Kim Wall died in accident on board submarine: Peter Madsen
Andrew Hill — What Donald Trump lost by wrecking his business relationships
Is Google Maps discriminating against people with disabilities? @Anoosh_C reports:
Bavarian leader criticized after dropping demand for maximum number of refugees
Govt Admits Plane Seized in Canada, Blames Opposition: #Tanzania
US to pause issuing non-immigrant visas in Russia: embassy via @AFP
India is facing record defaults
Trump ramping up for 2020 reelection via @politicoalex
Germany Durable Goods Price Index for August: 115.6, previous: 115.6 (change: 0%) #WPI
Kim Wall died in accident on board submarine: Peter Madsen
Trump to present vision for U.S. strategy in Afghanistan war
Extremely dissatisfied China blames India for border scuffle via @Reuters
Tax cuts as the lowest GOP common denominator.
Central Park Tower to become worlds tallest residential skyscraper:
You can be forgotten online, but not in the British Library via @jeremyakahn
Goldman Sachs warns a stronger euro may be Russian bonds Achilles heel via @markets
Quick guide for those who cant figure out the #nairas worth. #Nigeria
Musk warns of killer robot arms race - BBC News
Corporations can display good citizenship, too, @Profepps argues
Southern African Leaders Urged to Use Resources to Spur Industry #SouthAfrica
World shares mostly down
European manhunt on for main suspect in Barcelona van terror attack #Lead #Mallorca
UPDATE: Candles lit in #Tanzania for murdered ivory investigator. His team: We will fight on. Please join us.
Husband Attempts Suicide After Wife Found Dead: #Tanzania
Lenovos slump shows not all Asian tech stocks are a one way bet
9 killed in #Philippines #AbuSayyaf attack: Police
We condemn this egregious display of hatred, bigotry and violence, on many sides, many sides. #gameofthrones
Japan posted a trade surplus for another straight month in July
China is taking on the ‘original sin’ of its mountain of debt:
Tanzanian Police Hunt Men Who Shot South African Conservationist #SouthAfrica #Tanzania
Born 21 August 1725 - Jean-Baptiste Greuze, French painter of portraits, genre scenes, and history painting.
#Eclipse countdown: millions converge across US to see sun go dark
Check out our interactive map of the latest onshore and offshore licensing rounds
Its no secret US stocks are expensive – but just how expensive will come as a shock
US and Canadian diplomats in Cuba suffer hearing loss in mysterious sonic attack
Philippines Central Bank Grants First Cryptocurrency Exchange Licenses
Hard transition awaits after summer
Wildfires raze some 50,000 hectares a year, survey finds
A car crashes on two buses in #Marseille: #police operation in progress via @laprovence
Street of Juba on Sunday evening !!!
China set to build on its dominant crude oil import position #shipping
Hong Kong swelters under heat in one of the hottest days of the year
Is this the worst packaging ever?
Any excuse to eat more hummus! #vegan
This new cyberpunk game has players invade peoples nightmares
INSIGHT: Dogs and their owners race in Croatia
Spanish honey production drops, as disappearing bees continue to sound alarm bells
Maersk Oil sold to Total for $7.45bn
One-in-four Brexit voters believe they were misled by the Leave campaign
Hong Kong property investors go trophy hunting in London despite Brexit
The ‘Grand Paris’ era begins
Japan Recreation Index for August: 91, previous: 90.8 (change: 0.2%) #WPI
The Total. What we take, what we make, what we waste.
The #ECB needs a little zen: @Moss_Eco via @BV
Oldendorff bags Samjin handy resales
The Boquería market in Barcelona is here in relation to La Rambla, where the van attack took place.
Euros losses deepen before Jackson Hole via @Reuters
Oil dips on rising US output, but drilling activity slows via @Reuters
Yellen, Draghi head to Jackson Hole amid inflation unease
Japanese state forced to remove ‘sexually suggestive’ tourism video
Trump is president because of 78,000 votes in these three states.
this will forever remain in the top 5 crazy moments in central banking/monetary history.
Inside the Battle for the FDC Presidency: #Uganda
Car carriers fined $38m for Korean price collusion
Deadly Floods and Mudslides Were Man-Made Disaster: #SierraLeone
Southeast Asia’s ‘funding barbell’ spurs new Gobi Partners fund
Future trends for #cybersecurity #fintech #insurtech @cbronline
Building Intelligent #IoT with Fog Computing #fintech #insurtech #AI #machine
Electric cars The death of the internal combustion engine #ICE on ice?
US Food Price Index for August: 97.4, previous: 95.7 (change: 1.7%) #WPI
US President Donald Trump to address the nation on a new strategy in Afghanistan
Solberg new favourite in Norway PM poll
Finnish court names knife attack suspect Abderrahman Mechkah
US gears up for total eclipse
#Britain to treat Internet hate crime as seriously as offline offences
Unintended consequences of MiFID: Job losses, trading turmoil? via @BySarahJones
Facebook diversity chief: ‘We are not in the business of giving away jobs’ by @JPManga
#Finnish court names knife attack suspect as 18-year-old Abderrahman Mechkah
Latin America: Businesses remain wary that conditions will improve further. #SMI
Attention superstitious stock traders... beware of the solar eclipse crash

Mike Shedlock

Mike "Mish" Shedlock is a registered investment advisor representative for SitkaPacific Capital Management. He operates the blog MISH'S Global Economic Trend Analysis and believes in the Austrian School of economics.

Are Banks Hoarding Cash? Debate Over “Free Money” Interest on Excess Reserves

2 months ago

In response to Free Money! Banks Paid $22 Billion to Not Lend? I received a comment from economist Professor George Selgin who said I do not know what I am talking about.

Selgin made similar comments about Chris Whalen, Chairman of Whalen Global Advisors LLC,  in two supporting links.

I also received a Tweet from economist Professor Steve Keen who said: “Mish Nails It“.

Both viewpoints cannot be right. Let’s explore competing viewpoints on lending excess reserves, banks hoarding cash, and free money banks receive from the Fed for interest on excess reserves.

Mish Statements

Excess reserves are a function of the Fed’s balance sheet and those reserves do not change whether a bank lends more or not.

There is no “demand” for excess reserves. Rather, the Fed has crammed excess reserves into the system and has decided to pay interest on them.

  1. Mathematically speaking, excess reserves cannot spur lending.
  2. Banks are not paid $22 billion to “not lend” $2.2 trillion as many contend.
  3. Banks are paid $22 billion because the Fed decided to do so.

Whether or not banks lend has nothing to do with interest on excess loans. Rather, the decision to pay interest on excess reserves is simply $22 billion in free money to banks every year, at taxpayer expense.

Steve Keen

Selgin: Interest on Reserves

In Interest On Reserves, Part II, Selgin writes.

Of the many bemusing chapters of the whole interest-on-reserves tragicomedy, none is more jaw-droppingly so than that in which the strategies’ apologists endeavored to show that paying interest on reserves did not, after all, discourage banks from lending, or contribute to the vast accumulation of excess reserves.

But let us set our befuddlement aside, in order to allow our authors to dispute the view that the vast post-IOR accumulation of excess reserves was evidence that the Fed’s emergency loans and asset purchases weren’t serving to “maintain” an adequate flow of credit:

To the contrary, the level of reserves in the banking system is almost entirely unaffected by bank lending. By virtue of simple accounting, transactions by one bank that reduce the amount of reserves it holds will necessarily be met with an equal increase in reserves held at other banks, and vice versa. As described in detail in a 2009 paper by New York Fed economists Todd Keister and James McAndrews, nearly all of the total quantity of reserves in the banking system is determined solely by the amount provided by Federal Reserve. Thus, the level of total reserves in the banking system is not an appropriate metric for the success of the Fed’s lending programs.

A gold star to all who spot the fallacy here. For those who can’t, it’s simple: “reserves” and “excess reserves” aren’t the same thing. Banks can’t collectively get rid of “reserves” by lending them — the reserves just get shifted around, exactly as Walter and Courtois suggest. But banks most certainly can get rid of excess reserves by lending them, because as banks acquire new assets, they also create new liabilities, including deposits. As the nominal quantity of deposits increases, so do banks’ required reserves. As required reserves increase, excess reserves decline correspondingly. It follows that an extraordinarily large quantity of excess reserves is proof, not only of a large supply of reserves, but of a heightened real demand for such, and of an equivalently reduced flow of credit.

IOER and Banks’ Demand for Reserves, Yet Again

Here are some Selgin snips from IOER and Banks’ Demand for Reserves, Yet Again.

In our recent American Banker opinion piece, Heritage’s Norbert Michel and I argue that, if the Fed is really serious about shrinking its balance sheet, it had better quit paying interest on banks’ excess reserves (IOER) as well. How come? Because the current, relatively high IOER rate is contributing to a strong overall demand for excess reserves, while a shrunken Fed balance sheet will mean a reduced supply of reserves. Reducing the supply of reserves while doing nothing to reduce banks’ demand for them is a recipe for demand-driven deflation, which is a monetary policy no-no.

Predictably (because it has happened every time I write on this topic) our article generated several comments to the effect that we didn’t know what we were talking about, because banks couldn’t possibly prefer the meager 100 basis points they can earn by holding reserves (or something less than that, if they are obliged to pay FDIC premiums) to the far greater amount they can earn by making loans.

The remarkable thing about these criticisms is that they all appear to deny that banks (or some banks, in any event) are in fact sitting on large amounts of excess reserves, and that they are, to that extent, settling for a return on those reserves of 100 basis points or less, instead of swapping  reserves for other assets.

Excess Reserves

Let’s take a step back and look at the definition of “Excess reserves“.

“In banking, excess reserves are bank reserves in excess of a reserve requirement set by a central bank.”

Required Reserves

The reserve requirement (or cash reserve ratio) is a central bank regulation employed by most, but not all, of the world’s central banks, that sets the minimum amount of reserves that must be held by a commercial bank. The minimum reserve is generally determined by the central bank to be no less than a specified percentage of the amount of deposit liabilities the commercial bank owes to its customers.

[in the US] Effective 27 December 1990, a liquidity ratio of zero has applied to CDs and time deposits [e.g. saving accounts], owned by entities other than households, and the Eurocurrency liabilities of depository institutions. Deposits owned by foreign corporations or governments are currently not subject to reserve requirements.

Canada, the UK, New Zealand, Australia, Sweden and Hong Kong have no reserve requirements.
This does not mean that banks can – even in theory – create money without limit. On the contrary, banks are constrained by capital requirements, which are arguably more important than reserve requirements even in countries that have reserve requirements.

Are Banks Slowly Lending Excess Reserves?

One might superficially conclude that banks are lending reserves by looking at the above chart, but here is what’s really happening:  In the process of lending, a portion of the loan gets redeposited in instruments that have reserve requirements.

In the process of lending, a portion of the loan gets redeposited in instruments that have reserve requirements.

Thus, my statement “reserves do not change whether a bank lends more or not,” is incorrect.

Everything else I stated is correct because reserves, excess or otherwise, do not enter into bank lending decisions.

BIS Statement

Please consider BIS Working Papers #292 Unconventional monetary policies: an appraisal, page 19.

In fact, the level of reserves hardly figures in banks’ lending decisions. The amount of credit outstanding is determined by banks’ willingness to supply loans, based on perceived risk-return trade-offs, and by the demand for those loans. The aggregate availability of bank reserves does not constrain the expansion directly.

By the same token,  an expansion of reserves in excess of any requirement does not give banks more resources to expand lending. It only changes the composition of liquid assets of the banking system. Given the very high substitutability between bank reserves and other government assets held for liquidity purposes, the impact can be marginal at best. This is true in both normal and also in stress conditions. Importantly, excess reserves do not represent idle resources nor should they be viewed as somehow undesired by banks (again, recall that our notion of excess refers to holdings above minimum requirements). When the opportunity cost of excess reserves is zero, either because they are remunerated at the policy rate or the latter reaches the zero lower bound, they simply represent a form of liquid asset for banks.

A striking recent illustration of the tenuous link between excess reserves and bank lending is the experience during the Bank of Japan’s “quantitative easing” policy in 2001-2006. Despite significant expansions in excess reserve balances, and the associated increase in base money, during the zero-interest rate policy, lending in the Japanese banking system did not increase robustly.

Bank Credit vs. Reserves

If anyone thinks, as Selgin has proposed, that lending will reduce excess reserves to where they were if only the Fed did not pay interest on reserves, they need explain the above chart.

Between July 2008 and May 2017, bank credit rose by $3.59 trillion. Required reserves rose by all of $134 billion. At that pace, bank credit would have to go up by about $50 trillion to shrink excess reserves back to where they were before QE started.

Does Rising Interest on Reserves Hurt Lending?

Selgin says the Fed needs to halt paying interest on excess reserves to spur lending. Curiously, bank credit rose over $900 billion as the Fed was hiking. If there is any slowdown in lending, it is due to the slowing economy or lack of good customers, not that the Fed is paying increasing amounts of money for excess reserves.

If there is any slowdown in lending, it is due to the slowing economy or lack of good customers, not that the Fed is paying increasing amounts of money for excess reserves.

Loans and Leases vs Reserves

Selgin used loans and leases in his links, so I provide the above alternative to bank credit. One can look at M2 to see similar things.

Banks Lend, That’s What They Do!

Bakers bake, painters paint, homebuilders build, and bankers lend. That’s what they do.

If banks are not capital impaired, and they believe they have a good credit risk who wants to borrow, they lend. In the process, required reserves rise by a tiny amount.

But it’s capital impairment and creditworthy customers that drive the lending process, not reserves.

Definition of Demand

Demand has a couple of meanings. In widespread use, demand is an imposition on someone (e.g. pay me or esle).

What Selgin refers to as demand is the “desire of banks to hold money”. He cites $2 trillion in excess reserves as “proof” of “demand”. The statement is silly.

Banks did not demand $2 trillion in the classic sense, nor are they hoarding money because the Fed pays interest on reserve. Rather, the Fed crammed $2 trillion into the system.

If banks had creditworthy customers willing to borrow, banks would lend. It’s what they do, and it is precisely what the charts I presented show. The reserve requirements on lending are so small they are meaningless.

Elimination of interest on excess reserves will not do anything for lending, However, I am in favor of eliminating interest payments. Giving banks free money at taxpayer expense is galling.

Mike “Mish” Shedlock