The town at the heart of China’s black market in ivory
Firm that produced infamous Trump-Russia dossier wont comply with House Intel subpoena
Bid on exciting travel experiences via The Globe Auction. Hurry, auction ends tomorrow.
Must be because of all my food-related tweets today...
Trump faces backlash after claiming past presidents didnt call families of fallen soliders
Morning political talk shows virtually ignored the truck bombing in Somalia
How Reading Rewires Your Brain for More Intelligence and Empathy:
David Simon loves cities—even screwed-up ones
How people in Asia-Pacific view China
Kenya Tumble Down in FIFA Rankings #Kenya
Trump: U.S. not taking sides as Iraq, Kurds clash in Kirkuk
Four-in-ten Americans credit technology with improving life most in the past 50 years
Adobe warns that hackers are exploiting its Flash software
YouTube add-ons and tricks to improve your watching
Airbus to take majority stake in Bombardiers C-Series program
Honduras and #Ecuador Agree to Deal Improving Economic Relations
Trumps campaign paid his sons Russia-probe law firm $238,000
#WorldFoodDay: How we can build an Africa free from hunger and poverty by @KofiAnnan
JUST IN: Comey drafted Clinton email investigation statement months before interviewing her
From the AP archives: Body Found in Rubble of Burned California Home
Pacific Radiance debt obligations suspended as debt restructuring nears
Famed Chinese dissident: China and Russia are laughing at US under Trump
EU should learn from the #Catalan crisis, says @wesel_barbara
Are misfolded proteins causing Parkinsons? @Neuro_Skeptic
Why Kurdish oil is a wild card for markets
Attention @cnbc @business @wsj @FoxBusiness @nytimes @wapo
Meet the powerful Latino politician running against Senator Dianne Feinstein
Florida governor declares state of emergency over Richard Spencer speech:
The money-losing volatility trade that hedge funds cant resist
Fearing an end to #NAFTA, #Mexico looks to Middle East for new trade partners
Thunder and lightning: scientists pair gravitational waves, light
Woman creates funny photo series with a clone of herself after losing 150-pound in two years
Time Running Out for New-Look Zimbabwe Cabinet? #Zimbabwe
What Happens When President Zuma, a Chess Player Misses the Plot?: #SouthAfrica
Goldman Sachs and IBM — What you need to know in markets on Tuesday @MylesUdland
4 Ways Iran Is Destabilizing the Middle East
Trump is becoming a failed president
Europes Airbus to buy majority stake in Bombardiers CSeries
The battle over Kirkuk marks the prologue of the conflict after ISIS, @kcalamur writes
After socialists win 17 of 23 States, US claims Venezuela elections not free and fair
Asian stocks to gain as Fed chair talk hits bonds @adhaigh
Update: better to be prepared, I always say...
Group using John F Kennedys support for tax cuts to target Dem senators
$SPX Day Movers: Retail hit on $JWN failed MBO. HCare names hit on POTUS. Financials and Energy names lead $XLF $XLE
Trumps Obamacare sabotage is doing real damage to American health care
How Futura became the most ripped-off typeface in history
Trump attacks past sexual assault allegations against him as fake news
BE UnCommon. Blog post on UnCommon Women at #opened17
North Korea warns states: Dont join any U.S. action and youre safe
THE MEMO: Trump isnt letting go of 2016 election victory over Clinton
Yes, that’s Netflix CEO Reed Hastings wearing an ugly Christmas sweater on his earnings call
Are Former Bank Executives Mnuchin And Cohn Encroaching On Regulator Turf? $
Trump travel ban 3.0 hearing ends in Maryland without a ruling
Shesh Venkatraman to depart Miclyn Express Offshore
Photojournalist launches online campaign against Ed Gillespie over stolen image
How soot-covered birds tell the story of American industry
Pennsylvania ObamaCare premiums will rise 30 percent after Trump cut subsidies
Trump’s drug czar nominee under fire for pushing bill that weakened drug enforcement
Egg-shaped dwarf planet Haumea has a ring
Heres what to expect from Xi Jinping as he becomes Chinas most powerful leader since Mao
Louisiana: 7 Injured and 1 Missing as Oil Rig Explodes Near New Orleans
Progressives should be fighting back on Obamacare via @kdrum
Horrific #Somalia bombing is sign of governments powerlessness, says DWs Ludger Schadomsky
The event is over and the doors have been opened.
#Venezuela’s economy expected to shrink 12% by end of 2017: report.
Discounted SanDisk memory cards and other good deals happening today
U.S. buyers favor iPhone 7 over 8: research
#ThisWeek Food drink industry boss: Do not confuse ‘quality’ with ‘recipe’ in food debate
Christie backs Newarks Amazon bid with $7 billion in tax breaks
4 Insights on the future of data centers - Dataconomy
“Somalia blast victims ‘burned beyond reognition’
This small spot in NYC is serving up boozy #vegan milkshakes!
#Icelands best wildlife and where to find it by @egillegill
NEW: Trump forced to defend tax plan against criticism it benefits the rich
100-year-old from Napa County and his wife of 75 years among California wildfire victims
Trumps callous health care order will haunt the GOP in 2018
Trump was asked to explain his support for an anti-LGBTQ extremist. It didn’t go well.
Trump travel ban 3.0 hearing ends in Maryland qithout a ruling
#Live | From the South: #Portugal 145 wildfires, 30 people killed and more than 50 people injured from the flames.
One explanation for Fed Chair Yellen’s low inflation surprise is staring her in the face
Trump floats welfare crackdown: Some people are really taking advantage of our system
Trump claims Obama didnt call families of fallen soldiers, then walks back claim
Russias Putin signs decree imposing restrictions on North Korea
Deadline Expires for Striking #Avianca Pilots in Colombia
#Live | From the South: @JoanteleSUR regional parliament will hold the session on Wednesday.
Why are illustrations of mice in scientific papers so darn cute? @Neuro_Skeptic
Commerce secretary transferred $2 billion to family members after Trumps election: report
20% of Adult Men and Women are Chronic Procrastinators:
Workers should not just survive, we should thrive. And we will: #FightFor15
Tajikistan: Small-Time Debtors Detained, Larger Delinquents Get Away
Seattle has learned how to get more people to ride the bus, writes @asmall_word
#ThisWeek Guess who’s coming for dinner? Theresa May in Brussels today
#Live | From the South: @franciscatleSUR Pablo Neruda´s death investigation continues.
Nordstrom suspends buyout after struggling to get financing
Taylor impresses Trump for Fed chair, Warsh slips, sources say
This is why our campaign refuses corporate money. #iowaAF #ia03
thanks @thehill for letting david clarke write this you fucking assholes
Track What the Trump administration is saying about China
The Trump campaign has spent $1 million on lawyers in the last 3 months
.@TreborS discusses #PlatformCoops and the Digital #Commons:
#Live | From the South: Puerto Rico still waiting for help to get water and electricity.
Trump, McConnell show Republican unity at White House
Pentagon: Dozens of ISIS fighters killed in Yemen strikes
October sunset looking downtown over the new - $20B Hudson Yard, coming together
Microsoft Partners Up to Create First African Language Chat-Bot #Namibia
#Live | From the South: PM of Dominica @SkerritR stated that many schools are scheduled to reopen today.
Adobe warns that hackers are exploiting its Flash software
Miami congressional candidate claims she was visited by aliens.
Former Dem governor considering run for Corkers Senate seat
The Homeopathy Beliefs About Neonicotinoids And Honey
Madrid judge jails pro-independence Catalan leaders on possible charges of sedition
Zinc Lozenges May Triple Recovery Rate From Colds. By @AlexBerezow
The scary thing Hollywood does when it runs out of reboots
Ill take Headlines You Dont Want to See for $800, Alex
David Simon has something to say about “real America”
Panama Papers journalist killed by car bomb
San Francisco is suing major oil companies to protect its citizens from climate change
#Somalia: A broken state leads to hunger
California Officially Declares State Of Emergency Over Deadly Outbreak
#ThisWeek EU holds breath after Austrian vote
Dominicas @SkerritR reports on recovery effort after hurricane Maria
Russia withdraws its technological support to North Korea
Are Former Bank Executives Mnuchin And Cohn Encroaching On Regulator Turf? $
Netflixs Reed Hastings livens up earnings call by disappearing and returning in Stranger Things sweater. $NFLX
#Live | From the South: Latin-American leaders congratulate Venezuela for the democratic victory.
We have seen tragedies happen because of plastic: David Attenborough on Blue Planet 2
GOP donors being told Trump impeachment is likely if Dems win House
#Live | From the South: Venezuela´s regional elections in numbers.
#Live | From the South: Venezuela celebrates victory in the regional elections.
Judge OKs social media searches on potential jurors in Pilot Flying J rebate fraud case
@Ed_Crooks
The President is on top of it, now giving daily reminders...
The economist who helped wreck Kansas’ economy is Trump’s new budget cheerleader
Netflix adds more subscribers than expected, shares hit record
This gigantic titanosaur finally has a name of its own
Nordstrom family suspends attempt to take U.S. retailer private
The harvesting of Bolivias superfood, Quinoa #WorldFoodDay
#Peru’s Former Odebrecht Director Admits to Bribing Officials for Metro Work Contract
JUST IN: Senate confirms Callista Gingrich as Trumps ambassador to Vatican
TIL the US has run a trade surplus in plastics and plastic products since at least the 1990s
It was a busy quarter for deals in Fintech
Tune into #FromTheSouth news show now:
Central-bank chiefs prospects hinge on election of Abe as Japans prime minister
Not So Swell? Sibos Highlights Swifts Strained Relationship With Blockchain
When ETP Put/Call goes to 3 or above, since 06, clusters included. $spy h/t @hmeisler
Holocaust denier Ursula Haverbeck, 88, given six-month jail sentence
Trump joked Pence wants to hang all gay people: report
Securities-fraud case at Supreme Court may end through settlement
Airbus and Bombardier will become partners on the C Series aircraft program
Oil rig explodes in Louisiana 7 injured, 1 missing HT @backboneprog New Orleans
JUST IN: Airbus to acquire majority stake in Bombardiers C series, according to a statement
#Earthquake magnitude 4,2 - 117,5 km from #Puno - #Peru
Morten Morland on Theresa May visiting Brussels to revive Brexit negotiations - political cartoon gallery in Putney
#ThisWeek Varoufakis tells Macron to adopt the ‘empty-chair’ tactic
US Yield Curve at an expansion low: 76 bps. Dow Jones Industrial Average at an all-time high.
2020 is going to be interesting.
Trump to meet Yellen Thursday in search for new Fed chair: source
Firm that produced infamous Trump-Russia dossier wont comply with House Intel subpoena
Could you shape the way The Economist looks? Were hiring a graphic designer in London
#NotPretty
Twitters harassment problem is baked into its design, argues @debcha:
NRA spokeswoman says she’s moving due to death threats from gun control advocates
7 amazing aurora borealis videos for the beginning of northern lights season!
Kaepernick files greivance against NFL, citing collusion
Heres the passive ownership breakdown in US equities, global equities and fixed income/hybrid funds.
Florida governor declares state of emergency over Richard Spencer speech:
The top science and tech universities in America
But in some industries (especially defensive ones) ETFs are becoming a big factor. Heres the sectoral breakdown.
Oil rises 1% as Iraq fighting shuts output in Kirkuk via @Reuters
HelloFresh tells investors it will surpass Blue Apron in U.S.
But in some industries ETFs are a BIG factor, especially telecoms.
Related
Martin Fenlon merges architectural styles for house in Los Angeles:
If the goal is to decrease abortions then we shouldnt be fighting contraception
I see FANG lobbying is a growth business... FWIW - Yet another indicator of evolving sentiment.
US dollar up as selloff pauses, inflation in focus via @Reuters
Asias newest trillion-dollar economy faces a bittersweet win
Wall St. inches up with financials; earnings in focus
McConnell: Senate to vote on bill banning abortions after 20 weeks
Thwarted on GOP bill, Trump opts to tank the US health care system
Worse gridlock, more inequality? 3 ways self-driving cars could change cities
Some interesting new charts on active versus passive by Credit Suisse. First up, flows still one way...
Publics are generally divided on leaving governance to experts
U.S. not taking sides in Iraqi-Kurdish dispute: Trump
Miami congressional candidate claims she was visited by aliens
Portugal: Drone footage shows scale of destruction left by wildfires across central Portugal
Sunday in Harlem: where to find your soul food fix
For art collectors, Pres. Trumps tax plan paints a pretty picture
#ThisWeek Oyster flatulence worries climate scientists
Book Review: The Best Investment Writing, Volume 1 $
How a young German director documented illegal gold mining in #Ghana
Shock Over Attacks in Somali Capital #Somalia
RT @business: How one trader won big while everyone else panicked on Black Monday
Samburu Parents Marry Off Girls for Food as Hunger Bites: #Kenya
PHOTOS: Rwandan Fathers Joy Finding Daughter After 23 Years #Rwanda
Boko Haram Militants Surrender to Authorities in Cameroon: #Nigeria
#Russia Strengthens Ties to #Cuba as Trump Distances US from Castro Dictatorship
Robotics Summit heads to Boston next year -
Firm tied to Trump dossier objects to House panel subpoenas
Back to the Land - Friction As Exiles Return Home: #Somalia
More post-modernism from Kocic
Netflix is such a bargain at over 120x EV / EBITDA.
A Roundtable of Hackers Dissects the Season 3 Premiere of Mr. Robot
Trump is becoming a failed president
4/ In response to the request, the gov’t claimed Mar-a-Lago visitors logs didn’t really exist.
Could allegations of sexual harassment against Trump catch up with him?
Spain: Barcelona residents divided by Puigdemonts plea for more time
.@tsipras_eu meeting with IMFs @Lagarde gets underway in Washington DC
Horrors! Uber and Lyft are convenient, says @foxjust
Is Cameroon at War With Itself ? #Cameroon
Trump is coming for your birth control. Can states stop him?
Netflix shows its got the stuff to hook viewers
Indonesias president turns to private investment for the countrys needs
Harry Reid: Its very probable Dems will take back the Senate in 2018
Puerto Rico: Official Hurricane Death Toll at 48, Likely to Be Much Higher #puertoricorelief
Clinton breaks toe while running down stairs
Woman accusing Trump of misconduct subpoenas presidential campaign
Failings that sunk HMS Sheffield revealed after 35 years, reports @anguswalkertalk
Turkish spies may have infiltrated German authorities
Scientists uncover pictures of gravitational waves, reports @GeraintITV
Pennsylvania ObamaCare premiums will rise 30 percent after Trump cut subsidies
#Cuban military court sentences #US citizen to 13 years in prison for alleged espionage
Famed Chinese dissident: China and Russia are laughing at US under Trump
VERBATIM: ‘Other presidents did not call’ military families
Ara: Political prisoners.
#NewZealand Annual #Inflation at 1.9%
#NewZealand #Inflation Rate QoQ at 0.5%
China is building a mega-airport in Beijing that will open in 2019
Dozens die as wildfires ravage Portugal and Spain
Kyrgyzstan eyes peaceful transfer of power after poll
Lancaster California Is “Solar Power Capitol Of The Universe”
Colony Capital in talks to buy Weinstein Co
Malta anti-graft blogger killed in car bomb
Scientists discovered new genes that make humans intelligent
South African School Sexual Assault Disaster to Be Investigated #SouthAfrica
Harvey Weinstein, the entertainment industry, and the news media: A timeline of complicity
Trump attacks past sexual assault allegations against him as fake news
Trump reportedly joked about Pence wanting to “hang” all the gays
#NetizenReport: Free Speech Is Under Fire in Catalonia’s Push for Independence
Anti-corruption blogger killed by huge bomb in Malta
In pictures: The life of #HongKong’s shop #cats keeping their owners company at work
Trumps Puerto Rico failure is a national disgrace, says former Republican Joe Scarborough
There’s not much welfare left for Trump to reform ht @smencimer
France gave Weinstein its highest honor. @EmmanuelMacron says hes taking it back.
“It’s not going to happen in a day.”: A Mississippi town finally desegregates its schools
How a young German director documented illegal gold mining in #Ghana
Opinion: Hertha Berlins gesture is about the message by @JonBloggs66 #TakeAKnee
This is from July. EPAs given me way more evidence since I first did this story
#Ecuadorian Vice President Remains in Custody as Court Denies Habeas Corpus
This website will help you understand what its like to live below the poverty line:
This early bitcoin investor has some advice on how much money to hold in bitcoin
This is a surprising chart from Coca-Cola. $KO
Even China is tackling climate change, while US takes a back seat
Heres what you need to know this Monday:
The African Dictators
Looking forward to tonights chat with @coasttocoastam
The Northeast will endure its coldest night since last spring on Monday night:
Trump on stalled agenda: Im not going to blame myself
Trump Just Unleashed a Nasty New Lie About Barack Obama
What are they hiding? #health #food
Bank of America Revenue Growth, YoY: +1% Bank of America Stock Price, YoY: +67% $BAC
Drone Crashes Into Passenger Plane in Canada
Trump’s tax plan pitch isn’t working
Remembering Africas Che Guevara: #BurkinaFaso
Trump says he will look into drug czar pick following report
All the stuff you can do with iPhone 8 that you couldn’t with iPhone 7
Trump upbeat on bipartisan U.S. healthcare fix
#Honduras and Ecuador Agree to Deal Improving Economic Relations
Artist sets fire to bank in Paris
Commerce secretary transferred $2 billion to family members after Trumps election: report
How shipping containers are transforming housing for the homeless @melodyhahm
AP Top Stories October 16 P
Young American Socialists Ignore Venezuela
JP Morgan Revenue Growth, YoY: +3% JP Morgan Stock Price, YoY: +48% $JPM
Trump claims Obama didnt call families of fallen soldiers, then walks back claim
Citigroup Revenue Growth, YoY: +2% Citigroup Stock Price, YoY: +50% $C
Americans are giddy with optimism — bad news for Democrats
Why, oh why, can’t we have a decent stock bubble? -- WSJs Streetwise column via @jmackin2
Former Dem governor considering run for Corkers Senate seat
Nafta talks are reeling after the most aggressive proposals by the U.S. were delivered
Adobe warns that hackers are exploiting its Flash software
New (free) post: How American policy could tank #China
California governor vetoes bill that would have forced Trump to release tax returns:
Cassinis teaching us new things about Saturn from beyond the grave
Fearing an end to #NAFTA, #Mexico looks to Middle East for new trade partners
Tomorrows @guardian front page: assassination in Malta of leading Panama Papers journalist
How to Tell the Size of the Forming Top in U.S. Stocks
Trump repeats false claim that US is the highest taxed country in the world
.@JSchanzer explores the ramifications of ending Americas paralyzed Iran policy:
An overview of Africas main natural resources
What to know about hepatitis A as California outbreak triggers state of emergency
IBM is using blockchain tech to help businesses in countries with weak banking systems
Todays quote of the day honors @AlbertEinstein
Trump has a credibility problem on tax reform @rickjnewman
Panama Papers journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia killed in Malta car bomb blast
Trump Revives Notorious GOP Dog Whistle in Call for Welfare Reform
Our house just burned down—along with the rest of our Santa Rosa neighborhood
In search of tax win, Trump embraces McConnell
On this day in 1968, Jimi Hendrix released his third album Electric Ladyland
Exclusive: The number that explains @Snap’s new strategy
Fox Friends covered up giveaways for the super rich in Trumps tax plan:


Mike Shedlock

Mike "Mish" Shedlock is a registered investment advisor representative for SitkaPacific Capital Management. He operates the blog MISH'S Global Economic Trend Analysis and believes in the Austrian School of economics.


Are Banks Hoarding Cash? Debate Over “Free Money” Interest on Excess Reserves

4 months ago




In response to Free Money! Banks Paid $22 Billion to Not Lend? I received a comment from economist Professor George Selgin who said I do not know what I am talking about.

Selgin made similar comments about Chris Whalen, Chairman of Whalen Global Advisors LLC,  in two supporting links.

I also received a Tweet from economist Professor Steve Keen who said: “Mish Nails It“.

Both viewpoints cannot be right. Let’s explore competing viewpoints on lending excess reserves, banks hoarding cash, and free money banks receive from the Fed for interest on excess reserves.

Mish Statements

Excess reserves are a function of the Fed’s balance sheet and those reserves do not change whether a bank lends more or not.

There is no “demand” for excess reserves. Rather, the Fed has crammed excess reserves into the system and has decided to pay interest on them.

  1. Mathematically speaking, excess reserves cannot spur lending.
  2. Banks are not paid $22 billion to “not lend” $2.2 trillion as many contend.
  3. Banks are paid $22 billion because the Fed decided to do so.

Whether or not banks lend has nothing to do with interest on excess loans. Rather, the decision to pay interest on excess reserves is simply $22 billion in free money to banks every year, at taxpayer expense.

Steve Keen

Selgin: Interest on Reserves

In Interest On Reserves, Part II, Selgin writes.

Of the many bemusing chapters of the whole interest-on-reserves tragicomedy, none is more jaw-droppingly so than that in which the strategies’ apologists endeavored to show that paying interest on reserves did not, after all, discourage banks from lending, or contribute to the vast accumulation of excess reserves.

But let us set our befuddlement aside, in order to allow our authors to dispute the view that the vast post-IOR accumulation of excess reserves was evidence that the Fed’s emergency loans and asset purchases weren’t serving to “maintain” an adequate flow of credit:

To the contrary, the level of reserves in the banking system is almost entirely unaffected by bank lending. By virtue of simple accounting, transactions by one bank that reduce the amount of reserves it holds will necessarily be met with an equal increase in reserves held at other banks, and vice versa. As described in detail in a 2009 paper by New York Fed economists Todd Keister and James McAndrews, nearly all of the total quantity of reserves in the banking system is determined solely by the amount provided by Federal Reserve. Thus, the level of total reserves in the banking system is not an appropriate metric for the success of the Fed’s lending programs.

A gold star to all who spot the fallacy here. For those who can’t, it’s simple: “reserves” and “excess reserves” aren’t the same thing. Banks can’t collectively get rid of “reserves” by lending them — the reserves just get shifted around, exactly as Walter and Courtois suggest. But banks most certainly can get rid of excess reserves by lending them, because as banks acquire new assets, they also create new liabilities, including deposits. As the nominal quantity of deposits increases, so do banks’ required reserves. As required reserves increase, excess reserves decline correspondingly. It follows that an extraordinarily large quantity of excess reserves is proof, not only of a large supply of reserves, but of a heightened real demand for such, and of an equivalently reduced flow of credit.

IOER and Banks’ Demand for Reserves, Yet Again

Here are some Selgin snips from IOER and Banks’ Demand for Reserves, Yet Again.

In our recent American Banker opinion piece, Heritage’s Norbert Michel and I argue that, if the Fed is really serious about shrinking its balance sheet, it had better quit paying interest on banks’ excess reserves (IOER) as well. How come? Because the current, relatively high IOER rate is contributing to a strong overall demand for excess reserves, while a shrunken Fed balance sheet will mean a reduced supply of reserves. Reducing the supply of reserves while doing nothing to reduce banks’ demand for them is a recipe for demand-driven deflation, which is a monetary policy no-no.

Predictably (because it has happened every time I write on this topic) our article generated several comments to the effect that we didn’t know what we were talking about, because banks couldn’t possibly prefer the meager 100 basis points they can earn by holding reserves (or something less than that, if they are obliged to pay FDIC premiums) to the far greater amount they can earn by making loans.

The remarkable thing about these criticisms is that they all appear to deny that banks (or some banks, in any event) are in fact sitting on large amounts of excess reserves, and that they are, to that extent, settling for a return on those reserves of 100 basis points or less, instead of swapping  reserves for other assets.

Excess Reserves

Let’s take a step back and look at the definition of “Excess reserves“.

“In banking, excess reserves are bank reserves in excess of a reserve requirement set by a central bank.”

Required Reserves

The reserve requirement (or cash reserve ratio) is a central bank regulation employed by most, but not all, of the world’s central banks, that sets the minimum amount of reserves that must be held by a commercial bank. The minimum reserve is generally determined by the central bank to be no less than a specified percentage of the amount of deposit liabilities the commercial bank owes to its customers.

[in the US] Effective 27 December 1990, a liquidity ratio of zero has applied to CDs and time deposits [e.g. saving accounts], owned by entities other than households, and the Eurocurrency liabilities of depository institutions. Deposits owned by foreign corporations or governments are currently not subject to reserve requirements.

Canada, the UK, New Zealand, Australia, Sweden and Hong Kong have no reserve requirements.
This does not mean that banks can – even in theory – create money without limit. On the contrary, banks are constrained by capital requirements, which are arguably more important than reserve requirements even in countries that have reserve requirements.

Are Banks Slowly Lending Excess Reserves?

One might superficially conclude that banks are lending reserves by looking at the above chart, but here is what’s really happening:  In the process of lending, a portion of the loan gets redeposited in instruments that have reserve requirements.

In the process of lending, a portion of the loan gets redeposited in instruments that have reserve requirements.

Thus, my statement “reserves do not change whether a bank lends more or not,” is incorrect.

Everything else I stated is correct because reserves, excess or otherwise, do not enter into bank lending decisions.

BIS Statement

Please consider BIS Working Papers #292 Unconventional monetary policies: an appraisal, page 19.

In fact, the level of reserves hardly figures in banks’ lending decisions. The amount of credit outstanding is determined by banks’ willingness to supply loans, based on perceived risk-return trade-offs, and by the demand for those loans. The aggregate availability of bank reserves does not constrain the expansion directly.

By the same token,  an expansion of reserves in excess of any requirement does not give banks more resources to expand lending. It only changes the composition of liquid assets of the banking system. Given the very high substitutability between bank reserves and other government assets held for liquidity purposes, the impact can be marginal at best. This is true in both normal and also in stress conditions. Importantly, excess reserves do not represent idle resources nor should they be viewed as somehow undesired by banks (again, recall that our notion of excess refers to holdings above minimum requirements). When the opportunity cost of excess reserves is zero, either because they are remunerated at the policy rate or the latter reaches the zero lower bound, they simply represent a form of liquid asset for banks.

A striking recent illustration of the tenuous link between excess reserves and bank lending is the experience during the Bank of Japan’s “quantitative easing” policy in 2001-2006. Despite significant expansions in excess reserve balances, and the associated increase in base money, during the zero-interest rate policy, lending in the Japanese banking system did not increase robustly.

Bank Credit vs. Reserves

If anyone thinks, as Selgin has proposed, that lending will reduce excess reserves to where they were if only the Fed did not pay interest on reserves, they need explain the above chart.

Between July 2008 and May 2017, bank credit rose by $3.59 trillion. Required reserves rose by all of $134 billion. At that pace, bank credit would have to go up by about $50 trillion to shrink excess reserves back to where they were before QE started.

Does Rising Interest on Reserves Hurt Lending?

Selgin says the Fed needs to halt paying interest on excess reserves to spur lending. Curiously, bank credit rose over $900 billion as the Fed was hiking. If there is any slowdown in lending, it is due to the slowing economy or lack of good customers, not that the Fed is paying increasing amounts of money for excess reserves.

If there is any slowdown in lending, it is due to the slowing economy or lack of good customers, not that the Fed is paying increasing amounts of money for excess reserves.

Loans and Leases vs Reserves

Selgin used loans and leases in his links, so I provide the above alternative to bank credit. One can look at M2 to see similar things.

Banks Lend, That’s What They Do!

Bakers bake, painters paint, homebuilders build, and bankers lend. That’s what they do.

If banks are not capital impaired, and they believe they have a good credit risk who wants to borrow, they lend. In the process, required reserves rise by a tiny amount.

But it’s capital impairment and creditworthy customers that drive the lending process, not reserves.

Definition of Demand

Demand has a couple of meanings. In widespread use, demand is an imposition on someone (e.g. pay me or esle).

What Selgin refers to as demand is the “desire of banks to hold money”. He cites $2 trillion in excess reserves as “proof” of “demand”. The statement is silly.

Banks did not demand $2 trillion in the classic sense, nor are they hoarding money because the Fed pays interest on reserve. Rather, the Fed crammed $2 trillion into the system.

If banks had creditworthy customers willing to borrow, banks would lend. It’s what they do, and it is precisely what the charts I presented show. The reserve requirements on lending are so small they are meaningless.

Elimination of interest on excess reserves will not do anything for lending, However, I am in favor of eliminating interest payments. Giving banks free money at taxpayer expense is galling.

Mike “Mish” Shedlock