What happens when ice meets fire? Thats exactly what this geologist aims to find out:
#masseriadeivini on 9th Ave @CGasparino @KennyPolcari @tomkeene Amazing....
Deutsche Bank, Bank of America settle agency bond rigging lawsuits
#Update: Barcelona attack: At least 13 killed, dozens injured after van rams into crowd
Walmart is trying to out-Amazon Amazon
GOP lawmaker breaks with party, calls for Trump to fire Bannon
Obi Wan Kenobi Star Wars movies are in early stage development
iOS 11s new Cop button is a feature all phones should have
Dems propose law banning Confederate monuments on federal property
#Venezuelas latest prison riot turns into historic massacre, leaves at least 37 dead
America could use some “Car Talk” these days to help bridge our cultural divides.
DOE-funded study finds solar and wind power are literally life-saving
Trump’s tariffs would kill these American Jobs
Jose de San Martin, one of South Americas liberators died on this day in 1950.
Russia readies troops for Zapad war games with Belarus
Missouri state senator posts, deletes comment hoping for Trumps assassination
Yeah, Im going to pass
JUST IN: Second Kennedy Center honoree to boycott reception at Trump White House
Applied Materials beats profit estimates, shares rise
Trump cancels plans for infrastructure advisory council
Winding through the wilds: road-tripping #Norway’s west coast #EpicDrives
Trump to name GOP lawmaker head of NASA: report
What it’s like to have your anti-Trump art go mega-viral
.@megangarber on the supporting characters of Game of Thrones: lies
This guys never met a map he didnt want to fix #citylabarchive
Las Ramblas - Barcelona’s tourist magnet turned scene of terror
John Duarte is facing $2.8 million in fines from the EPA—just for plowing his own fields.
New Fintech Lenders Encroaching On Business Banking Turf
Australias no-win war on dual nationals, by @Moss_Eco
There is no comparison between white supremacists and Black Lives Matter
this should help take the edge off
Museum or dumpster? U.S. cities wrestle with Confederate statues fate
Is Donald Trump giving a voice to white supremacists?
In order for Medicare for All to be a viable option, we first have to make Medicare good.
Understanding Dimensionality Reduction and its Applications #DataScience
Opinion: Stop telling me to get over slavery - you first.
.@sebastianpinera said he may also visit #Caracas during #LatinAmerican tour
#ThisWeek Giant floating wind turbines installed off Scottish coast, in world first
Otherworldly adventures for aspiring astronauts by @TamaraSheward #travel
The growth strategy shared by Alibaba and Amazon @readkrystalhu
American Cancer Society cancels gala at Mar-a-Lago
August 17 Metals Commentary: Bob Iaccino
August 17 Energy Commentary: Bob Iaccino
Al Gore to Trump: You should resign
The @gp_sunrise has been seized. Here’s why: #PeoplevsArcticoil #SavetheArctic
#Starbucks founder Questions #US Moral Fiber #Charlotteville #news
Muslim group in Spain condemns #Barcelona van attack
Important things found in Antarctica this week: 91 volcanoes and also a fruitcake
How IS radicalizes teenagers using the internet
Pro-Trump rally to take place on same day as Juggalo March in DC
El Periódico: Horror in La Rambla.
#Gold: Strong technical resistance at $1,295 and $1,350 (Aug. 17, 2017)
La Razón: United against terrorism.
Reliable Perching Makes Fixed-Wing UAVs Much More Useful
Taylor Swift donates to assault victims group after groping win
Lawmakers Call for Firing of Trump Aides over White Supremacist Views
Dem lawmaker to introduce article of impeachment for Trump over Charlottesville
Heres what to do with the empty plinths of Confederate statues in Baltimore (or anywhere)
Tillerson dismisses Bannons claims of no military solution for North Korea
AP Top Stories August 17 P
A mattress: the reason Vice President of #Uruguay might have to resign. | via @PanAmPost_es
58 Insane Facts about #Bitcoin #fintech #blockchain @Paybefore
Meanwhile in Sweden....
#Greece launches new #oilandgas tender
Far-right extremism probe into elite German army unit opens
#BlackAugust | On this day in 1887, civil rights icon and Pan-African leader Marcus Garvey was born in Jamaica
Bill Ackman: ADPs share price can double by June 2021 @SallyPancakes
Opinion: Will smartphone games cause the tent pole franchises of movie studios to collapse?
Court overturns Exxon’s fines for major pipeline spill, calling it ‘regrettable’
Fed policy makers split over pace of rate hikes
Trumps Charlottesville remarks spark talk of staffers leaving
Italian lake goes all electric
Saudi coalition to blame for half of Yemen child casualties: draft U.N. report
Confederate monument to Jefferson Davis tarred and feathered
Why the military service chiefs are condemning white supremacy, from @ExumAM
Trump Justice Department in advanced stages of reviewing ATT-Time Warner merger: report
Off The Cuff: The End Of The Easy Money Era
The Macron series by @PaulineBock, #6: Macrons power struggle with the military
What is the Islamic State?
The ICT sector comprises 2% of global emissions – on par with the airline industry
WikiLeaks refused documents on Russian government during 2016 election: report
Confederacy capitalism in a graph –-livestock-to-be-milked-for-rent.html
Opinion: Wolf Warrior 2 is a Hollywood hero with Chinese characteristics
Why are Australias detention centres on Nauru and Manus Island still open?
Trinidad and Tobago says the country is too small to receive immigrants.
#icwa here with @suzyhans @gfeifer
Trump’s latest market whisperer is 19 years old
Aug 17, 1917 - Austrian soldiers grave, on the Italian Front #100yearsago
Traverse City: Its Wine Time!
Johnny Cash family slams white supremacist wearing his t-shirt
Journalist Suzy Hansen speaking about her new book, Notes on a Foreign Country. #ICWA
Meet drone dueling, the sport California is about to inadvertently kill
U.S. pension funds sue Goldman, JPMorgan, others over stock lending market
YouTube TV expands to 14 new markets, partners with Sinclair stations
Bitcoin bonds are the latest experiment in making money out of the digital currency
When white nationalists get DNA tests that reveal black ancestry, by @sarahzhang
The Future of Urban Transportation Is Sharing
Booker to introduce bill removing Confederate statues from the Capitol
Madrid to Manchester to Barcelona: A chronology of terror in Europe
Yellen should just say no if Trump wants to keep her on as Fed chief, ex-colleague says
Is the Norway-Sweden border a model for UK-Ireland?
Never disappoints
Chief FARC-Santos pact negotiator to run for President in #Colombia in 2018.
Karl Popper, Philosopher of Science and why we shouldnt tolerate fascists.
El Mundo: IS terror strikes Spain.
Did you visit this anti-Trump site? The US government w… , see more
New Yorker cover depicts Trump sailing with KKK
#LNG: Trade in #Japan- #Korea Marker swaps hits all-time high.
WATCH: Dem group puts Trumps Charlottesville remarks over video of white supremacist rally
This is pretty remarkable from @lucia_graves about the CEO of Sinclair
Trump drops plan to create infrastructure council: White House
$ES_F. Short term sell signal in force
GOP lawmaker breaks with party, calls for Trump to fire Bannon
American patriotism is actually a form of nationalism, says @suzyhans. #ICWA
The Market Forecast Commentary 08/17/2017 - Blake Young
Iran denies appeal of jailed Princeton student: university
Jose de San Martin, one of South Americas liberators died on this day in 1950.
As Dakota Access comes online, Americas most pipeline-constrained shale play sees new life
Two Sigma Risk Premia Strategy Keeping Its Head Just Above Water $
Is It Time For International Small-Cap? $
Barcelona terror attack: Leaders mourn victims
Indonesia’s 70th Independence Anniversary: greased pole climbing competition
The danger of embedding with white nationalists
How the President, the police, and the media embolden the far-right, @ckmarie reports
Cyber attack could cost Maersk US$300m! @Splash_247
Prudential is plotting its escape from Feds tough oversight
London clubs aglow with women wrestlers
Aussies suffer an electric shock that hurts like a rate increase
Dem bill would force Pentagon to change bases and streets named for Confederates
Casting the Brexit movie that is definitely real and will totally happen, by @natalia_bus10
Everything you need to make last-minute eclipse plans
Germany: Merkel advocates support for refugees at election campaign rally
.@suzyhans first moved to Turkey on an immersive two-year #ICWA fellowship and stayed for more than 10 years.
Politician who has called for a ban on Muslim immigration wears burqa in Australian senate
The Economist cover shows Trump using KKK hood as a megaphone
Maine governor: Removing Confederate statues is like taking down a 9/11 memorial
#Panama Balance of #Trade at PAB -1005.65M
Nuance vs Simple Messages
The trouble with a second Brexit referendum, by @georgeeaton
Want to learn a new language? With this AR app, just point and tap
British prime minister takes swipe at Trump: Leaders should always condemn fascists
Explosion At NYC Federal Building Leaves FBI Agent Injured
Democrats want Confederate statues removed from Capitol Hill, @fordm reports:
Banning transgender troops would cost 100 times more than letting them serve
#ThisWeek ‘You’re not welcome’: Tourismophobia spreads across Europe
Our own Ann Peters welcomes @suzyhans to @ICWAnews and the Pulitzer Center.
Heres what we know about the van attack in Barcelona so far. More:
Machining of silk fibers using femtosecond lasers
This is when #robots will start beating humans at every task: The machines are coming. @wef
At Least 3 Rangers Killed By Militia While Defending National Park in DRC: #DRC
Japan to install Aegis missile defence systems on land amid #NorthKorea crisis
Parliament Suspends Debate on Budget: #SouthSudan
ICC Orders Ex-Islamic Radical to Pay Damages for Destruction of Shrines: #Mali
Where to go in October for wildlife and nature: #travel
Is South Sudan Peace Possible Without Rebel Leader? #SouthSudan
Hague Court Issues Arrest Warrant for Libyan Commander #Libya
Change the World With a Single Click – Sign Our Petitions! #Petition #TakeAction #Resist
Bloomberg Benchmark podcast: Make America pay its bills. Again via @Moss_Eco @BChappatta
Creditor group wants to sue Sears executives, board
Walmart just sent a clear message about the future of Jet
Armed Group Likely Killed Investigators - UN: #DRC
Chinas yuan rebounds, set to snap four-day losing streak via @Reuters
Corker: Trump Hasnt Shown Stability, Competence
Atlantas planning department makeover
This mod makes GoldenEye 64 different every time you play
Van Plows into Crowd in #Barcelona; Police View it as #TerroristAttack #LasRamblas
So excited to be co-hosting @suzyhans with our partners at @ICWAnews to discuss her book Notes on a Foreign Country.
Murkowski and Sullivan say Trump’s handling of Charlottesville violence was wrong
Americas most prominent CEOs knew they had a problem well before Trumps Tuesday comments
Chinas making major progress with its aircraft carrier tech
ABC: Jihadism strikes Spain in Barcelona.
Trump to name GOP lawmaker head of NASA: report
SP 500 posts biggest decline in three months on Washington worries via @Reuters
Trump cancels plans for infrastructure advisory council
Fellow Republicans assail Trump after he defends Confederate monuments via @Reuters
Merkel, called traitor, defends refugee stance in rowdy east Germany
This is a take. Dont think theres much more to say, really.
Trump used to love destroying beautiful statues
Trump Adviser Katharine Gorka Helped Defund Anti-Hate Group #Charlottesville
IMAGES: Everything researchers are trying to learn about our sun: @NSF
A reminder that Burkina Faso and Nigeria suffered attacks this week. #Barcelona
Duterte’s war on drugs looks just like…war
Al Gore to Trump: You should resign
Canada sees unsustainable spike in asylum seekers at U.S. border
American Cancer Society cancels gala at Mar-a-Lago
Job, DIBS, pipe tobacco. Avant-garde poster by Noel Fontanet 1932.
The 3-Step Argument the Left Makes to Justify Violence Against Conservative Speakers
#Germany strongly condemns brutal @NicolasMaduro regime in #Venezuela
Poll: 40 percent say Trump should be impeached
New research could help reveal who is buying online trafficking ads #bitcoin @UCBerkeley
The Sun: Barcelona Bastards.
@nickrkm This is a great detail.
#DonaldTrump again cites dubious #Muslim execution story after #Spain attack
Delicate hand-sewn lace figures are harmoniously fused to real pieces of found wood
What will Kim do next? Sixth nuclear test seen as critical for North Korea.
Markets Roiled as Tension Mounts Over Trump Stance: Markets Wrap - BBG
Bolivarian candidates for Venezuelas regional elections speak
CNN political director: Trump is desperate for an enemy
Reformist Members of Irans Parliament Push to Free Green Movt Leaders Under House Arrest
Trumps Charlottesville remarks spark talk of staffers leaving
.@TheEconomist’s Trump-KKK cover pulls no punches, and neither does the story
6 surprising foods that stain teeth plus 6 that will clean and whiten them
Two men arrested over Barcelona attack were not the van drivers: police.
Becoming a benefit corporation is complicated, so the startup @clerkyinc wants to help:
Reliable Perching Makes Fixed-Wing UAVs Much More Useful
“Let’s kill another 32 every day. Maybe we can reduce what ails this country.” #Philippines
Missouri state senator posts, deletes comment hoping for Trumps assassination
amazing analysis from CNN
This Containerized Solution Brings Clean Water Solar Power To Remote Areas
Alibaba, Tencent and China’s fast growing ecommerce economy
The NS Leader: Trumps dangerous nation
Unplugging is nearly impossible now; by 2026 it will be even tougher, experts predict
JUST IN: Dems propose law banning Confederate monuments on federal property
The Canadian Housing Market is Bananas: by @awealthofcs $EWC #ToRE #VanRE
POLL: 40% of Americans now say they want Trump impeached
CMOs top 8 martech stories for the week - 17 August 2017
FDA approves Pfizers drug for rare blood cancer
Hong Kong fitness instructor falls to death from 12th-floor railings
Two people arrested, 80 injured after Barcelona van attack: Catalan head
Of course, all our plastic crap ends up in the Arctic
Japan posted a trade surplus for another straight month in July
We follow a group of Afghan women who have signed up to fight the Taliban and ISIL
SP 500 posts biggest decline in three months on Washington worries:
Alibabas mobile engagement is exploding thanks to AI @readkrystalhu $BABA
Pro-Trump rally to take place on same day as Juggalo March in DC
What is a personal racist?
Dem lawmaker to introduce article of impeachment for Trump over Charlottesville
Some college kids found $5,000 NASA flight suits at a thrift store:
#MexicoCity Governor claims city is safe, but numbers dont lie. | via @PanAmPost_es
‘Deep’ Subprime Car Loan Delinquencies Highest Since 2007 (As Auto Dealer Offer Bad…
US vows ‘immediate and specific action’ to intercept North Korean missiles fired at allies
North Korea tells UN chief nuclear programme not up for negotiation
Transformation of the Electric Grid
#Venezuela announces end to military trials for protesters.
GMO: latest 7 year forecast
President Trump responds to the Barcelona terror attack by spreading a debunked rumor
NEW: Trump fans the flames with defense of Confederate statues
Is #Trump going to war in #Venezuela?
8 steps to justice #AlMahdi #reparations 17 August #Mali #Timbuktu
Catalan police official says there is no evidence that there will be another attack. More:
New American oil tankers are great for traders... but lousy for owners
Polish government moves to rein in demands for WWII reparations from Germany
Blowhard -- The cover of next weeks @NewYorker magazine.

Mike Shedlock

Mike "Mish" Shedlock is a registered investment advisor representative for SitkaPacific Capital Management. He operates the blog MISH'S Global Economic Trend Analysis and believes in the Austrian School of economics.

Productivity Measurement is Totally “FUBAR” Yet Certainly Overstated

8 days ago

The BLS report on preliminary Productivity and Costs, Second Quarter 2017 shows nonfarm business productivity increased 0.9 percent during the second quarter of 2017.

Productivity is defined as “real” inflation-adjusted output divided by aggregate hours worked.

The quarterly number is very good, but revisions were massive and the overall trend is dismal. More importantly, the measurement is FUBAR. First, let’s dive into the report.

Labor Productivity and Unit Costs

Supposedly, the charts are seasonally adjusted, but the second chart on unit labor costs suggests something is seriously wrong. Alternatively, or additionally, there are lots of data-gathering flaws.


In regards to the possibility of data gathering flaws, let’s consider real hourly compensation revisions.

Year-Over-Year Productivity – Real Output Per Hour

The last time year-over-year productivity was up by more than 2.0% was nearly seven years ago!

I downloaded the above data all the way back to 1948 to calculate a long term trend.

Productivity Trend 1948-Present

Spotlight 2016

In 2016, productivity was -0.3% in the first quarter, -0.4% in the second quarter, -0.1% in third quarter and +0.8% in the fourth quarter.

THe BLS notes “Annual Average productivity growth in the nonfarm business sector in 2016 was revised down to a decrease of 0.1 percent.”

This was the first annual productivity decline since 1982.

Productivity Understated?

A Spring 2016 Brookings study asked Is Productivity Slowing or Are We Just Measuring It Wrong?

Here is the Brooking’s conclusion: “Productivity Slowdown is Structural, not a Measurement Problem”.

A Vox report says Productivity is Understated Due to Offshore Profits.

US multinational enterprises may legally shift profits from high tax countries (like the US) to low tax countries (like Bermuda). This column uses unpublished survey data to show how this causes part of the US economic activity generated by these multinational enterprises to be attributed to their overseas affiliates, leading to an understatement of measured US GDP and, in turn, productivity. Profit-shifting activity has increased significantly since the mid-1990s, resulting in an understatement of the growth rate of US productivity.

Lost in the Debate

Before one can measure productivity, one needs to accurately measure hours worked and real output.

Real output implies an accurate measurement of inflation. The term “real” means “inflation-adjusted”.

My Take – Productivity Measurement is Totally “FUBAR”

    • Hours worked are understated. Because of cell phones and the internet, people work countless unreported hours, even on vacation. Those are hours worked, but neither counted nor paid.
    • At the supervisory level, there is pressure on non-hourly workers to put in more store hours. Think Target, WalMart, McDonald’s everywhere. Supervisors do put in those hours (or they do not advance), and those hours go uncounted.
    • Pressure builds on truckers to make increasingly difficult (timewise) deliveries. This results in changes in trucker logs to keep truckers driving past the statutory limit of 11 hours. Those hours do not count either.
    • Illegal aliens work for less. Home builders and repair crews of all kinds pay illegal aliens less than US citizens. Those wages may or may be reported, but the output (a completed home), is.
    • On the inflation front, the only way one can calculate “real” output or “real” wages is to first calculate inflation. If inflation is understated, even by a minuscule amount, the error changes productivity measurements dramatically.
    • Inflation measurements do not include asset bubbles or even home prices. Rather, the BLS uses Owners Equivalent Rent (OER) as a substitute for home prices. OER alone dramatically skews inflation, sometimes to the high side, but mostly lower.

Totally “FUBAR” Yet Certainly Overstated (Short Synopsis)

Productivity is measured by taking an artificially high estimate of “real” output divided by an underreporting of hours worked.

  • On one hand, we have countless unreported hours worked. This acts to overstate productivity.
  • On the other hand, inflation measurements are complete nonsense. “Real” output is much lower than reported because inflation is understated. This also overstates productivity.

Despite two artificial boots, the productivity trend still heads lower! Thank the inflation tactics of central banks.

Related Articles

  1. August 7: Fed’s Discontinues Labor Market Index 
  2. August 3: Central Banks Puzzled as Global Inflation Hits Lowest Level Since 2009: Solving the Puzzle
  3. August 2: “Idiosyncratic and Transitory Factors” Holding Down Inflation: New Definition of Transitory
  4. August 6: Median Price-to-Revenue Ratio Higher in All Deciles vs 2007, 90% vs Dot-Com Bubble: THE Choice
  5. August 7: Tracking the Amazing Junk Bond Bubbles in the US and Europe

Point 1 discusses Janet Yellen’s preferred measure of labor, was quickly discarded because it did not show what it was expected to show.

Points 2 and 3 discuss the Fed’s puzzlement over inflation. Here’s a hint: They do not know how to measure it.

Points 4 and 5 discuss measures of inflation the Fed does not count, but should.

Mike “Mish” Shedlock